2 ms·
To be fair, it seems that that blog post and the Quora responses are older than her book, where she clarified her position significantly more, though your claim
by tsimionescu 6y ago
To be fair, it seems that that blog post and the Quora responses are older than her book, where she clarified her position significantly more, though your claim about the majority of particle physicists disagreeing with her is likely still correct.
The important difference between now and when the answer was written is that she has given her own alternatives: she believes that only theories that resolve an explicit contradiction or open problem in current physics should be considered, such as quantum gravity or dark matter or the measurement problem; while theories that simply fix 'ugliness' should be ignored, such as grand unification.
Furthermore, she believes that theories with open parameters whose range exceeds possible near future possible colliders should not be tested, even if the lower bounds on the parameter could be testable - this is true for supersimmetry or WIMPs. Since ruling out supersimmetry entirely requires a planet-sized accelerator, there's no reason to keep building slightly larger ones just in case.
Finally, she makes a concrete recommendation: shifting focus to astronomy as a better way to observe high energy particle physics occurring in the universe, investing in much more advanced telescopes instead of bigger particle colliders.
- irthomasthomas 6y ago" she makes a concrete recommendation: shifting focus to astronomy as a better way to observe high energy particle physics " Each starlink launch makes this task harder and more expensive. They have chosen a military satellite grid over scientific research :(
- ghusbands 6y agoInside the atmosphere is a terrible place to use telescopes, anyway, so we should use those launches to also get more telescopes into space.
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoThis is overly simplistic. Adaptive optics solves a lot atmospheric issues. There are also entire categories of telescopes that it simply makes more sense to keep on earth. Space telescopes are cool and all, but making a space version of something isn't necessarily better, even in a future with rapidly declining launch costs.