4 ms·
It's worth noting, when reading the great philosophers of that era and earlier, how static their world was. When Hume was writing, steam engines barely worked a
by Animats 6y ago
It's worth noting, when reading the great philosophers of that era and earlier, how static their world was. When Hume was writing, steam engines barely worked and the American Revolution hadn't happened yet. GDP growth was a few percent per century. Most people did not see the world change much in their lifetime.
- chmod600 6y agoInteresting point. If deciding whether to advocate for change or not, and you don't see much evidence that change actually happens (and/or works), that would certianly bias someone toward conservatism.
- golemiprague 6y agoOr you could derive the exact opposite conclusion, advocating for change since it hardly ever happens so we would like to have more of it. Anyway, the arguments today are not necessarily about change but rather about what kind of change. Which I suspect was always the case, conservatism or progressivism are just team names, exactly like democrats and republicans. In Australia the liberals are the right wing party, it is just a label.
- keiferski 6y agoThis might be true for Western Europe in the (early) 18th century, but it’s certainly not true of most of the rest of the world historically.
- sbierwagen 6y agoDo you have examples of other parts of the world that experienced double digit GDP growth on a century scale before 1700?
- keiferski 6y agoI’m replying to this: Most people did not see the world change much in their lifetime.
- accurrent 6y agoActually, I would say 18th century was definitely quite happening. Yes, we did not see much GDP growth. However, this was a century where tides shifted. While the Mughal empire and Qing Dynasty accounting for probably 55% of the world's GDP at the start of the century by the end of the century we see Europe dominating the whole world (the Mughal Empire was taken over by the British and the seeds of the opium war were being sown by the end of the century). The 18th century is also probably the first time when we see the entire world as a single unit. Thanks to advances in sailing, European traders were all over the place. In the 1750s we see what is probably the first world scale conflict with the Seven Year War. For the first time in human History politics in one continent affects the politics of another continent. The fact is the world was changing faster than ever before in the 18th century. I'm pretty sure its hard not to feel the winds of change if you were alive at the time.
- BobbyJo 6y agoIt would look dynamic to an omnipotent being, but I think your parent comment was referring to the experience of an average human. Pretty much everyone on the planet at that time died living much the same life as their parents and grandparents.
- accurrent 6y agoI would say thats qiite a eurocentric view. Many Asians would have been plunged into poverty. Entire industries essentially disappeared with the coming of the British (muslin, wootz steel) and new industries would be formed (opium, indigo). They would also have faced a a vastly different set of rules.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BobbyJo 6y agoMy impression is that the point would apply to those countries as well. The vast majority of people, even in those countries, lived just as their parents and grandparents.