5 ms·
Yeah. Everyone in my country uses WhatsApp. There's nothing I can do about it so I've made peace with it. At least it has end-to-end encryption. It's even prove
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
Yeah. Everyone in my country uses WhatsApp. There's nothing I can do about it so I've made peace with it. At least it has end-to-end encryption. It's even proven its effectiveness against my government's justice system.
- fragileone 6y agoFacebook own the keys so it's not real "E2EE".
- tome 6y agoCould you explain further? My understanding was that every WhatsApp user had their own private key.
- strogonoff 6y agoFor what it’s worth, OWS (whose co-founder created WhatsApp and which is now known as Signal Foundation) implemented Signal protocol for WhatsApp’s E2EE. WhatsApp’s technical paper[0] (last updated October 2020) describing the implementation indicates that only public keys, not private keys are stored on the server. Unless there’s been an incident I’m not aware of, all I’m seeing is you claiming that WhatsApp/OWS engineers are lying with the only substantiation being questionable ethical practices of the parent company. [0] https://scontent.whatsapp.net/v/t39.8562-34/122249142_469857720642275_2152527586907531259_n.pdf/WA_Security_WhitePaper.pdf?ccb=1-3&_nc_sid=2fbf2a&_nc_ohc=-6fjS-vdUYIAX-lpXbN&_nc_ht=scontent.whatsapp.net&oh=4191502da53769fda27035990f1dc729&oe=60BD3519 https://scontent.whatsapp.net/v/t39.8562-34/122249142_469857...
- beagle3 6y agoThat's likely true about the protocol, as far as I can tell. But that's never been true about data-at-rest on your device; which wouldn't have been much a of a problem, except ... They used to have encrypted backups, but at some point in time, the Android backup (and AFAIK the iOS backup as well) dropped encryption. And since 99% or so of users back-up to the cloud, it means that Google and Apple have the unencrypted history for essentially everyone (remember, every message has two sides - they only need one side from each message)
- strogonoff 6y agoThis is an issue separate from “X owning your private keys”, but I agree it’s a problem. Either way, secure messaging requires care from both sides; even if you both use Signal your counterpart can, say, let some spyware screenshot her jailbroken Android, and then it’s all for nothing. The only way of avoiding that is probably handling communication on a dedicated device, or a thoroughly locked down software ecosystem. Anecdotally, a couple years ago I lost the entirety of my WhatsApp conversations and contacts after changing phone: I missed the opportunity to enter a code at some point and it got wiped without any way to recover it. I don’t know if that was an indication of backup encryption, but it sure felt like security trumping convenience.
- beagle3 6y agoJust pointing out that there’s a difference between one person being owned (your signal example) and essentially everyone’s data being available to state-level actors (what’s happening with WhatsApp)
- strogonoff 6y agoTrue, the scale does matter.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y ago> They used to have encrypted backups, but at some point in time, the Android backup (and AFAIK the iOS backup as well) dropped encryption. Is this actually the case? I know they say it's not protected by E2EE, but my understanding is: - images are unencrypted (just like they're accessible on your phone's external storage, where many apps can read them) - the text messages are encrypted, but the key is escrowed with Facebook, who will provide it to anyone who can pass SMS verification This means that an attacker has to get access to both your Whatsapp account and your Google/Apple account. This isn't a very high hurdle (for governments, this likely just means two subpoenas, and for other attackers, it just means getting access to your phone number through one way or another, because in many cases that will let them hijack most of your accounts), but it seems slightly better than unencrypted.
- skinkestek 6y agoAs another one who dislikes WhatsApp these day and defend Telegram I think we should still stick to the facts instead of going down to this level: I've seen no credible or verifiable claim that Facebook currently has access to the keys. That said: credible and preferably verifiable sources are very welcome. However, depending on your threat model WhatsApp might still be a huge problem, and this is public information so you can verify it for yourself: If anyone you communicate (or you) enable backups in WhatsApp, any chats that person is part of is uploaded to Google as unencrypted data, i.e. I believe the upload channel is encrypted but it is stored in a way that everyone who can force Google to give them access can read them. Which means that you group chats might very well be readable to Google and everyone they have to obey without you even knowing.