3 ms·
I might have missed existing discussion, but what is wrong with GPS coordinates? If digits are good enough for NATO fire missions, they're probably good enough
by nicbou 6y ago
I might have missed existing discussion, but what is wrong with GPS coordinates? If digits are good enough for NATO fire missions, they're probably good enough for lost hikers.
- They're ubiquitous and do not require a shared codebook. I can find my GPS coordinates on a paper map.
- They are easy to transmit clearly regardless of medium, language or accent. Digits are the first words you'll learn in any language. Pronunciation can't be taken for granted [1].
- They offer unlimited precision, but 10-12 digits are enough to pinpoint your exact location [2]
- They let you see where you stand relative to another person on the same grid. It's a bit like trying to find your friend in Manhattan.
- They let you picture where someone roughly is without even looking at the map. You can perform error correction as the digits are being read to you. If someone is off-grid, you can tell immediately. This scene [3] comes to mind - the officer is calling a fire mission in the wrong country, and everyone can immediately tell.
Take Berlin - 52.5200 N, 13.4050 E: "Five Two Point Five Two North - One Three Point Four Zero Five Zero East".
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yR0lWICH3rY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yR0lWICH3rY
[2] https://xkcd.com/2170/ https://xkcd.com/2170/
[3] https://youtu.be/K9uXLzZyucI?t=87 https://youtu.be/K9uXLzZyucI?t=87
- Closi 6y agoThere are always exceptions, but one slight annoyance in the UK is that you can have the same coordinate but omitting the + or - at the start will change where it is (which if you are in line with Greenwich, for instance, can even be in the same town). This is effectively the same problem as stated in the blog post where similar numbers can lead to different places. Interestingly this can be seen in your example too. > - 52.5200 N, 13.4050 E If I read the "-" as a negative, this is in the middle of the ocean. If I read it as a delimiter from the sentence before, I get Germany. Not so much of a problem as you said Germany as a context clue, but if this was in the UK I would have two possible interpretations. For instance - 0.5 N, 300 E might be more of a challenge!
- nicbou 6y agoThis can be fixed without inventing a new system. Someone else in the thread gave an example of a mayday call that eliminates those issues. In any case, it's easier to figure out if the person meant east or west (or check both) than to figure out if they meant flour, flower, floor, lower or some other similar word. It becomes even sillier when you account for accents. I'm not sure how to pronounce certain English words, including flour. > If I read the "-" as a negative That shouldn't be a problem, since you'd hear the words over the phone, not in a HN comment.
- Closi 6y ago> That shouldn't be a problem, since you'd hear the words over the phone, not in a HN comment. I know, I just found it a little ironic that those coordinates could be misinterpreted considering the article was about misinterpreting words being a fundamental weakness of w3w :)
- nicbou 6y agoIf the goal is clarity on the internet, a Google Maps link ought to do it.
- out_of_protocol 6y agoThe only issue i have is: Is it "lon, lat" or "lat, lon". (If "N/S E/W is not specified and only + or - provided)
- chipsa 6y agoAmbiguity: Did I forget the N/S? Is it supposed to be +/-? Did I get Lat and Lon flipped? Is it decimal degrees or degrees minutes seconds? The decimal degrees vs DMS is the big one, by the way. Especially since it's not always obvious that it's one or the other. This is actually why the US military invented MGRS, which is a grid square reference (giving precision to 100km), then northing and easting coordinates (every pair of digits improves accuracy by 10x). And you may already be able to assume the map square, and give just the northing and easting numbers. Plus code is related, but instead of using northing and easting, it uses a 4x5 grid with alphanumeric ids, that then subdivide after getting your grid square, allowing change in precision just by truncation, instead of having to truncate the northing and easting values seperately. It's also slightly more compact, as the greater number base available compared to decimal allows less digits to be used, and therefore faster to write and communicate, especially over the phone.