2 ms·
The whole lore is undoubtedly nihilist, because it started in times and places where nihilism was a survival mechanism: Thatcher was gutting half of England, nu
by toyg 6y ago
The whole lore is undoubtedly nihilist, because it started in times and places where nihilism was a survival mechanism: Thatcher was gutting half of England, nuclear holocaust was on the card, greed was celebrated, and for many it felt there was no escape from a very grim future. Games Workshop took the “heavy metal” way out: everything should be grotesque and excessive, the “men in charge” are all equally bad, what matters is cool equipment.
Instead of criticizing something that helped people endure that time, maybe you should ask yourself why its popularity ebbs and flows but is still so attractive to so many. Maybe we do have to choose between following equally-terrible people, every day? Maybe we still feel powerless to stop never-ending conflicts? And maybe we just like doing cool shit for the hell of it.
- weregiraffe 6y ago>Maybe we do have to choose between following equally-terrible people, every day? Well, okay, but there are a lot of games where you can choose between good and bad sides. You know, like most of DnD. It's Warhammer 40k specifically that forces you to choose between bad, worse and worst.
- toyg 6y agoAnd? You are saying every game should have some “good guys”, because…? There are plenty of movies and books without “good guys”, so it’s reasonable there should be games too. After all, this situation is often closer to reality than the manichean “one side is Right” mindset, and actually spurs critical analysis of everyday situations more than the usual mindless “kill the Nazis”.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> There are plenty of movies and books without “good guys” There are very few, and fewer with any success (though, to be fair, not quite none), that don’t have any not irredeemably evil guys, which seems to be the issue people raise with WH40K.