3 ms·
Is it really conceivable that the Web would have been stillborn without ads, or with limits to the externalities of ads? Does "software will eat the world" only
by analog31 6y ago
Is it really conceivable that the Web would have been stillborn without ads, or with limits to the externalities of ads? Does "software will eat the world" only mean "software will eat the world if it can sell ads?"
I'm pretty sure ads don't support the cell phone industry, or at least didn't support its exponential growth phase, yet the middle class and poor have cell phones.
- originalvichy 6y agoCellphone industry? No. The smartphone industry? Definitely. There are two major OSs for phones. One by a hardware-software company and the second from an adtech company. Guess which one is the cheap/free OS and which one is the more premium product of the two. :) Android destroyed its competition by having excellent support for Google's "free" software and because of their huge ad income they can pay to develop it further. So yeah I believe the modern phone industry has to thank the freemium adtech world for pushing Android into the world.
- analog31 6y agoIndeed, it's arguable that things that cost money will tend to come from an industry that's flush with money. So I can't really dispute your point. Before Android, smart phones were evolving, but outside of iOS, a phone came with a bespoke OS and a handful of apps. I'm still not convinced that even smartphones would have been stillborn. The apps might have been more klunky, but I'm not sure that's important. For instance, I would be happy to receive my daily news in a giant flat text file, and don't need the features that generate "engagement" or tell me what other people are reading. People who are "in the know" about computing tend to use less flashy interfaces, and more of the terminal window. But of course the ultimate answer is... I don't know. It's interesting that the freemium model kind of contradicts that idea that we benefit from ads, since we are willing to pay money to get rid of them, rather than the other way around. Maybe the industry could be funded by making ads available to those who want them, for a price.