4 ms·
Why do you only care about your descendants, and not anyone else. We could create a society where everyone in the next generation benefits from the wealth that
by nicoburns 6y ago
Why do you only care about your descendants, and not anyone else. We could create a society where everyone in the next generation benefits from the wealth that everyone in the current generation creates. Is that not a much more worthy goal to strive for?
- anotha1 6y agoMuch. The parent comment reads like a mix of severely lacking empathy and selfish grandiosity. This guy would probably also agree he should have 500+ kids to spread his blessed seed to the world.
- listenallyall 6y agoRight, because confiscating wealth from those that earned it, has worked so well across the civilizations and societies that tried it.
- anoncake 6y agoIt has and it's called taxation. And taxing people who have not earned their wealth, using inheritance taxes, is even better.
- listenallyall 6y agoThe United States taxes its citizens in many, many ways... income tax, payroll tax, capital gains tax, sales tax, gasoline tax, liquor tax, inheritance tax, many more. If taxation "benefits" all future citizens, as described by the OP above, then the U.S. would cheer on its billionaires, they would be the heroes of all children because they would be providing almost all of the benefits! Funny that it doesn't work like that in real life...
- anoncake 6y agoNo, billionaires didn't earn their wealth. And paying your taxes is the bare minimum, it doesn't make you a hero.
- altusbrown 6y agoDo you think Amazon would just exist if Bezos didn't do what he did? Do you think groups of people spontaneously collect in ways that produce more value than they cost to exist? Even if there is no way to benefit from it individually at scale? If you do, I can understand where you are coming from - it doesn't line up at all with my experience or extensive datasets I have, but I'd understand it. If that can't just happen, then how did he not earn it?
- CRConrad 6y ago> Do you think Amazon would just exist if Bezos didn't do what he did? Something else very similar would probably exist. And in that universe, people would probably go "Do you think DeNile would just exist if Ben Jeffries didn't do what he did?".
- altusbrown 6y agoBased on your comment, I'm assuming you would expect them to be led by someone doing the same things - which just highlights the role doesn't?
- CRConrad 6y agoYes, indeed: It highlights that it's a "role" that pretty much anyone could have filled if it hadn't happened to be Bezos that did. And since discussion about compensation on this site usually centers around the ubiquity of potential fillers of roles -- "Amazon warehouse workers are paid shit because anyone can be an Amazon warehouse worker!" -- it also shows that Bezos' humongous windfall for more or less at random fulfilling this not so much more unique role is monumentally inequitable. Hopefully that was what you set out to highlight?
- anoncake 6y agoI'm not saying Bezos didn't earn anything. But not billions.
- altusbrown 6y agoTaxation is not confiscation, unless the taxation is punitively high. I'd argue it would likely need to be 100% to meet the common usage of it. The more you tax, the closer you get to banning or stopping activity. If a government sets a tax rate of 100% at say a certain threshold, it would be a poor planner that would be earning anything in that category no?
- anoncake 6y agoThat's an artificial distinction. There is no sharp line between "punitive taxes" and just taxes.
- altusbrown 6y agoNo sharp line, but hardly artificial. If someone gives you a cake, and I take the whole cake it's clearly confiscation no? You got no cake at the end. If someone gives you a cake and I take a slice (say 25%), then it is clearly not confiscation, since you got cake correct? Not only that, you got most of it.
- anoncake 6y agoDepending on who you are and why you took my cake, it could be a tax, confiscation, theft, a fine...
- CyberRabbi 6y agoI care about other people but I care about my family more. I couldn’t tell you why, I just do, it’s my instinct. I don’t believe in utopias nor do I commit myself to what other people consider “worthy” goals, this is not a popularity contest for me, it’s about survival.
- anotha1 6y agoLike cancer, individual (cell) reproduction without consideration for the group (organism). We all know how cancer ends... Hopefully, you'll soon recognize the value (and even beauty) of senescence (Steve Jobs did) and not commit our future generations to a slow painful death. If not, your kids might also appreciate an opportunity to prove themselves, and just not ride your coattails. Even if not, after you're gone no one will praise them without an asterisk. But hey, who doesn't still envy the life of a trust fund kid. Smoking weed and buying Supreme® crap your whole life doesn't seem that bad?
- CyberRabbi 6y agoMy descendants will never need to be preoccupied with proving themselves to anyone, especially people who might otherwise compare them to cancer cells. Praise from others serves no useful or necessary function when they prosper regardless.
- altusbrown 6y agoPretty impressive projection and pompousness you have there. Fundamentally, society is a mutual agreement of individuals. Those individuals have needs. If someone feels a need to provide for their children - which could include perhaps being able to afford a good education without putting themselves in debt - and they're willing to work and save for it (which is fundamentally where most inheritances come from at some level) rather than blow it on cocaine or give it away to strangers, why not?
- userulluipeste 6y ago"I care about my family more. I couldn’t tell you why, I just do, it’s my instinct." Let me rationalize that for you. In order to keep yourself at a functioning level you have to see some good in yourself, to be able to respect yourself, and in that line of thinking - to trust that your physical base has enough value to be preserved long term in the genetic pool. You also have to see the same kind of value in the person you associated yourself with (i.e. your wife), and consequently - in the resulting lineage. Anything less is just prone to higher risk in the natural selection game. "I don’t believe in utopias nor do I commit myself to what other people consider «worthy» goals, this is not a popularity contest for me, it’s about survival." Not believing in utopia is one thing but, unless you're a nihilist or think we're at the end of times, you surely have to believe that the world can be made better and maybe do something about it. That's part of caring for the same descendants that will have to live in the world you'll leave them to. In consequence, the fact that you say you don't commit to other people's goals could mean that (A) it's because you don't share any views with other people out there on what would make the world better, which is very unlikely, or (B) you care and can afford to contribute but you just rely on the fact that others' effort will be enough and you can focus on more personal gains (which attracts contempt, and rightly so), or (C) you share the concerns and maybe even the goals for common problems but can not afford to do anything due to some limits in your life, like if you're in a war zone and can care only for physiological (Maslow scale) needs. It's hard to believe that you'd be in condition C, but then you actually say that it's about survival...