21 ms·
That's not what they do at all. Just a few sentences later, they break down changes in death rates into 6 categories -- 3 that are increases but also 3 that ar
by crazygringo 6y ago
That's not what they do at all.
Just a few sentences later, they break down changes in death rates into 6 categories -- 3 that are increases but also 3 that are decreases.
But in any case, it's a pretty reasonable first-order assumption that excess deaths are from COVID, that can then be analyzed in more detail per-population to see if it continues to be plausible, e.g. whether excess deaths were also correlated in time and place with COVID, etc.
And isn't this precisely the kind of double-checking of official numbers that is valuable? Official statistics don't always tell the truth -- witness Cuomo specifically undercounting nursing home deaths. The shenanigans we should be concerned with aren't this -- it's shenanigans in official reporting. Thank goodness we live in a democracy with free speech where these kinds of things can be questioned.
Challenging findings to produce stronger, more trustworthy final results ultimately increases faith in science, don't you think? It sounds like you're arguing findings should never be challenged, which isn't science at all.
- fullshark 6y agoThey then say that they considered all the 3 factors that lead to increases to be COVID deaths: > The main potential increases in excess mortality due to deferred care and increases in drug overdose and depression are hard to quantify at this point or are of a much smaller magnitude. Given that there is insufficient evidence to estimate these contributions to excess mortality, for now we assume that total COVID-19 deaths equal excess mortality Basically the 6 factor breakdown is a way to decrease the volume of expected deaths to make the excess mortality number larger. 100% of which was attributed to COVID.