5 ms·
So, this is a really cool concept and I look forward to the determination if it is true or testable. I find the "double copy of other forces" verbiage to be di
by tomrod 6y ago
So, this is a really cool concept and I look forward to the determination if it is true or testable.
I find the "double copy of other forces" verbiage to be difficult to follow. Walking through a formula example would be helpful, and formaluae exist to communicate exactly this kind of clumpy-wumpy-lumpy-timey-wimey awkwardness language clods through in its quest to communicate mathematical structures.
- canadianfella 6y ago>clumpy-wumpy-lumpy-timey-wimey What the heck is this?
- alanbernstein 6y agoThis is my complaint about most of what I read about advanced physics. I have enough understanding of math and basic physics that it seems within reach for me to follow an equation-driven explanation, but the papers are a bit too dense for me. And I suppose I'm not interested enough to invest the time to truly understand all of the notation.
- pishpash 6y agoTheoretical physicists are handwavy a.f. to an extent that you can't tell a crank from a real one.
- ssivark 6y ago(Passing comment from a phone, so forgive the brevity.) The key predictions one typically calculates using quantum field theory are scattering amplitudes. Let’s consider both gravity and one of the other forces in the “weak”/perturbative limit — flat space time and force carriers as (quasi)particles Eg: photons, gluons, etc. Now let’s compare the algebraic expressions for the scattering amplitude in both cases (final answer after pages of calculations). For gluons it turns out there is one piece due to how the gluons are moving when they collide (kinematic piece), multiplied by another piece for the charge they carry (aka color); surprisingly the two pieces have a somewhat similar form if you squint (called “color kinematics duality”). Also gluons are spin-1. Now, gravitons don’t carry charge, but they’re spin-2. If you look at the algebraic expression for the amplitude of scattering gravitons (after a much more tedious calculation) — lo and behold — it looks like it just has kinematic-like piece multiplied twice! (and no color piece.) This is what is commonly referred to as “double copy” (of kinematic term) or “gravity = gauge (force) squared”. This is one of the seminal papers; it’s very short, and has very few equations (but they’re written in a very abstract form) — feel free to stare at them if you like: https://arxiv.org/abs/1004.0476 https://arxiv.org/abs/1004.0476
- naikrovek 6y agoso "double copy" means "squared". no wonder no one can follow any of this. they intentionally obfuscate everything.
- jiggawatts 6y agoThat's a general problem caused by "Publish or perish". Essentially, we've incentivised intellectual wankery. Contrast this to any field of engineering: intelligibility is selected for by market forces. Obscure, hard to follow stuff is slowly (but surely) weeded out in favour of the clear and simple. In the more theoretical sciences, that's just not a goal. Quite the contrary: The goal is to make the published papers look impressive. More jargon, more complex equations, fewer diagrams, all help achieve this goal.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ssivark 6y agoNo, “square” is the more crude analogy (there’s a lot more to “multiplication” than you might be familiar with in the case of numbers), and “double copy” is more natural. Don’t ask for a simpler explanation because the actual story is not yet well understood — after all it’s active research, so scientists are still groping in the dark trying to figure things out! Nobody is trying to intentionally obfuscate anything; the authors working in this area deserve tremendous credit for their sincere and sustained (decade+) effort in trying to elucidate the structure of gravitational interactions. Please don’t go around slandering them just because you don’t understand what’s going on.
- suifbwish 6y agoNo one is cast doubt on their work; we are saying their choice of terminology SUCKS.
- suifbwish 6y agoAgree. They might as well have included the phrase “super duper” in the title to sound a bit more scientific.
- dmix 6y agoThere's a ton of articles about this on every science news site and youtube channel. Here's an old one for example that explains what they are doing at Fermi wit the G-2 machine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4Ko7NW2yQo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4Ko7NW2yQo And just check the science sites.
- wrycoder 6y agoYour link is unrelated to the topic. Do you have something pertinent to gravity "double cover" work?
- wrycoder 6y agoCharlie Wood is no Natalie Wolchover. The article is depressingly simplistic - it's something I'd expect from Science Alert, not Quanta. I looked for a better entry into the subject and found this: https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.08183 https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.08183 And a longer review article: https://arxiv.org/abs/2003.12528 https://arxiv.org/abs/2003.12528
- wrycoder 6y agoAnd a later review article, 38 pages: https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.16441 https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.16441
- suifbwish 6y agoIf we find out we are living in a simulation it would be rather arbitrary to have a force that does not unify with the others. Consider buggy game physics and trying to harmoniously explain how those forces work together without knowledge of the fact it is a simulation with global variables, nodes, data corruption events ect
- xwolfi 6y agoWe only leave in a simulation at the first level, but the thing running the simulation live in a world with rules too and they must influence the shape of the simulator. Saying God created the world or the universe is a simulation is as dissatisfying a response as saying humans were made on Earth. Sure why not but what made it, did it start, will it end, how does it work at the most fundamental level? How does God's processing of information actually works ? That s what we must understand, up to the end.
- snet0 6y agoWorlds don't have to have rules. That's just how ours is.
- suifbwish 6y agoIf we discovered we were in a simulation, it would almost certainly mean there are more layers of simulation containing those. With each layer of simulations, the chances that we are perceiving any actual real world physics patterns drops close to zero. If there were a simulation, it would likely be the first lifeform trying to protect itself in some way , which would suggest that the simulations are there to allow the lifeform to experience virtual death and reset.. It may be that whatever built the simulation is trying to hide from the fact that it is the only being in existence.