5 ms·
Somewhat controversial opinion: The biggest problem with passwords is that users select them, and users are stupid. We would get 95% of the benefit of 2FA (For
by bawolff 6y ago
Somewhat controversial opinion: The biggest problem with passwords is that users select them, and users are stupid. We would get 95% of the benefit of 2FA (For forms of 2FA that aren't yubikeys, as yubikeys have benefits related to phising, but nobody uses them so its moot) if websites chose passwords for users instead of the user choosing the password.
In particular, the only two threats that 2FA as widely implemented on websites protect against are password reuse, and weak passwords. Both are the results of users choosing stupid passwords.
- timwis 6y ago2FA adds more value than that - it’s meant to be about “something you know and something you have” (in theory, physically). That way, even if your password is compromised three something like a data breach, you’re still protected.
- bawolff 6y agoIf the server in question is data breached, than they'll steal the 2FA secret. If the user's cell phone is breached, they will steal both the 2fa token and the password (or just the session cookie). Well what you say is true in theory, its not true in practise of how 2FA is commonly implemented.
- timwis 6y agoGood point, but wouldn’t they also need the time based algorithm? Here’s some more ammunition for your argument though: https://www.csoonline.com/article/3272425/11-ways-to-hack-2fa.html https://www.csoonline.com/article/3272425/11-ways-to-hack-2f...
- RamblingCTO 6y ago> The biggest problem with passwords is that users select them, and users are stupid. I really hope you don't work with users or are doing anything that affects them. Users are not stupid, they maybe lack understand or are lazy and things are inconvenient. But the world is easier if you can just pass of your responsibility to the ominous "dumb user", isn't it?
- bawolff 6y agoI meant no disrespect to users as a group. Nonetheless its clear that we can't get >99.5% of ùsers to implement this security control properly, and that makes it a bad security control. And to be clear, its my belief that if someone implements a security control that constantly fails due to misuse, the party at fault is the implementor, not the user. Whether that's because users don't understand or just that their interests/incentives are disaligned, doesn't really matter.
- RamblingCTO 6y ago> that makes it a bad security control I agree. We can improve it so that others don't have to think about it and it actually solves their problem. Right now we pretty much just move the responsibility to the user.
- jjav 6y agoNot controversial at all, very true. Make the password unique and >128+ bits of entropy and that's all that is needed. At that point it is as strong as a shared AES key.
- bawolff 6y agoWe probably don't even need 128 bits of entropy. TOTP 2FA is only 20 bits after all and people seem happy with that. If we make them be pseudo sentences they will probably be easier to remember (the $adjective $noun $adverb $verb a $adjective2 $noun2)
- forgotpwd16 6y agoFirefox has a very nice built-in password generation (e.g. S2AKGfsZ8i8t3PR) appearing on password fields in registration forms.