7 ms·
Major Depressive Disorders Have an Enormous Economic Impact
- ssivark 6y agoSuch a backward headline. The whole point of the economy is to enable human health and happiness; not the other way around!
- pmiller2 6y agoCould it be “the economy” is broken? Maybe it has been for a long time.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> The whole point of the economy is to enable human health and happiness; not the other way around! Agreed, however our economy serves to enrich asset owners, and the health and happiness of everyone else are afterthoughts.
- cmwelsh 6y agoUnfortunately, the capitalist system often ends up in rent-seeking. Property rights gives folks the rights to hoard resources and rent them out. This is a complicated topic with no clear yanswer. Obviously, owning, leveraging, and renting assets is a motivator and reward to those who are winning in the game.
- Nav_Panel 6y agoWow, it's almost as if the modern economic system itself is the problem... /s Their insistence on framing depression as if it were a biological illness (and not a result of the complex and historical interplay between psyche/desire and environment) is repulsive to me. Feels like blatant propaganda to discuss depression as "merely" an economic problem, in "scientific" american no less.
- quotemstr 6y ago> Wow, it's almost as if the modern economic system itself is the problem What makes you so sure that it's our economic system (inb4 "let's blame capitalism for everything") and not all the other aspects of modernity that make is isolated, atomized, and nihilistic?
- Nav_Panel 6y agoWe don't need to invoke "capitalism" to discuss the psychic distress involved in repetitive work schedules and, more generally, the expectations surrounding labor and wages, i.e. the modern economic system. The term contains too much, although I do personally agree with many critiques of capitalism.
- MattGaiser 6y agoBecause life as a hunter gatherer just a few days away from starvation at any point was less stressful? Generations upon generations of farming was less repetitive?
- Nav_Panel 6y agoI'm assuming you misread me, because I'm saying something to the effect of "reducing work hours and providing flexibility might be helpful for people, but the present social equilibria prevent that from happening, and mental health provides an excuse to avoid changing aspects of the economic system that have issues", and not some primitivist whatever. Also, stress alone isn't the issue here at all.
- monocasa 6y ago> Generations upon generations of farming was less repetitive? It was. Medieval serfs worked less than us. http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/hours_workweek.html http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/hours_w...
- Toks 6y ago
- pmoriarty 6y agoThe tech field is one that requires constant and ongoing self-development and learning, or you're just going to be left behind and gradually become all but unemployable (those who are able to carve out a niche by becoming an expert in an in-demand ancient technology like COBOL aside). But how do you get the energy and motivation for constant learning and self-development when you struggle to get out of bed every day, or are burnt out on tech altogether? Even if, against all odds, a depressed person manages to get a job, it's likely that doing it will feel meaningless and overwhelming, leading to a struggle not to quit, poor performance, and possibly firing. If you screw up at work because of depression, of course you're not going to make a good impression on your colleagues, making getting hired or recommended by them in the future even less likely. If one is out of work for extended periods of time, not only is that a drain on your savings, but also an economic drain on whoever helps you (whether that's family, friends, or society). Then there are the secondary economic effects of all that lost productivity that the depressed person could have contributed to the economy but didn't because of their depression. All of the deals that could have happened, all of the innovation that was missed, the people that they might have inspired, etc, have economic consequences that are difficult to quantify but that are real nevertheless. This doesn't even go in to the potentially drastic economic consequences of suicide, both to the family of the person who takes their life who might have been relying on them for sustenance, and because of the knock-on economic effects of depression and trauma of those affected.
- tinyhouse 6y agoThat is a real problem. Here is my advice to people in tech. First, don't think you can work in tech until you retire. Maybe you will. But burn out is real and it usually happens gradually. The key is to save (and invest) as much money as you can in your early career so that when the time comes you have options. That also means being active and looking for jobs every 2-3 years in order to improve your salary. (you'll also gain more experience by working for different companies) As for the learning part. Yes, finding motivation for self development is not easy when you're depressed or burned out. I'm not going to talk about dealing or treating depression since I'm not an expert. One thing I found helpful is developing different interests of mine since it solves the motivation problem. For example, recently I got into the world of investing and I'm learning a lot. This doesn't solve the problem of finding motivation for self development for work, but it helps in making me more productive and overall more excited about learning and doing.
- ditonal 6y ago> The number of US adults with MDD increased by 12.9%, from 15.5 to 17.5 million, between 2010 and 2018, whereas the proportion of adults with MDD aged 18–34 years increased from 34.6 to 47.5 If about half of young adults suffer from a disorder, it makes me question if it’s a disorder at all. And the noted impact of economic factors and things like Covid highlight the “nurture” aspect of the disorder instead of “nurture” (e.g. the “chemical imbalance” internet myth). I’ve been diagnosed with MDD, GAD, ADHD, and bipolar type 1 but after I suffered a manic episode while on psych meds , I really dug into the research of psychiatrists and now have the controversial opinion it’s very weak science riding on the coattails of the rest of Western medicine and is obviously influenced by the for profit pharmaceutical companies. The DSM 5 wasn’t even created in the open. Both as societies and as individuals, we need to introspect on how we can be so relatively wealthy yet so often so fundamentally unhappy. And the idea that half of the population has a brain disorder rather than is in a bad environment and conditioned by circumstances to feel that way seems hard to believe. I’m very interested in the anti psychiatry movement which includes a small minority of medical professionals, and I’m more open to sane ideas that I used to consider “new age.” But more than anything, I think many aspects of mental health are like losing weight - very simple but difficult especially in the wrong environment. Close family relationships, diet, exercise, time outdoors, a sense of community, less time on social media - we mostly know that this is the key to feeling better but we desperately want an easier answer in pill from someone in a white coat and our profit driven medical system is more than happy to oblige.
- ipnon 6y agoI hope that before dismissing you, any critics would lend weight to the fact that you have been diagnosed with several disorders and been through the psychiatric system. You have some skin in the game here. So even though your advice is certainly not universal and many perceive great benefit from psychiatric treatment, there is some truth to be had in your argument.
- caddemon 6y agoThe comment tone is way beyond advice and makes some bizarre claims about profit motives. Psychiatry is a hard subject and there has been some bad research, but it's pretty clear he has also done some reading on fringe sites. I understand being upset by shitty doctors and going down that rabbit hole, but it would be irresponsible to not respond to the comment when others on the fence about medication might be swayed. The key point he is missing is that psychiatric disease can make those lifestyle changes orders of magnitude harder for someone to make than it would be for a healthy adult. As lifestyle gets worse you get a terrible loop going. Medication helps many break that loop - certainly not all, but it is something to seriously consider with your doctor. If he was able to make those changes without medication that is great for him, but I think his message is kind of analogous to a rich entrepreneur that grew up poor telling everyone else they should just work harder and they'll move up in life. Is it probably good advice for those people to work harder? Yes, but many of them do not have the talent or luck to actually move up much, so it cheapens the message a lot.
- rsj_hn 6y agoAll of these "economic damage" studies have to be taken with a big grain salt due to the partial equilibrium nature of the analysis. Take a simple example: Look at how many times waiters get sick with the flu, say a million hours per year, and then multiply by the average amount of money a waiter earns - say 20 bucks an hour -- and conclude that the flu costs the restaurant economy 20 million dollars. Well that assumes that if the waiters didn't call in sick, that an extra 20 million dollars of tips/earnings would have been available. Yet that amount is determined by the demand for meals, not availability of waiters, and when one waiter is sick, others cover for them so all the meals get served. But then the extra labor of waiters needed to cover for each other is a cost, no? Well, again no, as collectively the pool of waiters that cover for sick waiters is the same pool that call in sick -- it is some extra volatility in hours worked, but total hours worked is unchanged. So at the end of the day, it's hard to determine how much damage to the economy is created by waiters calling in sick and covering for each other. It's certainly much, much lower than what you get by multiplying hourly wages by time spent sick. Now come to depression. Depression may be just the mental price of brains capable of risk assessment or deep thought. Like sleep is not a dead weight cost, but just the price of having a developed brain. It's not clear that Depression is "costing" us anything anymore than sleep is costing us lost labor, and it could be that a world without depression would also be a world without genius, realism, and creativity.
- witherk 6y ago>Depression may be just the mental price of brains capable of risk assessment or deep thought. There are plenty of very smart people who aren't depressed, but I don't know of any smart people who don't sleep.
- fsloth 6y agoAgree. Speaking from experience depression is a miserable state. There is no reason to create silly rationales to justify it. Depression is at worst a lethal malady that creates suffering not only in the depressed but for their families as well.
- 6y ago
- The_rationalist 6y agoBtw the current first line prescriptions are extremely suboptimal: SSRIs cause sexual disfunction in 60% and even pssd Bupropion cause tinnitus TCAs are neurotoxic MAOIs have a diet that is not hard to follow. Irreversible or transdermal MAOIs are the answer for first line treatment - > Moclobemide and Emsam They have almost no side effects and are more effective.
- timonoko 6y agoWhat is happening to this magazine? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27042906 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27042906
- orthecreedence 6y agoI think what they meant to say is that our economic setup has an enormous impact on our mental health. We're treated like labor robots ("human resources") with the constant looming threat of unemployment, having every last bit of value squeezed out of us so that shareholders can get a few extra cents out of their Chucky Cheese tokens that entitle them to absentee ownership of some resource they've never lifted a god damned finger to produce. Not to mention there's an enormous apparatus designed solely to convince us to buy useless trash that we don't need in order to support the very system continuously bending us over a barrel. But hey, here's some fucking happy pills, now get back to work.
- haram_masala 6y agoI’d say this is perhaps a bit of a violent oversimplification, but still contains some useful perspectives. Work to live, don’t live to work.
- 74d-fe6-2c6 6y ago> We report our latest estimates showing that the incremental economic burden of adults with MDD was $326 billion in 2018, 38 percent higher than in 2010. This way of thinking is fundamentally responsible for our societies being so suseptible for the spiritual crises which are mainly the cause of depression.