3 ms·
In the span of just a few comments in the thread below, I've seen people claim that the ethical problem is: 1. All ads in general. 2. Targeted advertisement,
by UncleMeat 6y ago
In the span of just a few comments in the thread below, I've seen people claim that the ethical problem is:
1. All ads in general.
2. Targeted advertisement, regardless of the privacy implications.
3. Data collection for targeted advertisement.
4. Data collection for anything.
5. Whether or not users consent to all of the above.
So I don't really think it is fair for anybody to insist that there is a single agreed upon actual ethical problem in web advertising.
- smsm42 6y agoWhy it has to be a single ethical problem? The industry is quite capable of having multiple ethical problems in parallel.
- summerlight 6y agoBecause it's much easier to have constructive outputs when you focus on a single problem with a clear definition. But people usually conflate multiple topics into single and take advantages from this intentional ambiguity, irrespective of whether you're a proponent or a critic.
- UncleMeat 6y agoBecause everybody is complaining to everybody else that they aren't discussing the real ethical problem. This is being pointed at OP as well as commenters. It makes conversations difficult to have because as soon as people start talking about one thing, somebody jumps in and says "but you aren't talking about the real problem".
- ma2rten 6y agoI have also noticed this in other HN discussions. Everyone seems to assume everyone else agrees with their view on the topic and there is never any open discussion about it. Usually people just talk past each other and it's never pointed out.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xondono 6y agoYes there is, because none of what you mentioned is “the problem”, the problem is that all these practices are deliberately put into practice without users consent, or by trying to trick users into inadvertently give consent.
- UncleMeat 6y agoI'll add that one to the list.
- ma2rten 6y agoI don't know if it was mentioned here but another issue that many people have with Google specifically is it's perceived monopoly position and market power.