13 ms·
Clubhouse downloads are falling
- 0xy 6y agoUtility is gone, and all that's left is crypto scammers and "entrepreneurs" selling Amazon dropshipping master classes. When Clubhouse is acquired or implodes, it will serve as a cautionary tale on how quality control is an essential element of social media.
- rchaud 6y ago"Quality control" for some would be "censorship" for others. If nothing else, that would at still be enough for a HN post with several hundred comments.
- asah 6y agoSearch engines use ranking functions to promote higher quality content, while allowing determined users to still find the obscure, unpopular, trashy and dangerous. They just needed a decent search/recommendations engine.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoClubhouse was lightning in a bottle. It also proves that some things just can't scale, no matter how much money and star-power you can throw at it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xtracto 6y agoWhat's old is new... I remember around 2006 Skype had a feature that allowed you to "host" talks. The community made some interesting channels, and I used to participate in some of them. Eventually the feature was dropped, and I haven't found a place that could substitute that. But yeah, that's a feature, not a product.
- ALittleLight 6y agoThis is a good thing to consider. I'm setting a reminder for myself in ten years to create a clubhouse clone. If one exists then I'll just snooze another decade.
- jfengel 6y agoQuora was an interesting example of that. They seeded it with some big names, especially from venture capital and Silicon Valley culture. That attracted a lot of eyeballs quickly, and for a while, some very good content (mostly not from the big names but from its diverse user base, and some good writers achieved notoriety). That wasn't very lucrative, and they've spent the last few years spending that goodwill to attract lower-quality content but more page views. Eventually that will cause its hard-earned SEO to drop off, but today they seem to feel its the best way to monetize what they developed from that early money and star-power.
- SilverRed 6y agoQ&A does scale. As much as people shit talk StackExchange, they have done an excellent job keeping the platform high quality and it's leaps and bounds ahead of any other Q&A platform.
- Graffur 6y agodid clubhouse have any star power?
- ryanSrich 6y agoDepending on how you define star power, it had Musk, Rogan, among 100s of other well known celebrities in the early days. Not sure if any of those stuck around, but they certainly attracted the right people early on.
- Graffur 6y agoAh, I thought you mean star-developer/employees. Yes they had some big names, although I heard Joe Rogan went on it once and said he wouldn't go back on it.
- blueyes 6y agoBen Thompson has some intelligent comments on this, and what he got wrong, here: https://stratechery.com/2021/market-making-and-time-horizons-clubhouse-struggling-what-did-i-get-wrong/ https://stratechery.com/2021/market-making-and-time-horizons...
- 1cvmask 6y agoI think Clubhouse is great in many ways. It’s initial rawness and authenticity and the lack of gatekeepers. They failed to come out with an Android version in over a year after so much funding, and now in their iOS markets they are battling the return to normalcy with vaccinations and the opening up of societies.
- reidjs 6y agoI see the lack of an Android app as a feature. People who really want to use it will just get a cheap iPhone, I gave Android using friend my old iPhone 7. Most of the fun is the mix of exclusivity while still being able to chat with B-tier celebrities on a whim. Supporting Android means more users, which means we will have to sift through even more “Hodl BTC Gamestonk xD” rooms to get to the interesting rooms.
- meibo 6y agoIf your social network relies on having less users to be good, you might have a problem in your long-term business model(especially considering the funding they've already gotten).
- reidjs 6y agoHow is that not a viable business model? Who says every social network has to be for everybody?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- diveanon 6y agoThis idiotic elitist mentality serves no one. You aren't special because you purchased a product made by the largest consumer product company on the planet.
- sv123 6y agoFunny, more users is exactly what they need.
- dqpb 6y agoHow many times do I have to hide rooms about “Worship and Prayer” or “Manifest Infinite Wealth” before clubhouse will get the hint?
- simongr3dal 6y agoI didn't feel like hunting through my network for an invite, so I'm still waiting for my sms to sign up. They should have scaled their inviting quicker if they didn't want alienate people and lose them.
- rognjen 6y agoI don't really care about Clubhouse one way or another but if your article uses the phrase "falling off a cliff" I think you should have a graph where you can see that cliff.
- themanmaran 6y agoJan: 2.4M Feb: 9.6M Mar: 7.2M Apr: 0.9M
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deathanatos 6y agoYou've transposed the numbers for March. It was 2.7M in the article. Jan: 2.4M Feb: 9.6M Mar: 2.7M Apr: 0.9M (edit: and I replicated the error facepalm)
- jmt_ 6y ago"Clubhouse saw about 922,000 downloads globally in April, a 66% dip from 2.7 million installs in March and a surge of 9.6 million in February, a Sensor Tower spokesperson shared with Insider." A graph would have been handy, but I would say a 2/3 reduction in new installs qualifies as a cliff. They note however that retention is ostensibly strong, so this cliff might not be as scary as it sounds, at least in the short term.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 6y agoAt least the google trends graph [1] very much deserves the phrasing [1]: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?q=clubhouse https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?q=clubhouse
- anonytrary 6y ago
- underseacables 6y agoI signed up for the novelty of it but it’s not what I hoped it would be, or perhaps I just haven’t found the right rooms. I really hoped this was more of a salon in the old Victorian way. Gather to listen to someone lecture. I would pay for that to hear good speakers lecture in private without fear or worry of disruption etc.
- janekm 6y agoWhat would be the benefit over podcasts / video recordings of lectures?
- SAI_Peregrinus 6y agoI'd guess an ability to ask questions after the lecture.
- toomuchredbull 6y agoThis piece is missing. The audience can't do much. They should at least have chat while people are on stage. Seems like an obvious feature to increase participation.
- janekm 6y agoThis is actually something that both Twitch and Youtube can do fairly well. Several science Youtubers put on lectures for school students studying from home, it's a nice format. Of course that's video... but at least with the YouTube subscription you can listen to the audio without the video.
- werber 6y agoThey went crazy with their notifications. They had levels of contact and at the lowest level my phone was alerting me about content that i didn't find relevant more than any app, including the phone and text messaging. They ended up annoying me off the platform
- offtop5 6y agoThis is how all social media apps eventually work. Apps know you get an endorphin rush every time a notification comes. Even if the notification doesn't show anything relevant, it MIGHT be important so you hurry to open it. I had to quit these apps over this, maybe some people are able to handle constant meaningless stimulation, but I can't.
- karatinversion 6y agoI aggressively turn off notification privileges from apps. One "engagement" notification and they are gone. Works a treat.
- ghaff 6y agoI don't know how people who get notified about everything manage. For me it's basically just text messaging and calendar.
- offtop5 6y agoThey don't. Anxiety is though the roof. I don't waste time arguing about this, but I don't use social media / online dating. It wasn't good for me emotionally. I've still done very well meeting people.
- trts 6y agoYep. The first week I joined clubhouse I spent >10 hours on the platform, it was fascinating to see high profile people drop into rooms and be able to participate in ad hoc conversation with them. But the notifications were constant. Once I turned them off, I forgot about the app almost completely. After I did this, I realized how little time I had to allocate to hearing other people banter. It's already the case that I miss some great podcasts because of time constraints. It also started to seem like an audio-version of Twitter with all of the negativity and in/out group dynamics that are common there.
- Tycho 6y agoNot exactly sure what their strategy around room discovery is. I can't search all rooms. I can't block key words. Is this just for lack of engineers, or is it some galaxy brain scheme to keep me engaged?
- ryanSrich 6y agoI can’t imagine it’s a lack of engineers. They’ve raised over $100m dollars. That’s a lot of well paid engineers. https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/clubhouse-voice https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/clubhouse-voice
- bern4444 6y agoI agree and find this is the largest problem I face on clubhouse. Room discovery is hard. Titles and descriptions are often poorly written and inaccurate. I also often find the conversations to be far less insightful and interesting than I expected. I was hoping there would be more interesting discussions and lectures. Instead many rooms often feel a bit like a circle jerk for the hosts. Perhaps this is an issue in Clubhouse's ability to validate who people are. I have no idea if the person speaking is actually credible. Maybe Twitter spaces will be better since they have the blue check mark system and I can have confidence that the people speaking are known to some degree.
- saurik 6y agoThe design of Clubhouse doesn't start with rooms: it starts with people. You follow people you want to listen to, and when they happen to be in rooms--rooms either they started or that were started by someone they know who they follow and so they joined and were invited on stage--you get notifications and see those rooms on your list. You don't go into Clubhouse searching for rooms--they didn't even try to add features to let you rhino about rooms until December, and it frankly felt like they simply gave up on their vision--you search for people. (FWIW, that a system where you value people above content, and where rooms largely fork out of cliques of people who want to be associated with each other's followers, leads to "a circle jerk for the hosts", as you call it, might be obvious... at least in retrospect ;P.)
- perardi 6y agoHuh, the novelty of a sweaty, desperate conference call where you try to get the attention of some venture capitalist wore off quickly. Who would have thought?
- motohagiography 6y agoThey have a vouching problem, which Richard Feynman described the dynamic well in honor socieites, where once you were on the inside, most of the effort went into figuring out how to attract the people you wanted and continue to signal your status, while keeping others out. I've been invited into quite a few exclusive social networks (scenes, clubs, societies, networks, etc.) and they all have a similar dynamic. There is a core group annointed by someone legendary who doesn't really participate much, a senate of old guard who run things in the background, some quirky legacies who are tolerated but marginal, a few social queen bee types who gatekeep and police the tone, and then a lot of social butterflies who promote and attract people into the gateway funnel. It's the model of leader/essentials/influentials/interchangeables model. What I'd speculate happened (or will) is they didn't have a good funnel because the top influentials were too high stakes, and it creates the incentive for arrivistes to knock the ladder away behind them, which tanks growth. Clubhouse doesn't have enough privacy to invite your friend who might attract tone police attention, and growth depends on being able to select from those very people in a funnel. Basically, the path from outsider to interchangeable to the more socially secure influential level is too unstable, and strivers won't invite their off-brand friends. Where I have seen other networks and scenes grow is you need a lobby that is attractive to people, and then once you are on the other side of it, you are securely inside, at least the first level. It requires a layer of real privacy and privilege, and even relative secrecy. Maybe Clubhouse secretly has that now, but it's perhaps too secret, as this article is about how their funnel into their pipeline is drying up.
- Syzygies 6y agoCompelling analysis. From reading meta-histories such as "Guns, Germs, and Steel" or "Sapiens", I get the impression that various organized religions exploited these same dynamics. I always imagined that Karl Rove had a heavily marked-up copy of "Guns, Germs, and Steel" as he manipulated politics, paying particular attention to the sections on religion. This should also be required reading for anyone staking their livelihood on a social media startup.
- ahoy 6y agoI think any discussion of "Guns, Germs, and Steel" needs to come with the caveat that the author (Jared Diamond) is widely criticized by the greater historical/anthropological/poli-sci community for prioritizing narrative in his books over scientific accuracy. "Guns" is still a good read, as long as you don't stop there.
- system16 6y agoNot surprised. I gave it a shot early on, but it just wasn't for me. Listening to a bunch self-proclaimed "thought leaders" tell almost biblical tales about their struggles that lead to their dubious success, followed by an "ok, let's reset the room" and then a bunch of back patting about how great and positive the group is, and then starting over again was just cringe inducing and painful. The ONLY Clubhouse use I found actually interesting was when the developer behind Hacking with Swift used it to hold mock iOS developer interviews, inviting attendees to step up and try to answer a mock interview question. Of my friends who Clubhouse did appeal too, many were hooked for a couple of weeks. Today none of them use it at all anymore. The consensus is generally "it was interesting at first, but now it's really boring."
- stemlord 6y ago>Listening to a bunch self-proclaimed "thought leaders" tell almost biblical tales about their struggles that lead to their dubious success, followed by an "ok, let's reset the room" and then a bunch of back patting about how great and positive the group is I don't understand how there's so little criticism about this desire to keep such (apparently) valuable knowledge from "thought leaders" confined to an exclusive club. I always sensed the overwhelming consensus among us all (tech people, namely) was that such information should be made free and accessible? Is being a member of some dumb hyped up app really more interesting for so many of us?
- grensley 6y agoProbably because it reduces the amount of said "thought leaders" on other platforms. In my opinion, the signal-to-noise ratio isn't great.
- tclancy 6y agoIt's because the knowledge isn't that valuable usually. It's prized because of its exclusiveness. Most anyone who describes themself as a thought leader is probably full of hot air. A more cynical person might suggest it's like how much of the success attributed to college isn't what one learns as much as the connections one makes.
- 6y ago
- mahadeep 6y agoThere is a lot of meeting fatigue due to WFH. People are probably preferring async platforms. Imagine spending an hour only to find it waste.
- ryanSrich 6y agoReally interesting to see these numbers knowing they just closed a round that valued them at $4 billion. a16z had to have seen this trend coming. I wonder what they’re seeing that we aren’t.
- dannyw 6y agoThey're in a delusional silicon valley bubble.
- spoonjim 6y agoThey just made $10 billion on Coinbase, they can afford a lot of misses.
- mrkramer 6y agoWins and loses do not cancel each other out. When you win you win when you lose you lose but I can agree that at the end of the day balance sheet is what matters. Cryptocoins are fad, technology and concepts behind them are important. Coinbase is nothing but a bucket shop. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bucket_shop_(stock_market) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bucket_shop_(stock_market)
- cblconfederate 6y agoMaybe their top influencers were being sincere†. Maybe it was very good and convenient app for them, perhaps because it acted as a good voice recorder / orchestration tool for their podcasts. What they didn't realize is that the listeners have a totally different viewpoint † I think a lot of it was paid publicity
- afavour 6y agoMaybe I'm too cynical but Clubhouse always felt like a weird pyramid scheme. It was huge solely because a core group of people said it was huge. VCs hyping a VC investment to a sky-high valuation and bringing lots of VC-aspiration little people along with them as reinforcement. And I guess it worked, they got a valuation of $4bn! But now what?
- whb07 6y agoYep, this is my exact feeling. Really felt like Ben Horowitz fell in love and maybe coaxed/cut-in his rapper friends to help push this real quick. Maybe one of his buddies kept saying “yo Ben, when can I make an investment just like Ashton Kutcher or Bieber?!” Heavy lies the crown
- rchaud 6y agoA16z has been doing this Substack for months. First it was the disingenuous blog post from one of their partners about how "100 True Fans"[0] can make you monetize your content Then they started paying journalists to post on Substack, while writing pieces about how media bureaucracy is chasing away top talent, who are "choosing" (aka being paid) to write on Substack. [0]: https://a16z.com/2020/02/06/100-true-fans/ https://a16z.com/2020/02/06/100-true-fans/
- version_five 6y agoClubhouse reminded me of the description in Neuromancer of the trends (I think the relevant example was the Panther Moderns) that emerge out of nothing, become prominent, and then disappear within a couple weeks. It's not at all surprising that this happens with a social network, what I find more interesting is that there is a better opportunity to capitalize on it by purposely embracing "disposability" and grabbing some value out of it as it runs its course, instead of insisting that it be a longer term play that demands a bunch of VC funding and whatever demands come with trying to maintain that valuation.
- skilesare 6y agoThere was so much promise. After a year of quarantine I had 5 of my most interesting non work/family conversations of the year in a one week period. There was no real way for me to connect with those people without wading into the morass of twitter or instagram. I tried to build a tool (https://inof.me https://inof.me) to help people connect by providing an invitation and an asking for an offer. No one was really interested...it needed to be integrated into the platform to work. I couldn't block topics. I couldn't search for terms of active channels. I couldn't politely ping interesting people and ask if they'd like to set up a time to chat. I love talking about decaying currency, certain(non-NFT) blockchain topics, Longhorn football, some philosophy topics, etc and I'll talk to anyone about them most all of the time if I can find a conversation partner(especially during quarantine). I had no real way to make those connection on clubhouse even though I had spoken with interested folks previously. Most of all, I couldn't catch up. If an amazing conversation happened that you were late to...too bad. You couldn't explore and find if the person speaking was really trustworthy by looking at their back catalogs. I wanted a clubhouse that lets me pay $9.99 a month to have access to a back catalogs that will let me listen to the interesting conversations that occurred in the past about very long-tail specific topics. Then I want to star those people with different color stars and notification levels so that if they start talking again I can quickly see what kind of conversation it is and jump in. If I'm late I want to back up 30 minutes and listen at 1.75x until I'm caught up. Give me the knobs and dials to customize my experience.
- skellera 6y agoGuy Raz makes a good point in the How I Built This episode with the Clubhouse founders. You can have a really interesting conversation with someone but that conversation doesn’t necessarily make good radio that’s interesting to others. So much of that catalog would be gurus repeating the same stuff over and over again. It would be so hard to sort through all of it to the find interesting parts. I think it’s wonderfully interesting to be pulled into the conversations of people I look up to because it feels genuine. But once the masses join the platform, everything becomes so curated to specific topics that it loses the magic. It isn’t any better than a badly produced podcast or blog. Live audio and video will still be the future but this isn’t it. Or, isn’t yet.
- skilesare 6y agoWhen I heard that they were going to monetize with 'tipping' my heart sank. If ever there was an opportunity for 'a rising tide lifts all boats' style social experiment, clubhouse was it. Charge a subscription, let people listen to long tail content that interests them, pay the people that get listened to. You incentives the creation of interesting conversations. It would have been like a giant long tail podcast generator where serendipity and intellect could spin out a lot of new ideas. Boo.
- diveanon 6y agoIs it on android yet?
- tzury 6y agoI had clubhouse for nearly two days on my phone before I removed it, and that was a day more than Tinder managed to survive. I simply could not find anything interesting to listen to on Clubhouse. Perhaps I am not an "App" person.
- gregsadetsky 6y agoIt’s hard not to think of this twitter thread from almost 2 months ago which laid a compelling case for how it would go down. Threaded: https://threader.app/thread/1371972261004070913 https://threader.app/thread/1371972261004070913 Twitter: https://twitter.com/shaanvp/status/1371972261004070913 https://twitter.com/shaanvp/status/1371972261004070913
- adam 6y agoReminded of this Twitter thread from a couple months ago about how this will all go down: https://twitter.com/ShaanVP/status/1371972261004070913 https://twitter.com/ShaanVP/status/1371972261004070913
- pygar 6y agoI'm personally turned off by the live nature of it. In the same way that I don't particularly like voice messages. At least with text (even in chat rooms), you can edit and condense. Also I dont have anything particularly interesting to say and I don't want to listen to blowhards who think they do.
- whatever_dude 6y agoEh, tornado chasing "thought leaders" and "influencers" can only get so many people interested in a product before reality comes knocking. After the gimmick is gone, it's just another poor product with little to offer.
- dqpb 6y agoI wanted to hear Elon Musk talk to Vladimir Putin. Instead it’s like I stumbled into some kind of weird new age multi level marketing crypto mega church summit.
- m3kw9 6y agois as simple as when you need people to constantly scheduling for hour long non pro live talk shows, it isn’t gonna work. You may get a few heavy hitters, but most are just random people chiming in. The drop off is high.
- etaioinshrdlu 6y agoThis data is from a nice shady company, Sensor Tower: https://www.cnet.com/news/sensor-tower-used-vpn-ad-blocking-apps-to-secretly-grab-user-data-report-says/ https://www.cnet.com/news/sensor-tower-used-vpn-ad-blocking-...
- Camas 6y agoShady as in the data is unreliable or shady as in you have an ethical disagreement?
- etaioinshrdlu 6y agoEthical, although I suspect the data is also not too great: it's the subset of users using questionable VPN apps. Good enough to determine that Clubhouse story is accurate though, most likely.
- mrkramer 6y agoSo ad hominem attack not relevant in any meaningful discussion.
- villgax 6y agoAnd without a sharing option or being able to login from a website it is very limiting & unnecessary device app installation needed
- villgax 6y agoIt was laughable how despite Agora having Android SDKs they were not able to bring in an Android version
- evolve2k 6y agoI was curious to get started until I heard of their serious disregard for user privacy.
- npv789 6y ago$4B