>it's not everyone else's responsibility to divine that you are the magical case. The irony here is that the only divining happening is assuming that I should

>it's not everyone else's responsibility to divine that you are the magical case. The irony here is that the only divining happening is assuming that I should be doing Y when I specifically asked for a solution to X. What you're proposing also requires me to divine all the ways that people will say "Don't do X, do Y." and explicitly state how I don't wish to do Y but really just want to accomplish X. "I'd like to accomplish X. No I can't do Y1 since E1, no I can't do Y2 since E2, ..., Y_N since E_N. Please just stick to X." It would be better if people just stuck to X in the first place, instead of doing all this divining. It also makes it really frustrating for others who share problem X and search for solutions to problem X, only to get people solving problem Y.