3 ms·
Or you know, the JIT will trivially optimize away the old class if it is reassigned to the same variable, as you would use it inside a loop. How do you think th
by kaba0 6y ago
Or you know, the JIT will trivially optimize away the old class if it is reassigned to the same variable, as you would use it inside a loop. How do you think the litany of FP languages work? Like Haskell, Scala, Clojure?
- slver 6y agoIt can be done in theory, but the JVM does nothing of the sort right now.
- kaba0 6y agoFalse. The JVM already does quite a good job with escape analysis, and record types just add extra semantic information to potentially further improve the situation.
- slver 6y agoWhat precisely of what I said is “false”?
- jandrese 6y agoCounterpoint: Java programs with memory consumption graphs that have decided sharktooth patterns, which is extremely common.
- kaba0 6y agoAs opposed to what exactly? How would a C program’s memory graph look with quick bursts of memory-allocation requiring functionality, especially if it is very dynamic in nature? Yeah you can overallocate with memory pools and the like, and there are cases of course where escape analysis can’t help — that’s why Valhalla is in the works for quite some times now. But GC-wise the JVM is far ahead the game, whatever you see is likely better than the same functionality would be under JS, Python, C#, Go, etc (though the latter two do have value types/structs already so they can at some place manually do the “escape-analysis”. But not every problem requires/can use value types either)
- slver 6y agoValue types are essential element of design to me, but this is not widely recognized yet. To me it’d be like saying primitive types are not essential.
- vbezhenar 6y agoThat's a theory not happening in practice. In practice Java programs are slow and memory-hungry because of those issues when some people think that it's cheap to create small objects or that escape analysis will solve their issues without verifying that it works for their case.
- kaba0 6y agoMost of the world’s server applications would like to disagree with you.
- slver 6y agoJava isn’t perfect. But you underestimate the amount of software written in it. Or even things like Python and JS which are a lot more basic but have similar elements in regards to their memory model. What do you use?
- vbezhenar 6y agoI work as Java developer for the last 10 years, I perfectly understand the amount of software and other things. I don't know much about Python and JS, but I do know that they're not using immutable model, everything is mutable in Python and in JS, so I'm not sure what's your point. The only immutable language I'm aware of is Haskell which is not used widely. Just because JVM is faster than Python or V8 does not mean that it's OK to slow it down with immutables.
- slver 6y agoUsing immutables doesn’t mean you go full Haskell. Strings are also immutable you know.