4 ms·
This is poor logic influenced by the politics of the LA aqueduct and water project. Nuts are calorie dense, and most foods require as much if not more water pe
by s1artibartfast 6y ago
This is poor logic influenced by the politics of the LA aqueduct and water project.
Nuts are calorie dense, and most foods require as much if not more water per calorie. Food simply requires a lot of water. For example, A 5 oz glass of wine takes 34 gallons. A head of iceberg lettuce takes 16 gallons of water.
You will note that the motherJones article compares almond water things like home use, not other food sources.
- ramraj07 6y agoCan you give more sources? First time I see someone refuting that growing almonds is a water shit show
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- npsimons 6y agoIt's not so much that almonds aren't water intense, as that things like beef and dairy (which are also heavily produced in California) are so much worse: https://www.truthordrought.com/almond-milk-myths https://www.truthordrought.com/almond-milk-myths Yet we never see beef or dairy demonized the way almonds are. Believe me, there are better plant milks than almond milk (pretty much any of them), but dairy has such a higher impact on the environment (as does beef), it's incredibly disingenuous and hypocritical to complain about almonds before addressing dairy and beef.
- tuatoru 6y agoThis is also poor logic. Nuts are not a calorie crop, they are a relatively high-cost garnish/flavouring. A snack size serving of almonds is around 20 of them, representing about 20 gallons. A side dish of lettuce is probably about half of one, 8 gallons. That said, California's water is probably best used in high value add industries like semiconductor manufacturing.
- digitalsushi 6y agoI believe I read once that it takes about 920 gallons of water to make 1 gallon of almond milk. edit: i am apparently worse than an almond milk drinker, since coffee uses even more water at 1,056:1. and learning even more, cow-milk is about 2000 gallons of water to make a gallon of milk! so i really have no idea about any of this and its all surprising https://shamelesshousewife.wordpress.com/tag/how-much-water-does-it-take-to-make-a-gallon-of-almond-milk/ https://shamelesshousewife.wordpress.com/tag/how-much-water-...
- cornel_io 6y agoSure, but water isn't scarce everywhere, so optimization for water cost is not like carbon footprint where it all gets blown into the atmosphere and is bad. Many regions don't need to worry about water at all so it's basically free.
- dragonwriter 6y agoDiverting high quality agricultural soil is even more expensive than diverting water, though. Irrigating California deserts and semi-arid regions for agriculture isn’t just some kind of random vanity project.
- tzs 6y ago> That said, California's water is probably best used in high value add industries like semiconductor manufacturing. California has some of the best soil for farming in the country (or even the world). A gallon of water used for agriculture in California will be more effective than a gallon used for agriculture in most other places. As far as I know there is nothing that makes California a great place for semiconductor manufacturing. A gallon of water used for semiconductors in California isn't more effective than a gallon used for semiconductor manufacturing anywhere else. That argues for prioritizing in California water for agriculture over water for semiconductors.
- UncleOxidant 6y ago
- colechristensen 6y agoThis is also poor logic. Many crops around the world receive zero irrigation, the only water they get comes from rain. Much of the cereal grains (not all, but still much) are grown without irrigation. In Iowa we drain the land by putting porous pipes a few feet down which are interlinked and drain into the rivers. If we didn’t, the water table comes up all the way to the surface and much of the land would be ephemeral ponds for significant portions of the year.
- daveevad 6y ago> In Iowa we drain the land by putting porous pipes a few feet down which are interlinked and drain into the rivers. That is a fascinating. How extensive and interlinked are those pipes?
- colechristensen 6y agoPipes as little as 30 to a few hundred feet apart. There are parts of the state where they're literally everywhere. Here's some drainage basics: https://fyi.extension.wisc.edu/drainage/files/2015/09/Basic_Eng_-Princ-2_2017.pdf https://fyi.extension.wisc.edu/drainage/files/2015/09/Basic_... There is extensive law regarding drainage and interconnection obligations between landowners, Iowa is pretty flat, there just has to be a path between your fields and a local river. All of the roads are edged with drainage ditches, there are bigger much deeper ditches where necessary to direct water. http://publications.iowa.gov/19966/1/IADOT_tr_497_Iowa_Drainage_Law_Manual_April_2005.pdf http://publications.iowa.gov/19966/1/IADOT_tr_497_Iowa_Drain...
- s1artibartfast 6y agoThe faulty logic as I see it is to focus on nut crops opposed to all crops in California, irrigated or otherwise. The problem is political because California has water rights and the legislature does not want buy the water rights from farmers or use eminent domain to seize them with fair compensation.
- npsimons 6y ago> and most foods require as much if not more water per calorie. Yup. Beef and dairy are far worse, yet almonds get shit on: https://www.truthordrought.com/almond-milk-myths https://www.truthordrought.com/almond-milk-myths