10 ms·
The article makes a very strenuous effort to make a point about something something racism in rock that sounds a bit boring and trite to my ears. After all, Bon
by YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago
The article makes a very strenuous effort to make a point about something
something racism in rock that sounds a bit boring and trite to my ears. After
all, Bon Scott said it best years ago:
In the beginning
Back in nineteen fifty five
Man didn't know 'bout a rock 'n' roll show
And all that jive
The white man had the schmaltz
The black man had the blues
No one knew what they was gonna do
But Tchaikovsky had the news
(Although, Tchaikovsky? What the...?)
What I want to know is why young black Americans, do not, in their majority, do
rock anymore. I get that the music industry always tries to control what gets
airtime, but who needs the music industry today, and who needed the music
industry in the past? If it was for the music industry, nobody would have heard
of Jimi Hendrix- a black man with a guitar? That'll never sell!
Look at metal and how it took hold. Growing up in Athens, Greece, it seemed like
every neighbourhood had a metal band and you would never know by looking at
billboards, or even coverage in the metal press (a lackey of the music industry,
if there ever was one). Euro kids took Rock from the Americans and ran with it
and made something new, all ours, and all working class (see the early years of
Sabbath and Priest in Manchester; remember the apocryphal story of Ozzy and Tony
having one pair of good shoes between them and wearing them on alternate days to
go out). Metal quickly became the authentic popular music of entire generations,
without ever any need of mainstream acceptance. Metal grew from below, with no
help from above and despite the disdainful snorts of mainstream music critics.
So why didn't the black grasroots ever sprout an analogous new rock scene,
instead of turning towards the mainstream, big stage, light show, for-profit
music that comes from black artists for the last few decades?
Why Rihana and Beyonce, rather than a new Jimi Hendrix? Female, even. Why is
Rock 'n' Roll pretty much dead to black kids, nowadays?
- xphilter 6y agoI mean, if you exclude racism and structural racism as an answer, you’ll be wondering for a long time “why black people don’t rock anymore.” But it’s not my job to educate you, I’d suggest you look into yourself.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dang 6y agoPlease don't post ideological flamewar comments to HN or cross into personal attack. Neither of those makes for interesting conversation, only dumbed-down hostility. If you have a substantive insight to offer about the topic, that of course is welcome. It's no one's job here to educate the others, thankfully. But learning from each other is the point of this place, and that only works if we don't get stuck in ideological tropes and internet putdowns. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=share%20know%20learn%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- xphilter 6y agoGive me a break. Y’all are so eager to say “it can’t be racism” to explain current situations despite explicit racism for hundreds of years in the US. Maybe take that learning attitude you’re talking about seriously.
- dang 6y agoWho is "y'all"? If you mean "some HN commenters", then sure—some HN commenters post all kinds of crap. This is the internet. If you mean anything more than that, I'd like to know who. It doesn't describe the community as a whole. If you mean the moderators, it is deeply untrue. Could you please stop posting in the flamewar style to HN? It leads to extremely poor-quality, indeed vicious discussion, which does zero good and only contributes to destroying this place. You don't need swipes, putdowns, snark, or personal attacks to make your substantive points. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- derwiki 6y ago“Roll over Beethoven” by Chuck Berry has the line “And tell Tchaikovsky the news”—-I presume that is the reference?
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoRight! That explains it I think. Thanks!
- jrm4 6y agoI mean, it's important to remember that the racist segmenting of the industry (again, mostly the fault of the sellers not the artists) never really went away, it just changed in a lot of ways. So there's the difference between "Rock n Roll" the sound, and "Rock n Roll," the product. As a sound, it pretty consistently stays there, though perhaps not as crisply defined. Prince, Michael Jackson, and later Run DMC et al. But for a very long time, those artists are explicitly not given space on Rock n Roll stations. Later on, these same stations would go on to explicitly and openly denounce hip-hop, but the play Beastie Boys, and even EMINEM. What's really interesting is early Hip-Hop on this; how it very consistently both sampled Rock-n-Roll, but also frequently explicitly "hated" it. Not too hard to see why this division happens, given the disparate treatment (i.e. hip-hop comes out a little after most of the Satanic Panic has died down. Rappers get treated as "scary" for basically just being black, RIGHT AFTER and in the face of rumored blood rituals etc etc.)
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoRun DMC count as rock? That explains why I dig them :) (or it might just be the Aerosmith cover/ duo)
- bigbillheck 6y ago> hip-hop comes out a little after most of the Satanic Panic has died down That's not the way I remember it. For example, the McMartin trial started the same year as 'Paid in Full' dropped, and the West Memphis Three the same year as 'Enter the Wu-Tang'. > Rappers get treated as "scary" for basically just being black, RIGHT AFTER Young men 'get[ting] treated as "scary" for basically just being black' has a history way longer than rap music.
- mellosouls 6y agoSo why didn't the black grasroots ever sprout an analogous new rock scene, instead of turning towards the mainstream, big stage, light show, for-profit music that comes from black artists for the last few decades? I think this claim speaks more to your perception of music that isn't "rock" (there is no greater association with stadium-filling and dull commercialism than that label for some of us) than it does about what young creative people (of whichever colour) should be making.
- tolbish 6y agoRight. Isn't rock the most mainstream, big stage, for-profit genre in existence? Their comment just sounds like they want to criticize black people as a whole for some reason. Like...do they also criticize Indians for not being really into rock and for only being into stereotypically Indian music?
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoI don't understand why you say that I am criticising black people. I wondered why black kids don't, as a rule (some do) make rock anymore. How is that criticising anyone? I think you and other posters here are jumping the gun and making associations between my comment and other comments you may have heard or read elsewhere and in a different context. If that is the case, please consider again the HN guidelines about responding to the strongest interpretation of other users' comments. Assuming I'm criticising blacks just because I ask why they don't make rock music anymore is a very weak interpretation of my comment.
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoI'll speak to this bluntly: some of your comments come across as lecturing black musicians on what they should be doing, in particular how they should shape their response to the racism they experience. Your comments also make clear that you do not experience the specific sort of racism black folk experience. This is a very poor combination, one that many people fall into, where they think they're being supportive but come across as patronizing, arrogant, and dismissive if not racist. Basically the listen more, lecture less, and make space for the voices that really need to be heard argument.
- nzeribe 6y agoThat's not true. Afropunk was a response to the question you pose. White people stole the rock from Black kids the way Ancient Greece stole the Hippocratic Oath from African culture. It is almost the same. Today, it's almost impossible to know Bo Diddley, Sister Rosetta Tharpe and other Black pioneers created rock in almost it's complete form. "History is written by the winners", they say, and our cultural memory is like a hard drive which has been written over. Show the typical rock fan footage of Black women going hard at a rock guitar in 1955, and they will profess shock. The re-writing of history has been successful. The "analogous new rock scene" you are searching for is called rap. It is rock music without guitars and for years in the early days, without white people. Think about Run-DMC in 1982, and how "punk-rock" they were with the stripped down sound and hard lyrics. Black artists were hounded out of rock music by racist promoters and a hostile music industry, and their answer to it was hip-hop. The history of Black music has been of flight, an attempt to escape white cultural aggression stealing their music and style without accreditation or compensation. Promoters defunded and starved out Black performers, and the answer to that is two turntables and a mic on the underground, sound systems plugged into street lights - where they can't get defunded, have control, and have no white people. The Beatles up until 1964 were almost identical to the Isley Brothers but racism in the US was so entrenched that Americans had to re-import the music on their doorstep being made at home through 4 white kids from Liverpool. How ironic is that?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dang 6y agoYou're right, of course, although surely anyone who isn't ignorant knows that rock n roll was black music, and in any case Elvis (and countless others all the way—I would say down, but that's mean—to Cliff Richard and Pat Boone) were busy at that before the Beatles. By the way, if anyone is interested in this who doesn't know the incredible story of the Detroit proto-punk band Death, it's sort of a glimpse into a parallel reality in which all this didn't happen (but it did happen, so they were forgotten for 30 years). The missing black Ramones, Stooges, Clash. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OwehxN2ipCU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OwehxN2ipCU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uAZ9R2t5Jd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uAZ9R2t5Jd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iIsE8TyNEL4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iIsE8TyNEL4 https://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/15/arts/music/15rubi.html?_r=1 https://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/15/arts/music/15rubi.html?_r... ("Their musicianship tightened when their mother allowed them to replace their bedroom furniture with mikes and amps as long as they practiced for three hours every afternoon") This interview is so great, everyone reading this thread should just watch it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vru_cgNnNv4#t=59m50s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vru_cgNnNv4#t=59m50s
- wolverine876 6y agoI didn't know metal was so big in Athens, Greece. Thanks. > So why didn't the black grasroots ever sprout an analogous new rock scene, instead of turning towards the mainstream, big stage, light show, for-profit music that comes from black artists for the last few decades? For me, that's like asking, 'why didn't Van Gogh ever develop something innovative, like the abstract artists, instead of painting in his popular impressionist style?'. Is there any subculture in the world that has invented more music on the grassroots level than African-Americans? There's jazz, blues, gospel, turntableism (i.e., two turntables and a microphone), rap, techno (yes, created by African-Americans in Detroit), and all their derivatives: R&B, soul, hip-hop, etc. etc. All of that began at the grassroots. Just because people aren't inventing rock genres, doesn't mean they aren't inventing musical genres - does that need to be said? Just because you hear it now on the big stage doesn't mean it was born there, or that there isn't grassroots innovation still going on that you don't see. > The article makes a very strenuous effort to make a point about something something racism in rock that sounds a bit boring and trite to my ears. White people's skepticism of racism, every time it's mentioned, is tired and old - as old as racism, I suppose.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoTo clarify, I'm skeptical of the article's attempt to point at racism, not of the existence of racism in general, neither even in the context that the article places it in. I'm criticising the article. I must say I don't appreciate your attempt to connect my comment with racist views you may have encountered in the past. I invite you to consider your comment in the context of the HN guidelines about responding to the strongest interpretation of others' comments, which I believe you ommitted to do in this case. (And I edited this and deleted other comments to make the whole exchange less combative, also in the spirit of HN guidelines).
- wolverine876 6y agoI'm sorry you feel that way. To be clear, I am not calling you racist (whatever that means exactly) and I am not calling that sentence racist, etc. But I have said racist things and held racist perspectives in my life; I'm human; I probably still do, unwittingly. I take that seriously - it hurts people, maybe more than anything else in humanity. (To make clear my position: I'll be damned if the scourge continues, on anything like its current scale, past my generation.) Also, sometimes I say things that unwittingly contribute to racism. If you did one of those things - I'm not saying you did - it wouldn't make you the devil. It's not about judging you; I assume you don't want to do these things either. This is my personal point of view in more detail. From the GGP: > The article makes a very strenuous effort to make a point about something something racism in rock that sounds a bit boring and trite to my ears. IMHO that sentence makes a joke of the article's points about racism, and calls them "boring and trite". Also, importantly it's an expression of feelings, not facts and reasoning. I'm saying it fits a general pattern: Very often IME, when racism is mentioned, people express skepticism in the same manner. The manner is an essential factor: It implies (and the GGP sentence says almost explicitly), 'these people can be ignored; I won't give them the time of day'. The power imbalance, that the vulnerable can be ignored, is at the core of racism; it allows racism to continue and be perpetuated; it puts the vulnerable under constant threat. Whether intended or not, I think the sentence repeats and reinforces that. To dramatize it, imagine a city council hearing: Someone says they are the victim of ongoing violence and threats from their neighbors, and gives a reasoned, factual account. The city council member doesn't ask detailed questions and explore the issue and possible solutions, they say, 'something something threats - how boring and trite'. It's a clear message that nobody need care and the attacks can continue.
- Digit-Al 6y agoAs a black English man who enjoys a bit of rock and metal myself I have wondered this myself. I have some theories, which I fully admit are half baked and quite possibly incorrect. However, I think that a lot of the culture around rock and metal is off-putting to a lot of black people. If you look at something like black metal and it's sub-genres, a lot of the culture and imagery revolves around satanism and European paganism; which is popular with a certain segment of European people but would hold little to no interest to those of an Afro or Caribbean heritage. Especially since so many black people have quite strong Religious beliefs. (Less so these days possibly, but many still pay lip service at the very least.) If you then look at the 80's hair metal and glam metal genres with the emphasis on long hair and make up and an image of sexual ambiguity. I think we can all agree that there (sadly) exists a big homophobia problem amongst many black communities; which means that the aforementioned sexual ambiguity would be very off-putting to them. Those are obviously extreme examples, but I think I've maybe made my point. I'm probably talking out of my ass, but those are my thoughts for what it's worth.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoNo, I agree. I listen to black bands but sometimes I'm happy that a few of them choose to sing (ish) in their native Scandinavian languages that I don't understand. I think I'd be very disturbed if I knew what they're singing about. Brrr. And indeed casual racism, sexism, hooliganism, homophobia, and general assholeness was common among my metalhead friends growing up (and for some it wasn't just poseuring). So I can see why black kids wouldn't feel welcome in today's metal scene at least. At times I didn't either. (My friends were equally dismissive of hair metal as "faggots" also, of course. Goes hand in hand with the rest. Oh, I did mention homophobia). But, why not raise a middle finger to today's metal scene (or the rock scene back in the day) and go do their own thing- their own rock thing, like they did their own rap thing etc? That's what I wonder about. Although, I guess I might as well ask why white kids don't all dig classical music, or their respective folk musics. Tastes change across generations. Edit: having thought about it a bit more I think what you say is simply: any kind of rock was tainted by its association with attitudes that were offputting to black kids, one way or the other. So they didn't want to do their own rock thing because the idea of any kind of rock thing felt wrong and as if it couldn't really be "theirs". If I think of it that way, that answers my question actually.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> So why didn't the black grasroots ever sprout an analogous new rock scene, instead of turning towards the mainstream, big stage, light show, for-profit music that comes from black artists for the last few decades? When hiphop evolved, rock was the premier mainstream, big stage, light show, for-profit genre. I’d argue that, insofar as rock & roll “died”, a more succinct explanation than the article’s is that: it became popular, controlled by big business, and ossified. And because of that, it ceased to be the voice of the outsider, which hip hop became. (Of course, as often happens, the energy, diversity, and rawness that comes from being the voice of the outsider led to hiphop becoming broadly popular, so now it is thr mainstream, yadayadayada... But it became that at a time when industry gatekeeping isn’t as powerful, so maybe it won’t ossify under elite control the same way. Time will tell.)
- jtdev 6y agoBecause culture has been weaponized against minorities: “The poverty rate among black married couples has been in single digits ever since 1994. You would never learn that from most of the media. Similarly if you look at those blacks that have gone on to college or finished college, the incarceration rate is some tiny fraction of what it is among those blacks who have dropped out of high school. So it’s not being black; it’s a way of life. Unfortunately, the way of life is being celebrated not only in rap music, but among the intelligentsia, is a way of life that leads to a lot of very big problems for most people.” - Thomas Sowell
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe poverty rate is still between two or three times that of white (non-Hispanic) married couples. Allegations of poor moral character are a stock racist talking point - which ignores the reality of the poor moral character of those who lean right but are privileged enough not to have to face consequences, and also the huge differences in social and economic opportunity.
- jtdev 6y agoThomas Sowell is anything but a racist… take off the blinders.