7 ms·
GTK4 still doesn't support native rendering of window controls, so unless you're willing to create a faux "native" theme, your application will look like it doe
by jeroenhd 6y ago
GTK4 still doesn't support native rendering of window controls, so unless you're willing to create a faux "native" theme, your application will look like it doesn't belong on anything other than a Gnome desktop. I think it's idiotic and childish that the devs stick to their guns like this when there's clearly a high demand for a crucial feature like this. I dislike the project as a developer.
Don't get me wrong, I'm using a Gnome desktop for my day to day work. As a user, I enjoy the end result and I'm very happy with the way the system looks, but the absolute refusal to allow for any SSR has so far prevented me from ever seriously considering GTK for any cross-platform desktop application I'd like to write.
I don't really have a problem with the Gnome apps. There's nothing special about them, but they work and they're there. I quite like the software tool when it works, I've never managed to get Discover working for more than a few days so at least Gnome Software is stable in comparison. I also don't have any trouble with MPV for video playback. Sure, it doesn't contain a lot of power user features, but I only need it to play video files when I double click them, for anything else there's VLC.
Gnome, as a package to build a diatro around, works quite well. With a full Gnome setup, you can do almost everything you need to do on a computer. KDE is similar in that regard, although I really dislike the general UX of the KDE ecosystem for some reason.
On a side note, VLC is getting a (controversial) new UI that makes it look more slick and modern than the current design.
- zxzax 6y ago>GTK4 still doesn't support native rendering of window controls FYI this is not entirely correct. There is a flag for this in GDK4: https://developer.gnome.org/gdk4/4.0/GdkToplevel.html#gdk-toplevel-set-decorated https://developer.gnome.org/gdk4/4.0/GdkToplevel.html#gdk-to... It may be that this is not implemented yet for some backends (I think it is not implemented in the Windows one) but they probably would accept a patch to implement it there if you know how to do it. Please avoid making these hostile assumptions about open source developers without having the full information. From what I have seen, there is a push recently to make GTK4 a better cross platform toolkit than GTK3 was.
- jeroenhd 6y agoAllowing for SSR is a good step, but does this also render the other controls in their native style? The window border is one important place for styling, and I'm glad GTK4 will improve the situation once it hits the mainstream distros, but as far as I can tell, the rest of the controls (buttons, textboxes, etc.) are still rendered by the application rather than by the system. I've given GTK4 a try on Windows, and all enabling the top level decorations seem to do is to disable the window border. All controls are still Adwaita, so you'd still need to fake a Windows UI style if you want to make the application feel any kind of native.
- zxzax 6y agoI'm sorry, I misunderstood. I thought you meant the toplevel window controls like close, minimize, maximize. There is currently no way to make all the widgets render using the Win32 API to look like Windows widgets. You probably don't want to do that anyway, it will start to look and act really inconsistent when an application uses custom widgets. Somebody could definitely fake a theme that makes the widgets look like Windows, and ship that with their windows builds, if that was desired. That to me is a much more viable option. There are multiple themes like this for GTK3. [0] [1] I don't know if any have been ported to GTK4 yet, but they could. [0] https://github.com/B00merang-Project/Windows-10 https://github.com/B00merang-Project/Windows-10 [1] https://github.com/B00merang-Project/Windows-7 https://github.com/B00merang-Project/Windows-7
- bsder 6y ago> GTK4 still doesn't support native rendering of window controls Sorry, this ship has sailed, and I find that bringing "native" into an argument simply invalidates the argument. That "native" has changed so much over the years shows that there isn't one "truth". The fact that things like Electron and Flutter and other toolkits exist clearly demonstrates that end users don't give one iota of damn whether a control is native or not.
- jeroenhd 6y agoUsers don't get a choice whether a control is native or not, that doesn't mean they don't have a preference. There's a few code editors out there integrating heavily with macOS that get featured here on HN once a while, and every time the comments are filled with people complimenting how well it works with the operating system and how nicely it integrates. People also complain all the time about how Google sticks to material design on iPhone, even though the rest of the device follows an entirely different standard. If users really didn't care about native controls, that wouldn't be a problem at all. When an application fits into the system, it's generally celebrated, but we've reached the point where we stopped expecting any form of integration anymore because every application is Javascript wrapped into a copy of Chromium now, if you even get a desktop version of the application in the first place. the fact that Electron and Flutter and React Native and others exist clearly demonstrates that developers don't give one iota of a damn whether a control is native or not. These are tools of developer comfort, not of user comfort. Users don't care what you use to build your applications, as long as your app does the things they want to do well. I don't see anyone celebrating the diversity of ways the different X buttons on their desktop looks, but I do see people enjoying the native look. To me, that seems like proof that this is a feature people are missing but not vocalising rather than that people don't care about. In the end, people enjoy native experiences more, but native experiences cost more time and effort to produce and therefore more money. Consumers want free or cheap apps so businesses use cross-platform toolkits to reduce cost and effort, but these platforms certainly don't prove that users don't give a damn. They prove that they value having an app for cheap over having a good app for more money.
- sofixa 6y ago