9 ms·
Astronauts with disabilities can apply to Europe's space agency for first time
- dahfizz 6y agoThis feels a bit played up. They are allowing short people to apply to be astronauts; I wouldn't consider that championing inclusion and diversity.
- jhgb 6y agoGagarin did it before it was cool.
- barbazoo 6y agoI'd say we don't let the good be the enemy of the perfect. This is what the article said and at least include more people with disabilities than it did before, isn't that good? - They have a lower limb deficiency (for example, due to amputation or congenital limb deficiency). - They have a leg length difference. - They are of short stature (<130 cm).
- anthony_romeo 6y agoYou ignored the first bullet of the three, which was: "They have a lower limb deficiency (for example, due to amputation or congenital limb deficiency)"
- jhgb 6y agoTechnically, those are short people, too.
- kingsuper20 6y agoYou could argue that an optimum space-human has amputated legs.
- sterlind 6y agoI read a scifi story as a kid where the protagonist was paralyzed. in space, her disability actually gave her an advantage because she adapted much more easily to moving through the station.
- _Microft 6y agoAstronauts hook their feet under handles to stay in place while doing things on the I.S.S. They do this so extensively that they develop callus on top of their feet and loose it on their heels. Once back on Earth walking without hardened skin on the heels is said to be painful until they have re-developed it. Here is an account of astronaut Scott Kelly: https://www.businessinsider.com/scott-kelly-weirdest-thing-year-in-space-2016-2 https://www.businessinsider.com/scott-kelly-weirdest-thing-y...
- kingsuper20 6y agoThat's interesting but doesn't sound like much of a prosthetic to add to the proposed legless astronaut corps(tm). Somebody must have studied this. Effect of G-forces on amputees, perhaps there's less in the way of nutrition and oxygen needs. For that matter, I wonder what tests have been done to find natural differences in resource depletion depending on the individual, that sounds like an obvious selection point for a Mars mission or any other long-term isolation.
- dahfizz 6y agoProsthetics might work for someone missing the lower portion of their leg(s), but I don't think it would work for someone with a congenital limb deficiency. If they have no control of their legs, bolting on some extra hardware wouldn't do much.
- gostsamo 6y agoI'm blind and though a big cosmos fan, I know that I'm not fit for the job and would not expect to be included. However, this might not be true for people with other disabilities and if they are fit for the job, it is pretty logical the requirements to be adjusted in order to allow them to participate.
- standardUser 6y agoIn terms of novel space exploration, it would only make sense to compose a crew of smaller individuals who require less space, consume less food, produce less waste etc. There's a strong case to be made that a first time Mars mission, or similarly challenging feat, would be best undertaken by an all-female crew.
- baoqdau 6y agoPandering again. Let people with disabilities stay on Earth and continue posting on HackerNews.
- brotherofsteel 6y agoGiven how few people we can afford to send into space, is it too much to ask that we send the best people we have? Leave the identity politics back on Earth.
- NovemberWhiskey 6y agoWell, that seems to me to be an argument in favor of having the widest possible applicant pool, rather than narrowing it.
- gostsamo 6y agoI'm downvoting because you imply that having body abnormalities makes someone lower quality person. A disability should not be taken into account if it is not significant for the job (a rather personal bias).
- _aunn 6y agoi agree with the second half of your comment, but with regards to the first part, don’t you think that space travel — an endeavor that subjects the human body and mind to immense, unadapted-for stress — can/should only be undertaken by the most physically and mentally capable? we’re hardly experts at space travel (google says only 533 people have been to orbit). given that number, any disability is significant for the job of going to space at this point, especially when every action can potentially bring immediate death to everyone around you.
- gostsamo 6y agoWe are sending people in space for the last sixty years. Each of them has been monitored comprehensively and we know what are the stressors during those missions. Especially when it comes to height and legs, they doesn't mean much in zero gravity. If the person is tough enough to survive the acceleration, they should be good to go. The only real issue might be if the equipment has some hidden assumptions for the arm length of the user.
- 6y ago
- galgalesh 6y agoMy dream of going into space was shattered when I got the news that my heart was enlarged and I needed surgery to replace my aorta valve. Between the life-long dependence on blood thinners and the already-weakened heart, I don't think I'll ever be able to go.
- systemvoltage 6y agoMany people can’t become pilots (pre requisite) because of poor eye sight.
- redis_mlc 6y agoWell, the full story is ... The vast majority of pilot applicants don't really need to be concerned with their vision: - civil: will pass the vision requirements with correction to 20/20 near (the instrument panel) and far with glasses, contacts or surgery. - US military: last time I checked, one service allows laser surgery, and the others are evaluating it. I don't recommend eye surgery for civil pilots because of the risk of infection, sparkling, regulatory changes and changes in eye geometry in middle-age. Note that DUIs and epilepsy are disqualifying, and heart problems usually make things difficult. Source: pilot.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- freshair 6y ago> - US military: last time I checked, one service allows laser surgery, and the others are evaluating it. HUGE caveat here: They only allow eye surgery if they were the ones that did it. My brother had eye surgery when he was 3 years old, signed up with the Navy to be a pilot and only learned about this after he was signed. His vision is fine today and they let him be a naval flight officer, but they will never let him be a pilot.
- Jtsummers 6y agoUSAF's pilot vision requirements shift based on need and also aircraft type (which relates to number of applicants). For fighter aircraft they generally require 20/20 vision but permit correction for some candidates (particularly USAF Academy grads), usually up to 20/50-20/70 range. Many more people want to be fighter pilots than fly other kinds of aircraft so they can be picky here. For heavies (cargo, bomber) and helicopters that are less popular they may permit that range of correction for all candidates, not just Academy grads. For getting vision corrected, it was PRK only for a long time, no LASIK. I'm not sure the present rules. So long as your initial vision was within some range (I think better than 20/200 for a while there, again not sure of the current rules) and was corrected to 20/20-20/70 or so then you could qualify to become a pilot. Above 20/200 there are other issues with vision that start creeping in which causes them to ignore those candidates. However, it depends on current need. If they feel they have enough candidates and current pilots then they'll be stricter on the vision requirement (and other waiverable requirements like being just above/below the height range), when they hit their next pilot deficit because they were moronic and created another bathtub curve they'll relax the requirements again. Happens every decade.
- the_lonely_road 6y agoI’ve always wondered if NASAs obsession with “perfect astronauts” really had enough merit to warrant itself. My personal conspiracy theory was it was more about not losing face to the USSR then it was any practical need.
- mzkply 6y agoSure it does, and it has nothing to do with another country. They will take 10 years teaching astronauts about everything from orbital dynamics to spacewalking to Siberian survival. It's literally millions of dollars spent on one person, so you need to maximize the probability of success. It's why they go for perfectly healthy people, both physically and mentally. Can't have someone quickly out of breath, or someone who breaks down in a stressful situation.
- ksdale 6y agoI always thought of it as a tolerances thing. The stronger/fitter (for certain definitions of those words), and the smarter (ditto), the more slack you have built into the system. On the average space flight, an average person is just fine, but when things go sideways, it's better to have someone with very exceptional abilities. That's also not to say that seeking "perfect" astronauts selects for the most ideal abilities, but that was my thinking about what they were going for.
- caturopath 6y agoGiven the large number of people wanting the job and the low number of positions, pruning it in even a tiny-merit way seems like a nice strategy to employ. It's not like you're cutting anyone who could be predicted to be a gamechanger; there's only so much utility you can get out of an astronaut, I think.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anthony_romeo 6y agoThis is great forward-thinking. It's rarely too early to think about people with disabilities. Setting up some structure to allow reasonable accommodations early will help avoid a need to later 'open up' space travel to others when it [hopefully] becomes more commonplace. This sort of research ought to be done now while we're still in a nascent phase of space travel. Disclaimer: I don't know much about the typical protocols of astronauts and the engineering required for safe space travel, but I do know a thing or two about disabilities.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoReminds me of climbers and runner without real legs that can out perform the legged due to their use of carbon fiber. https://www.wndu.com/content/news/Blade-runners-The-future-of-prosthetics-565439842.html https://www.wndu.com/content/news/Blade-runners-The-future-o...
- philwelch 6y agoThe Atomic Rockets website (which is a great resource in general) has an interesting section about disabled astronauts: http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/crew.php#id--Crew_Candidates--Disabled_Or_Not http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/crew.php#id--Cr...?
- wintorez 6y agoSome forms of disability could be useful in the context of space exploration. For example, using colostomy bags could make longer spacewalks possible and also remove space toilets altogether.
- _u1dn 6y agoSpace exploration seems difficult and delayed enough without this virtue signaling. Supporting disabilities would add a number of new challenges on top of the existing ones, and with marginal practical benefit (increasing the pool of potential astronauts by the small minority that have disabilities). Being an astronaut is a ridiculously selective process, it’s not like disabled people are missing out on something here that’s accessible to any non-disabled person. The opportunity for someone to get into space, whether disabled or not, is almost nil regardless.
- anthony_romeo 6y agoThis is a bad take and arbitrarily discriminatory, and I don't like this sort of reactionary anti-virtue signalling I've been seeing a lot on HN recently. You did not establish that the "new challenges" are especially difficult to overcome, nor that they're not worth undertaking. There can be a lot to learn through this process, and that by itself is valuable. YOU seem to believe that there is only marginal practical benefit, but I can't quite understand why you believe that merely increasing the pool of applicants is a bad idea [and the European Space Agency seems to disagree with you as well]. I'm curious on the specifics of your interpretation. It might be a "ridiculously selective process," but the specific restrictions within that process are, to some degree, arbitrary. They're certainly worth reconsidering and expanding from time-to-time as technology/safety improves, especially since we're getting closer to an age of commercial space flight where people with disabilities will have more access to space flight regardless of what any specific space agency will do.
- _u1dn 6y agoI didn’t say that increasing the pool was a bad idea. In fact, I said it’s a benefit, albeit a marginal one because it’s a relatively small % of people we’re talking about here. The problem is that it comes at a cost. Furthermore, while we’re on the subject of pool increase, it’s also vastly lowering the selection pool if they favor people from this small group. There may be aspects of the selection process that are arbitrary, but not having physical disabilities isn’t one of them. As the article discusses, this would involve changing a number of aspects about the program to accommodate this one specific group. It’s not just a matter of “reconsidering and expanding” the restrictions, it’s clearly a major undertaking.
- hirundo 6y agoFor an astronaut could having legs be a relative disability? It seems to me that ableism is a very good thing with respect to choosing astronauts, but different in micro- than in macro-gravity. A disabled earthling could make an unusually able spaceling.