To be clear, I agree we should eliminate the deduction for employer paid health care. For historical reference, employer-paid insurance only became prevalent i

To be clear, I agree we should eliminate the deduction for employer paid health care. For historical reference, employer-paid insurance only became prevalent in the US during/after World War II as a way to compete for labor after the government implemented wage controls. When the wage controls were lifted, people had become used to the benefit of employer-paid health care and it stuck. My sense is the US will never move to the model you describe with young men creating a buying group for very specific policies. Society is simply not going to accept extreme differences in premiums for young, healthy people vs much older, less healthy people.