3 ms·
I'm glad this got a second chance, because I really think it's a brilliant idea. I just have a difficult time seeing how it could be cost-effective, without be
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
I'm glad this got a second chance, because I really think it's a brilliant idea.
I just have a difficult time seeing how it could be cost-effective, without being eye-wateringly expensive.
Being able to detect forgeries requires some pretty intense domain expertise, and that tends to come with a lot of experience and schooling. Those folks don't run cheap. Very often, you need specialists in each domain. For example, you can't have a fashion purse expert determining whether an "antique" firearm (where forgery is a big problem) is fake.
I'd assume the biggest value would be to contract with auction houses or appraisers, where the workflow would be familiar. With regular users, the workflow would be all over the place, and I could easily see the whole thing taking hours, because the user keeps sending cruddy photos in a tungsten light, so the color can't be judged, or the focus is off.
But I guess if it's really just sending links to Amazon listings, things are fairly "standardized," so a number of assumptions can be made.
Nonetheless, this is not my area of expertise, and the OP insists that it is a viable service, making a profit, so I must offer kudos.
- chdaniel 6y agoI'm glad too and grateful for the second chance on the article! > I just have a difficult time seeing how it could be cost-effective, without being eye-wateringly expensive. We write the guides first, which 'earns' us the 'audacity' to claim we know how to authenticate. I thought of the academic world so as to prove the expertise (I'm the complete opposite of an academic) * We write public guides (see: https://legitcheck.app/explore-the-library/ https://legitcheck.app/explore-the-library/) - we have about 1m words written on the subject * People are free to contest it. If we're wrong, we'll correct * The more other people link to our guides, the more we get... credentials, I guess? > you can't have a fashion purse expert determining whether an "antique" firearm (where forgery is a big problem) We don't really get that far, into firearms and the such. Currently we do sneakers, clothing, watches, bags and some collectibles (e.g. Pokemon Cards) > I'd assume the biggest value would be to contract with auction houses or appraisers, where the workflow would be familiar We've worked occasionally with some (e.g. authenticated a pair of $20,000 Jordans: https://legitcheck.app/certificate-of-authenticity/property-room-air-jordan-4-eminem-carhartt/ https://legitcheck.app/certificate-of-authenticity/property-... But mostly B2C, so it's a consumer-focuseed service > But I guess if it's really just sending links to Amazon listings The products we're authenticating are mostly 'asset products', so items that are $300+, most of the time sold-out, have some resale value over retail OR retain more of their retail value than usual items (think: Chanel items)
- barbegal 6y agoSo the value is in the content of the guides. How do you write these? Do you get input from the manufacturers or other experts? Fakes can be very convincing and genuine manufacturing processes can be very variable.
- flurie 6y agoThere is a great deal of information already available in their main lines of business with items of high volume, popularity, and resell value. A great example of all three would be the original set of collaborative releases between Nike and Off-White, called "The Ten." Many people have bought authentic pairs, and many, quite a few knowingly, have bought fakes. There is a large pool of information on the variability of both authentic and fake items. Often, experts can determine which sellers have factory sources in common, because the factories frequently do not sell directly to consumers. People who know where this information exists, since it is frequently in a few different places, could read as much as possible and compile it into guides. My guess is that's what they have done, since it can be difficult to be an expert on everything. The bulk of their business probably also has to do with a small subset of the full market. I doubt they see many requests to authenticate, say, a pair of Carol Christian Poell drip sneakers, because they are low in volume and overall popularity. And sometimes the best source of information is rep makers and resellers, especially with pieces that are difficult to duplicate. Fakes can be convincing, but they're frequently sorted into a couple tiers, and in some cases, fakes can only be spotted with a detailed examination of areas where the fakes are most likely to deviate from the originals. There is a fuzzy threshold for quality that is determined by the ability to identify these differences while someone is wearing the fake item.
- biot 6y ago> Being able to detect forgeries requires some pretty intense domain expertise, and that tends to come with a lot of experience and schooling Does it really require that? Perhaps for some items expensive enough to have expert forgeries (like with artwork where sometimes you need to test the composition of the paint itself or x-ray the canvas) but I doubt that’s the case for the typical knock-off item where all you need are pictures. Here’s how I would go about this if I, as someone who knows absolutely nothing about any of this, wanted to setup this kind of business. First, I would search for images of popular items which have known knock-offs produced. Let’s say the Nike sneakers or the Louis Vuitton bag mentioned. I would gather as many pictures of the known, proven knock-offs as I could. Then I would find official images published by Nike and Louis Vuitton. Put the images side-by-side and it’s simply a matter of going through that children’s exercise where you spot as many differences between the two pictures as you can. Then given all the differences I spotted, I would start writing up guides documenting all of what my rudimentary exercise discovered. Publish the guides to gain credibility and then participate in various forums where those products are discussed. Pump the free guides and get established as an authority, even though all I’ve done is use my eyes to spot differences. Then, just as they wrote up, start offering to check people’s stuff for free. When it hits a certain volume, offer priority service, etc. Same playbook for that. When you get an item you’ve never reviewed before — say, a Rolex watch — ask the customer to submit photos that exactly match ones that Rolex publishes (actually, you should always ask for matching photos to make the work 100% trivial). Rinse and repeat: spot the differences. You may not find 100% of the differences but you can get close enough to authoritatively state if it’s a knock-off or not. If you hit a wall where you’re not sure if the Rolex is real or not, there are two options. If Rolex is amenable to this, send the images to Rolex and ask them if there are obvious signs of a fake. Then you’re just playing the middleman and if Rolex needs more photos to authenticate, relay that back to the customer. If they’re not, I’m sure it’s not too difficult to locate someone who you know has a Rolex. Or maybe partner with a jeweler and cut them in. Hey, now it’s not just you anymore and you can claim you have a team of people performing authentications behind the scenes. Customers don’t need to know that your team is really just you and a buddy who can spot differences between pictures, plus occasional ad-how strangers, and maybe even the official companies themselves from time to time. I’d be somewhat surprised if they didn’t do exactly what I described.