4 ms·
My lizard brain reads your comment as "What? Apple do good things? No! Apple bad! All things you say are good about apple are actually bad. You'll see, because
by josephg 6y ago
My lizard brain reads your comment as "What? Apple do good things? No! Apple bad! All things you say are good about apple are actually bad. You'll see, because apple is bad!"
You can make tribal cynicism sound clever if you use complex enough arguments, and rely on enough obscure details. "Peh, Apple didn't give the world LLVM. They bought it out and made Chris Lattner into a sellout." But you have to heavily filter reality if you want to do this. And its suspicious when anyone hunts so hard for a particular conclusion. I mean, would LLVM be as successful without Apple? No. Did Apple fund LLVM massively? Yes. Did Apple opensource LLVM? Yeah; they did. But so what? There's a proprietary llvm binary shipped with xcode; therefore proof that apple is Machiavellian and evil? Therefore proof Apple is good and can do no wrong? No! Its complicated.
Trying to simplify the world into good guys and bad guys isn't clever. Its childish and boring; and it gets in the way of having the real adult conversation, where we look at the imperfect world as it actually exists and decide what we want. Not "Apple bad" but "Apple makes great products, and free markets are good. And the app review process is great. But on balance it would still be better for the economy as a whole if the app store had real competition - even if that would probably be worse for many iphone customers."
You can spot the people who think this way easily, because when you talk to them about stuff like this they sigh and name the ways in which their favorite solution would make some things worse. "Yeah, FB is probably terrible for our society. But also FB really does connect people in meaningful ways. I don't know how we would keep the good aspects of free market innovation and social media's shrinking of the world while also softening its negative effects on teenagers. But there have to be some real answers here. Maybe XXX".
My challenge to you is this: Name some things you respect about the "other team" (apple or whoever). What would you would do if you were king for a day, and have the power to pass any laws you want? How would you fix the ills you see in the world? What are the ways your fixes might backfire?
- smoldesu 6y agoI'll indulge you. I respect Apple's dedication to to having a single unified experience across all of your devices. I'm glad they switched to a Unix-based operating system instead of the garbage that powered their previous machines. I think the Quartz window manager is one the most impressively designed pieces of contemporary software, and I'd kill someone for the chance to look at the source code. My "King for a Day" changes at Apple would probably include pausing their ARM transition, potentially to use ARM and x86 as a differentiator between their "Air" and "Pro" lines, respectively. The patents for the latter ISA are expiring this year, meaning that Apple would be well withing their legal rights to sell a chip with all of the battery optimization of the 5nm node while also supplying a more complete and standard instruction set. I would stop the chase to "make the computer disappear" and instead seek to make the computer functionally seamless. The dedication to making thinner devices is sabotaging their lifespan and usability. Plenty of other machines opt to add extra room to accommodate for a better keyboard, better webcam or more ports, and I gotta say I prefer it. I'd much rather carry around my 5 year old Thinkpad than my M1 Macbook Air, if solely for the reason that the former has RJ45 and SD card slots. I don't really see any way that it could backfire, though I'm sure abandoning the M1 devices would cause a little initial friction. Apple could easily cart out a new "L1" chip that ships as an APU with the M1's CPU and GPU architecture onboard. Once people see that it's just as fast (if not faster for industry applications), people won't care. In closing, I don't think Apple is the bad guy. But I'm far from convinced that they're the good guy, or even a morally grey participant. Their historic greed and botched engineering continues to make a mockery of their legacy, and it's a shame when many of the engineers involved are genuinely talented people. If Apple wants my respect, they should respect the input of the open source community trying to make package managers with Apple-level integration, or the right to repair community who's trying to make sure that the Mac lives as long as it can.