3 ms·
I'm no expert, but I thought that Einstein was pointing out the flaws of the Copanhagen interpretation of quantum physics. Sean Carrol gave a talk about his ne
by ZeroGravitas 6y ago
I'm no expert, but I thought that Einstein was pointing out the flaws of the Copanhagen interpretation of quantum physics.
Sean Carrol gave a talk about his new book and his claim is that quantum mechanics is pretty straightforward, and all the spooky weirdness is only needed if you try to ignore the implication that the data supports the-many world interpretation.
https://youtu.be/F6FR08VylO4 https://youtu.be/F6FR08VylO4
i.e. similar to the sock example given, when you open the envelope you find out what universe you are in, the blue sock or red sock universe and that tells you information about the other sock in your universe. But another you is finding the other color sock in a different universe.
- jiggawatts 6y agoBut physics is so much more mysterious if everybody carefully refuses to acknowledge the mere existence of the clear and obvious answer.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoMWI people keep making these strong claims and ignoring the very credible criticism of them. https://www.quantamagazine.org/why-the-many-worlds-interpretation-of-quantum-mechanics-has-many-problems-20181018/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/why-the-many-worlds-interpret...
- ZeroGravitas 6y agoThat's a very philosophical rather than physics-based rebuttal. He appears to be saying it can't be true because it would make life/and or the concept of self meaningless. Whereas I would say that a theory that suggests we are meaningless temporary blips in an infinite universe is probably a much greater indication that it is true than otherwise.
- fsh 6y agoMost interpretations of QM make identical predictions for the outcome of any possible experiment. This makes the field fundamentally philosophical rather than scientific.
- AgentME 6y agoI previously found this article and wrote a bunch of notes about it that I never got around to posting before. It was too long to be an HN comment so I've just cleaned it up and posted it here: https://macil.tech/2021/05/09/bad-mwi-criticism/ https://macil.tech/2021/05/09/bad-mwi-criticism/. I'm not a big fan of the article, it mostly just defines self in a nonsense way and then treats it as a contradiction with MWI despite also laying out more sensible answers.