6 ms·
As for the high levels of violent crime feeding in to this system, I would like to evangelize the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violence_Reduction_Unit https://
by pjc50 6y ago
As for the high levels of violent crime feeding in to this system, I would like to evangelize the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violence_Reduction_Unit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violence_Reduction_Unit
A lot of people, especially Americans, like to think of Americans as a uniquely violent people, but this is really a systemic and cultural problem as well as a failing of individuals. People used to think of Glasgow as uniquely violent but that problem has been greatly reduced thanks to the VRU.
- diogenescynic 6y agoI think it has more to do with accessibility to guns. Anyone in America can be carrying a gun and it’s incredibly easy for criminals to buy them because they are so abundant. That’s not something people have to worry about in Japan or Europe.
- tjs8rj 6y agoThis doesn’t square with the fact that many of the most gun dense states have the lowest violent crime rates. New Hampshire has tons of guns, violent crime comparable to Nordic countries. I’d say in order the biggest determinants are: culture, social cohesion, and poverty. I put culture and social cohesion ahead of income because plenty of poorer asian countries do much better than richer european countries.
- diogenescynic 6y ago> New Hampshire has tons of guns, violent crime comparable to Nordic countries.I’d say in order the biggest determinants are: culture, social cohesion, and poverty. This sounds like borderline race theory or something Charles Murray would argue... So basically you’re saying that richer white people in homogeneous states are less violent than the states with poor, more diverse populations? I don’t think it’s based on race or culture, but income and class are definitely factors.
- thesuitonym 6y agoIncome is probably the biggest predictor of who will go on to commit violent crime, but guess what also correlates to income? In the US, non-white people are mostly poor.
- diogenescynic 6y agoCounter-point: highest income earners are actually Indian-Americans: https://gulfnews.com/world/americas/indians-in-america-make-100000-on-average-highest-earning-ethnic-group-1.1569215954674 https://gulfnews.com/world/americas/indians-in-america-make-...
- dfilppi 6y agoNo he didnt basically say that
- tjs8rj 6y agoWhat? I justified why I put culture and social cohesion first explicitly in my comment: because many poorer asian countries do much better than many richer white countries on average. The culture variable is overriding the income one. Culture is so obviously a factor: why does Switzerland have so many guns and similar average income to New Hampshire but much less violence? Clearly culture has an effect.
- syops 6y agoNew Hampshire doesn't have a city of the size of Stockholm, Oslo, or Helsinki in it. Large cities almost always have higher crime rates than rural areas. Clearly class and culture are part of the equation but I believe so too is the ready access to guns.
- tjs8rj 6y agoReady access to guns, also ready access to alcohol, ready access to knives, etc these are all part of the equation, but I contend that they are so dwarfed by the other factors that focusing on them seems disingenuous and otherwise random except as a result of knee-jerk politics. So maybe cities have the same order of magnitude effect in increasing crime as guns do - what would you suggest we do about that? Should we lower violent crime by banning cities and banning guns, or should we focus on the root problems of culture, social cohesion, and poverty? Also: Switzerland also has a ton of guns and major cities, violent crime rate is near the bottom - is suspect because their culture, social cohesion, and efforts to minimize poverty.
- syops 6y agoI don't suggest anything other than what I wrote. Specifically, that comparing the crime rate of a rural American state that has no major metropolitan centers to the crime rate of Scandinavian countries which do have major metropolitan centers is not apt. Switzerland has a ton of guns but not a ton of ready access to ammunition. Also according to this article [1] the U.S. has far more guns per person than Switzerland. According to the Geneva-based Small Arms Survey, there are about 89 civilian-owned guns for every 100 people who live in the United States. Switzerland ranks third in terms of gun ownership, the Survey estimates, with 3.4 million guns among its population of nearly eight million. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-21379912 https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-21379912
- mbrodersen 6y agoYou are absolutely right that culture and inequality is the key decider on violence. The US worship guns and the military to a degree I have never seen in any other western country. I am not surprised at all that individuals in the US believe they can fix things by shooting a random number of people or blow up federal buildings. I have lived and worked in western Europe, USA and Australia so I have seen the differences in culture up close.
- shigawire 6y agoIt is both but I believe the comment you were replying to was saying violence prevention programs are harder due to the number of guns. So NH having a high amount of guns isn't really a counter example. The point wasn't that guns are the sole cause, but that their prevalence makes it harder to resolve a violence problem (that stems from many sources). Or if I am assuming too much about the original posters view, I can instead just say this is my view.
- tjs8rj 6y agoSure, but access to alcohol has the same effect and I’d imagine has the same level of magnitude impact in increased violent crime. There are a million factors, but singling our access to guns - which is way down on the list of factors - sounds less like a genuine interest in solving the problem and more like a gut reaction “solution” that actually solves very little.
- mbrodersen 6y agoSo making nukes legal would be OK in your mind because it isn’t nukes that kill people but people?
- tjs8rj 6y agoThis is an interesting point. I thought about it and concluded that for me there’s a gradient of any freedom between the harm it causes and the liberty it grants. Making nukes accessible at Walmart is a little bit more freedom with likely much more harm. Allowing gun ownership is much more freedom with an increase in harm, but as I see it the increase in freedom is much bigger than the increase in harm. On the other end of the spectrum of marginally more harm but dramatically less freedom, would you suggest that we go into a covid shutdown every flu season? Or compelled speech laws? Or banning cars because the harm they cause? It’s all a balance between freedom and harm.
- mbrodersen 6y agoYep I agree that everything is a balance between freedom and harm. As for your examples: Cars are necessary for a modern society to function. Gun’s aren’t. Australia (where I live) have very few COVID deaths because of strict shutdowns. The US decided to let close to a million people die for “freedom”. Clearly our perceptions of harm is different. So our conclusions will also be different. Having lived and worked in the US, Europe, and Australia, it is clear to me that the US (in general) value human lives less than other Western nations. So the outcomes will be different.
- dmode 6y agoAll of what you said are true. But when you add gun to the mix it makes matters far worse. Gangs in the UK typically resort to stabbing, which leads to far fewer deaths
- mbrodersen 6y agoAbsolutely. If nukes were legal it wouldn’t just be cinemas and churches being attacked by crazy individuals but whole cities. Crazies would kill hundreds of thousands. Not “just” a few dozens.
- pjc50 6y agoThe crime just shifts down to knives, which are less lethal. Back in the notorious days of Glasgow that's what was used for the murders. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-45572691 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-45572691
- dls2016 6y agoThanks for sharing this, I have never heard of VRU or the American versions in Boston and Cincinnati. Though I'm no fan of reliance on stop-and-search.
- eplanit 6y agoIt was called "stop and frisk" in the US. When Giuliani did it in NYC in the 1990s, crime was reduced _dramatically_. Entire neighborhoods were liberated. Washington Square Park went from a very dangerous "no go" zone to a lovely, family-friendly park. Giuliani was praised for the outcome, and other agencies started the practice. But, unfortunately, political correctness won over, and the practice is mostly gone now -- and the crime rates have since soared. Giuliani was once called "America's Mayor" -- my how quickly times change.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoYes, because authoritarian policing drives out anyone who can get out and career criminals tend to not have very long term living arrangements. All Giulliani did was move the problems to New Jersey. It was successful in reducing crime in his jurisdiction. It didn't really reduce crime in the NYC metro area relative to anywhere else. Crime dropped off a lot over the 90s and '00s everywhere. There's a really wide gulf between police state tactics that ignore people's rights (90s stop and frisk) and the current situation in parts of the country where crimes with a victim that people are complaining about are ignored or given such a small slap on the risk they have a positive ROI.
- AlexTWithBeard 6y agoSo what would happen if New Jersey implemented the same policy as well?
- dmode 6y agoCrime rates have soared ? Pre-pandemic NYC had some of historically low crime rates. And it is one of the safest cities in the world https://www1.nyc.gov/site/nypd/news/p0106a/overall-crime-new-york-city-reaches-record-low-2020 https://www1.nyc.gov/site/nypd/news/p0106a/overall-crime-new... And all this without having to stop and search some rando black or brown dude walking down the road. This categorically proves that stop and frisk had no impact on crime rates at all. Los Angeles also experienced similarly historically low crime rates and had no stop and frisk. I can’t imagine how someone can live in a liberal democracy and be ok with authoritarian behavior like stop and search.
- bennysomething 6y agoKnow someone who works in a Glasgow A and E, says this really helped.
- bitshiftfaced 6y ago> which uses a public health approach to target all forms of violent behaviour including street/gang violence, domestic abuse, school bullying and workplace bullying. What's this mean exactly?
- pjc50 6y agoWell, they have their own explanation, but as I understand it: - there's an epidemiology of violence: untreated violence tends to breed more violence. Fear of violence and responses to violence cause violence of their own. Either retaliation or pre-emptively carrying weapons. - squalor tends to breed violence in the same way as it breeds disease - this stuff often starts at school (see US "school to prison pipeline") - A&E departments of hospitals are convenient contact points for people who've been stabbed or punched - this is an opportunity to discourage them from taking revenge or starting more fights - also it recognises that the effectiveness of police before a crime has been committed is (rightly) pretty limited, but social services can perform other kinds of interventions.
- egwynn 6y agoMy understanding is that programs like these work on the hypothesis that violent crime is often a symptom of an underlying public health issue (often mental health, in particular), and so should be addressed by public health resources more than by enforcement resources.
- diogenescynic 6y agoSo the Chesa Boudin strategy? That seems to be working out great for San Francisco.