2 ms·
While the article goes for tongue-in-cheek, it brings up an important point. Pedagogy is important. And pedagogy can get stuck. "Electromagnetism" is a good
by bsder 6y ago
While the article goes for tongue-in-cheek, it brings up an important point.
Pedagogy is important. And pedagogy can get stuck.
"Electromagnetism" is a good example. We still learn the Heaviside-Hertz formalisms which are based around an "ether". Why?--Because they work and you can calculate a lot of simple systems by hand. This helps A) develop intuition and B) generate calculations which approximate more complex systems.
However, once you start trying to do motors and capacitors and stuff--things get weird (starting with "displacement current"). At that point, the fields formulations tend to work much better (See: "Collective Electrodynamics" by Carver Mead). However, your calculations take a jump in complexity that you didn't have to deal with before--your linear algebra and vector analysis better be pretty solid. However, dealing with motors and coupled fields and stuff gets much easier.
- noir_lord 6y agoNot unusual, we still mostly use Newtonian physics even though we know it's only an approximate solution because the math comes out close enough until you get in the realm where you are talking decent fractions of C. I mean Newtonian methods put is on the moon so they are good enough for a lot of cases. Something as 'simple' as inertia looks very different once you step from Newtonian/special to general relativity.