3 ms·
Its a tradeoff between complexity and results. Think of it like this, every kg added to Starship is one kg less to Orbit. And maybe like 10-30kg less to Mars.
by nickik 5y ago
Its a tradeoff between complexity and results.
Think of it like this, every kg added to Starship is one kg less to Orbit. And maybe like 10-30kg less to Mars.
For what you are talking about you likely need 16-32 SuperDracos, you need massive tank. A highly complex system of tubes along the vehicle and so on. You would reduce the payload to Orbit and return by a huge margin.
On earth, for a system to be reusable AT ALL, is incredibly hard. Like seriously, super hard. Their margins are already very thin. I'm not even sure what you suggest is possible at all.
And such a system would only prevent some very few cases. You already have engine redundancy. It wouldn't save you in many failure cases either. So its a gigantic increase in complexity for a slight reduction in potential failure.
The extra complexity quite apart from the performance would also lead to many new failure most that must be considered. If in a full risk analysis this would actually be safer is questionable.
If you want to increase safety adding a 4th Raptor would like by safer, as well as starting the flip earlier.
P.S: The fuel would also be highly toxic and would make operations with humans much more complex and much more expensive.
- SECProto 5y ago> Think of it like this, every kg added to Starship is one kg less to Orbit. And maybe like 10-30kg less to Mars. With standard staging this would be correct. With starship it's a bit different: Every 1kg added to Starship is 1kg less [payload] to Orbit. And 1kg less to Mars. And maybe an extra tanker launch for refueling
- nickik 5y agoThat's exactly the thing. I will take more launches. So overall its still true. If you did the exact same flights, overall you would end up with many fewer kg landed on Mars. But of course that inefficiency is gone be buffered by more refueling. Still calculate the lost efficiency on the scale on a mars base and 1kg is a major. Not to mention the system suggest above.