3 ms·
Who decides which part of the majority opinion to push back against?
by chrisseaton 6y ago
Who decides which part of the majority opinion to push back against?
- Retric 6y agoIt’s less about specifics than approach. IMO, direct democracy is very poor fit for creating or editing laws especially in terms of taxes, but a fine idea for repealing laws. Several times I have seen something complex where making an informed decision take at minimum several hours of research. Which most voters are obviously not going to do. Most people are at best following their parties lead, which asks the initiative pointless, or more likely making a knee jerk reaction without understanding the details. Repealing laws on the other hand is something voters can have direct experience with.
- staticautomatic 6y agoWhat reason is there to believe that repealing laws is any less susceptible to the same kinds of influence?
- Retric 6y agoSimilar issues are in play, but exceptions are generally more difficult to judge. Arguing that the limit for arsenic in drinking water should be lowered is very different than arguing the limit should be removed. The first needs a detailed analysis to judge, where the second comes down to more fundamental ideas. Further, if the power is limited to removing legislation then similar rules can be added if it becomes obvious their needed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Sophistifunk 6y agoYou don't. You build protections into your constitution that the mob cannot overrule without revolution.
- AdrianB1 6y agoIt does not work, see how US Constitution amendments got eroded in time to the extent that some practically don't exist anymore in California, for example. "should not be infringed" gets to "can be regulated" which goes to "practically banned".