2 ms·
Numerous problems. 1. The current death toll is with the existing lockdowns. There are good reasons to think that without (especially the early) lockdowns the
by whimsicalism 6y ago
Numerous problems.
1. The current death toll is with the existing lockdowns. There are good reasons to think that without (especially the early) lockdowns the death toll could have been way higher.
2. Being dead for 1 year cannot be equivalently compared to being socially distant for 1 year (not 2). Is that not obvious?
3. This is before we get into life long disability, etc. due to covid. I know someone whose parent had a covid caused stroke, essentially ending their existence as the person they were before.
- hervature 6y agoCorrect, all valid points. But we can assign numbers to all these things and the error bars are sufficiently large that there is ample room for debate. As for 2. is it obvious? My niece doesn't know that there are other humans like her, I would gladly take a year at the end of my life to give that gift to her. Given the current vaccination rates, many people will not see normal until 2022. For 3. it cuts both ways, how many new alcoholic parents and child abuse that ruins an entire lifetime?
- xkjkls 6y ago> is it obvious? My niece doesn't know that there are other humans like her, I would gladly take a year at the end of my life to give that gift to her. I'm not sure she is going to agree with you when she visits you toward the end of your life. > For 3. it cuts both ways, how many new alcoholic parents and child abuse that ruins an entire lifetime? It's far from obvious what the effects of COVID-19 are on child abuse. The data is hard to disaggregate because there are so many conflicting factors, but there isn't obvious reason to believe that child abuse is up during the pandemic given the data we have seen: https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2021/03/419961/child-abuse-surges-times-crisis-pandemic-may-be-different https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2021/03/419961/child-abuse-surges-...
- hervature 6y ago> I'm not sure That sounds like it is not obvious. > The data is hard to disaggregate because there are so many conflicting factors Basically sums up COVID policies. The point remains, I have yet to see any clear objective policy making that even tries to estimate impact on life of all citizens. In absence of anything resembling a consideration of all age groups, I just ignore any opinion of lockdown both for and against.
- whimsicalism 6y agoImportant to keep in mind about the YLL numbers I cited: most of the YLL comes from younger people who died early, even though most of the deaths are among people 70+. So if you are going by this "differential quality of different years" argument, you have to account for the fact that most of these years actually aren't for really old people.