6 ms·
The idea is that if something js 5z as durable but is 2x the price, its more economical. Secondly - there are areas like SF and London where house prices are l
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
The idea is that if something js 5z as durable but is 2x the price, its more economical.
Secondly - there are areas like SF and London where house prices are like 5x the national average because of land. Surely they can afford better materials?
- spenczar5 6y agoIt's more economical only if the original buyer is there to reap the benefits of the durability. Because American houses change hands so fast, durability is the next guy's problem. This is exacerbated by the fact that a huge number of homes are built by developers who want to sell the thing as soon as it's built, and then move on. In a long-term, societal sense, you're right that it's kind of irrational. It's really unfortunate.
- lazide 6y agoI wouldn’t take the economical argument too seriously on this front. One factor that is a big issue in Europe is energy efficiency, and recent/updated electrical. With so much of the stock being ancient, and societal trends towards keeping older structures (and large investments in very durable structures being more of a norm), they have huge issues with a large stock of very inefficient and difficult to upgrade or fix structures. It is entirely possible to make energy efficient and modern buildings in Europe of course - it just doesn’t happen as much (because there is so much existing stock), and it is REALLY expensive compared to the US. Even Munich which got bombed to smithereens and rebuilt not that long ago (so less a problem than most), it’s not common to have well insulated walls or what American’s would consider modern electrical. Lots of retrofit work, surface mounted outlets and conduit, etc. What most Americans would consider a normal remodel (adding a bathroom, changing the layout of some rooms though modifications to non-exterior walls, whatever) are essentially impossible or crazy expensive in many of these buildings too because of the concrete masonry construction. Wood frame construction is cheap and easy to reconfigure, drywall and wood frame is easy to rip off and upgrade what is underneath, then replace, and all of these are easy to stuff with insulation. They’re also remarkably strong, durable, and flexible. They do have flammability and pest issues, but those have good solutions in modern structures. They all do use a lot of wood; which is a bit of an issue now.
- cycrutchfield 6y agoYou will not find very many brick or stone buildings in SF...
- lmm 6y agoThe whole reason those areas are so expensive is extremely restrictive planning rules.
- nemo44x 6y agoI wouldn’t consider bricks better than wood. Especially in an earthquake prone area. Now, steel - that would be better. But if thinking about the future I think wood framing is superior. In many places in Europe the old brick or stone homes have a lot of issues by modern standards and they are expensive to renovate. They tend to have floor plans that made sense 200+ years ago but not today. Like small rooms to better conserve fireplace heat. But again, it’s very difficult to renovate these homes to have a sensible, modern floor plan. Old wood frame homes are fairly easy to renovate either to modernize or to renovate.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoThe only thing unusually expensive about houses in SF and London is the ground it's sitting on. Even a house that's going to fall over in a year would be worth 75% as much as one that would last 1000 years.