7 ms·
The Chernobyl disaster is simply unimaginably expensive. The total costs so far are estimated to be in the hundreds of billions of dollars. The new containment
by wongarsu 6y ago
The Chernobyl disaster is simply unimaginably expensive. The total costs so far are estimated to be in the hundreds of billions of dollars. The new containment structure that was finished in 2019 was $2,000,000,000 alone, and dismantling the reactors and cleanup is scheduled to take another 45 years.
- faitswulff 6y agoIt’s the most expensive wildlife refuge in the world.
- ryanmarsh 6y ago$2B is table stakes for anything in heavy industry. I haven't heard of a new oil refinery for anything less than $10B in a while. I'm not saying Chernobyl wasn't a disaster. I'm just saying, as far as heavy industry goes $2B isn't much. I know that's hard to fathom but it's true.
- philistine 6y agoYeah but that refinery starts making money at some point. With Chernobyl, the $2B is completely gone.
- barkingcat 6y agoNot to mention the site will need to continually rebuild the sarcophagus around it until half-lifing makes the sarcophagus unneeded. The current one is only designed to last 100 years.
- KptMarchewa 6y ago"only"
- barkingcat 6y agoYes "only", meaning it's insufficient for the long run. It's estimated that the ruins will remain highly radiactive for 20,000 years, meaning that a scarcophagus-like containment is needed at least for that long. If human technology remains as is (ok I am really hoping for tech advancements in this area), we will need to build 200 of such structures if the design specifications work as planned. The area is only "safe" because we keep the site contained. Without renewal of the containment structure, the radiation will spread. https://www.power-technology.com/features/making-chernobyl-safe-a-timeline/ https://www.power-technology.com/features/making-chernobyl-s... "Meanwhile, Reactor No. 4, now covered by the New Safe Confinement, is estimated to remain highly radioactive for up to 20,000 years. "
- KptMarchewa 6y agoWe do fuck all about carbon dioxide killing our planet, but are "extremely concerned" about the fact that people will have to spend some money on one building. That's as close to "non-concern" as we can have.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoOn the scale of the relevant half lives, yes, "only" a century:)
- throwawayboise 6y agoThe objective of the New Safe Confinement is to shelter the site and allow for safe demolition of the structure and disposal of the material on the site. There will probably be some sort of "cap" over the site for a long time but it will not need to be as expensive or technically sophisticated once that work is done.
- barkingcat 6y agoI'm considering the "safe demolition and disposal" to cost multiple orders of what it would cost to rebuild the containment ... so yes, at some point the new containment cap need not be as expensive, but by the time we have gotten to that point, the site will probably have consumed a lot more money than just building the same containment over and over again. Some future leader(s) would probably do the calculations and just say "let's build another 100-year-containment so the next generation can deal with the disposal" and pocket the money. It's the "tech debt" discussion embodied in real life.
- arcticbull 6y agoA new nuclear plant can cost up to $10B. Spending $2B per 100 years to keep the worst disaster in nuclear energy safe and secure doesn't actually sound like a bad deal to me, in context. Of course the actual disaster in totality cost much more - up to $700B in impairment [1], overwhelmingly opportunity cost. Further, consider that the Chernobyl complex did already produce value, and for many years. In fact, there were four reactors at Chernobyl. No. 4 is the one that suffered the catastrophic failure in 1986. However the remaining 3 reactors continued to operate for many years. No. 2 was shut down in 1991, No. 1 was shut down in 1996 and No. 3 was shut down in 2000. Even that was reluctant, the Ukrainians only agreed to shut them down in exchange for assistance with the NSC and putting up 2 new reactors, Khmelnitski 2 and Rovno 4. [1] https://globalhealth.usc.edu/2016/05/24/the-financial-costs-of-the-chernobyl-nuclear-power-plant-disaster-a-review-of-the-literature/ https://globalhealth.usc.edu/2016/05/24/the-financial-costs-...
- merb 6y ago> A new nuclear plant can cost up to $10B you forget the $40B in cleanup costs if no disaster happens, of course disaster or cleanup costs will be socialized in "developed" countries. all cleanup costs were grosly underestimated, in germany and everywhere else.
- ryanmarsh 6y agoConsidering renovation of one of the reactors in the STP (South Texas Project) nuclear plant cost ~$5B I find that $10B suspiciously low. The renovation project I was made aware of was supposed to be done by Fluor. I don't know if it took place. The Wikipedia page for STP talks about some $10-14B for two new reactors on the existing site. Originally applied for circa'07. If the reactors ever get built they will cut down on natural gas usage and be more more profitable than gas plants over their 25+ year lifespan. I can only imagine a modern net-new nuclear power generation facility in the most hospitable jurisdiction would cost beyond $20B when all is said and done.
- advisedwang 6y ago$2B is just the new containment structure. Wikipedia lists the original cleanup as costing $68B (inflation adjusted). This article [1] lists the total economic cost as $700B [1] https://www.thebalance.com/chernobyl-nuclear-power-plant-disaster-economic-impact-3306335 https://www.thebalance.com/chernobyl-nuclear-power-plant-dis...
- KingOfCoders 6y agoI remember all the vegetables etc. thrown away / not eaten in Germany back then - especially mushrooms (not vegetables, not animals I know) if I remember correctly.
- chihuahua 6y agoI remember having to drink powdered milk instead of regular milk for months afterwards. I thought it was very unpleasant. Apparently there was fallout on the grass that cows would eat, resulting in radioactive milk?
- gmueckl 6y agoAs a result of the Chernobyl accident, Mushrooms and wildlife feeding on them are still showing elevated levels of radioactive Caesium-137 in the Bavarian Forest and other parts of Bavaria. These levels are still monitored closely, even though they aren't considered dangerous anymore. Still, they are beyond the levels required by food safety standards.
- Gibbon1 6y agoAll I got to say is the Japanese are really lucky the wind wasn't blowing onshore during the meltdown.
- gmueckl 6y agoIt wasn't that: The Fukushima reactors didn't contain graphite moderators that started to burn. In Chernobyl, this graphite fire carried fuel and fission products high into the atmosphere.
- cesaref 6y agoSheep farmers in Wales were still being affected by this in 2012, with testing performed on lambs and restrictions on which could be sold and which land they could be raised on due to radioactivity in the soil and hence grass. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-17472698 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-17472698 Just to put this in perspective, the affected part of wales in something like 1,500 miles from Chernobyl. I would guess some freak of the weather conditions caused Wales to be badly affected.
- kewrkewm53 6y agoStill cheaper than the Iraq and Afghan war though.
- arethuza 6y agoThe Chernobyl accident was arguably a major factor in the eventual downfall of the Soviet Union and therefore the end of the Cold War so perhaps some good did come from those awful events.
- dcgudeman 6y agoWho is arguing that? I never seen any credible evidence that it contributed in any significant way to the collapse of the Soviet Union.
- arethuza 6y agoMikhail Gorbachev for one https://slate.com/technology/2013/01/chernobyl-and-the-fall-of-the-soviet-union-gorbachevs-glasnost-allowed-the-nuclear-catastrophe-to-undermine-the-ussr.html https://slate.com/technology/2013/01/chernobyl-and-the-fall-... Edit: Chernobyl: The History of a Nuclear Catastrophe by Serhii Plokhy also makes a claim that the accident let to political instability in the Ukraine which certainly didn't help with the integrity of the SU.
- yc12340 6y agoGorbachev is directly responsible for collapse of USSR, — he ruled it when it collapsed. So he is responsible for both of the disasters. Shouldn't you be a little skeptical, when he tries to blame one of his disasters for another?
- arethuza 6y agoOf course I'm sceptical - but given other accounts of the times that I have read I haven't seen anything in his account that seems fundamentally wrong.
- GordonS 6y agoBy comparison, BP paid around $65 billion for the Deepwater Horizon cleanup, fines and claims [0] [0] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-bp-deepwaterhorizon-idUSKBN1F50NL https://www.reuters.com/article/us-bp-deepwaterhorizon-idUSK...
- dmos62 6y ago> BP was paid around $65 billion That's "BP paid", I believe.
- drran 6y agoThe Chornobyl disaster is so expensive, that it collapsed the Soviet Union and put a hard burden on economies of Ukraine and Belarus for 20+ years. The full price of cheap nuclear energy is extremely high.
- gfodor 6y agoGood news: we've paid for it, it was the costs associated with learning from these kinds of failures.
- edoceo 6y agoI hate that you're right. I wish experience wasn't such an expensive teacher.
- UI_at_80x24 6y agoI love that quote, it reminds me of a similar one: >If you think education is expensive, try ignorance.
- dylan604 6y agoI feel like we are doing that right now. We had our Age of Enlightenment. I feel like we are heading for Dark Ages 2.0.
- bioinformatics 6y agoI guess the price for communism, corruption, mismanagement, censorship it way higher than nuclear energy. But, hey what do I know, experienced Chernobyl when it happened.
- yosito 6y agoWhile Chernobyl may have played a role in the Soviet Union's collapse, it wasn't the only factor, and it wasn't the financial cost of the disaster that contributed to the collapse, but the loss of public trust in government.
- 6y ago
- mekal 6y agoIf hundreds of billions to address the first nuclear meltdown in world history is unimaginably expensive, what do you call the "conservative" estimate of covid-19's total cost of "$16 Trillion" for the US alone? Source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7604733/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7604733/ And that's assuming its all taken care of by fall of 2021.
- splithalf 6y agoThere’s a cost to building back better.
- irrationalPpl 6y agoI tried to explain this here but was flagged by mods rather than downvotes. Emotions beat out statistics, optimism beat out realistic expectations. I know our politicians aren't scientists but even the majority of the intellectual class completely blew it. I'm not sure how, but it would be beneficial to humanity to use this event as a filter for logical intellectuals and emotional intellectuals.
- wongarsu 6y agoIn terms of cost per citizen that's actually the same order of magnitude as the $700 billion quoted here [1] (if as citizens we count Ukraine and Belarus, which is of course not totally fair). But yes, Covid is also incredibly expensive, and with a couple of years of hindsight we will no doubt talk about its major political impact just like we are talking about Chernobyl contributing to the fall of the Soviet Union. 1: https://globalhealth.usc.edu/2016/05/24/the-financial-costs-of-the-chernobyl-nuclear-power-plant-disaster-a-review-of-the-literature/ https://globalhealth.usc.edu/2016/05/24/the-financial-costs-...