4 ms·
This doesn't bother me at all. Wouldn't it mean that if you talk to Apple about something you need they might actually give it to you? I suspect that people im
by mrtksn 6y ago
This doesn't bother me at all. Wouldn't it mean that if you talk to Apple about something you need they might actually give it to you?
I suspect that people imagine Zoom getting a privilege due to their inartistic value but I don't think that this is the case. I think that it's just a business and there's no reason why you can't have it with Apple too.
I imagine, engineers in Zoom needed this to accomplish something and they told the management. The management contacted Apple management and explained them how this could work well both for Apple and Zoom and promised not doing nasty stuff. Apple trusted Zoom enough to open or implement that feature for them. Maybe Apple have seen the the need of this API, developed it and contacted Zoom to give it a try.
Why wouldn't they open it for everybody? Probably edge cases that can be worked out on 1:1 partnership but need good design when open to everyone.
It's just business. What would have annoyed me though is if a competitor like Skype request access in similer terms but got denied.
For some reason, the narrative on HN and similar tech heavy forums require us to pretend that business relationships don't exist or that business relationships are dirty elitist entities that you can't have. A lot of people can be surprised how much you can have by just asking to have it or proposing something that can work for everyone. Maybe that's the dirty secret of the non-technicals :)
- jefftk 6y agoWould you feel the same way if a web browser added a feature that could only be used by a specific partner?
- mrtksn 6y agoGood question. I had to think about it and I can't get more definitive beyond "it depends". In many ways, it's already the case. Browsers are already possible through partnerships with companies that manage certificates, DNS and so on. They also have special APIs that are open only to the vendor. You can't spin off your authoritative DNS or certificate authority or malicious site detection and have it made accepted by Firefox/Chrome or others. On the other hand, we have an understanding about what web is and expectations about the web standards which makes me to expect neutrality. It's the tool that promises me to parse whatever HTML I throw at it and execute any JS. Then we have things like Brave browser that has API that's not of any standards. So, I don't know. It depend. I will know it when I see it.
- easrng 6y agoLike window.chrome.webstorePrivate? It exists, but only on https://chrome.google.com/webstore/ https://chrome.google.com/webstore/ pages.
- jefftk 6y agoThat's a bit of a funny example, since it looks to me like that's Chrome giving special treatment to it's own store? And offering APIs for the store to function, like showing installed extensions differently from non-installed ones?
- bellyfullofbac 6y agoI won't speak for anyone else, but my problem is more that I need to ask permission to tinker with hardware that I own. We can't even deploy apps on the device without having an Apple ID...
- mrtksn 6y agoYou don't need to ask for permission to do anything on your own device. What you need permission is, to use Apple's tools that makes it orders of magnitude easier to do it. Just remember, the first iPhone did not have an AppStore or SDK. People made apps for it anyway. People also often confuse the right for access to Apple's app distribution services with the right to run apps on their own device. In reality, you can have a torrent client or anything you want on your phone without asking Apple for permission. That doesn't mean that it's going to be as easy as installing it from AppStore though. You will need to thinker harder.
- bellyfullofbac 6y agoOK, fine, they're gatekeeping not their hardware, but their dev tools. Kinda sad that you're fine with that...
- mrtksn 6y agoWhy wouldn't anybody be fine with that? Of course it would have been amazing if they let us do more with their tools but I simply don't see how they are obligated to do it. I also like how Apple is the opinionated elitists design house. As long as they are not the dominant force in this space, I'm fine with them doing things their way. I see some people argue that Apple is dominant and everything changes when Apple does something but that's simply because Apple is really great at designing it. There are also many thing that Apple does and then doesn't stick. It's the stuff that they simply fail to design well. It's good to have someone around that doesn't race to the bottom and have opinions on how things should be made.
- risyachka 6y agoWhy do you have a problem with asking permission? You always have to ask for it unless something yours and you own 100% intellectual rights for it. And this is the case not only with Apple, but with 99% of all devices out there. Developers get access only to what manufacturer gives them right to, and this is how it should be. If you make some device no one should force you to open it up or give everyone access to it. This is your own product, you should be able to control who access what, otherwise it is not yours by definition.
- gregoriol 6y agoIt would be business if there was a way to know this thing exists and to contact them and request it; otherwise it's a hidden secret between them and that partner, which is a disadvantage to all other developers paying 99$ every year to have access to it.
- mrtksn 6y agoAnyone acan do any business deal with anybody and not disclose it as long as it complies with the government regulations. Companies rarely disclose their dealings with other companies, trade secrets are often the most guarded secrets out there and its completely legal.
- scarface74 6y agoMarco Arment - a one man development shop, albeit well known, was able to work with the iOS team to get better audio support for the Apple Watch. It’s not just big developers. Have you noticed that when every big tech company announces a new product they already have testimonials about how well the product works?