4 ms·
The problem is that, in this case, "Default Deny" can mean someone is dead. And, I would go further. This kind of "Default Deny" means that this system simply
by bsder 6y ago
The problem is that, in this case, "Default Deny" can mean someone is dead.
And, I would go further. This kind of "Default Deny" means that this system simply does not comply with the standards and practices that give you legal shielding and are normally required for "safety equipment". It's going to have a whole host of "failure modes" that normally wouldn't be present because it has to "deny" usage under certain cases.
As such, they're going to lose a really large court case for very good reason.
- oh_sigh 6y agoIs there any safety equipment that leaves the manufacturer legally liable if the end user doesn't set up and activate the equipment properly? Is Honda responsible if my seatbelt doesn't work, because I didn't put it on? It's not like this airbag is a passive, always-ready device. You can't even just put it on and expect it to work. You need to actually turn it on too, and have the batteries charged. And if you turn it on and it says "NOT ACTIVE" or something like that, would anyone believe that the airbag was going to work?
- bsder 6y agoHonda would be liable if the passenger airbag doesn't go off because the "passenger sensor" failed. The addition of the "passenger sensor" added extra failure modes that have to be managed and certified. Now, car manufacturers did this because people are stupid and put their children in car seats on the passenger side and Honda doesn't want to kill children. Nevertheless, you have to account for the failure modes and sign off on them. I can't imagine anyone with a PE signing off of this kind of fiasco. I'm sure you can find one somewhere if you pay enough money, but man ...
- oh_sigh 6y agoThat's an instance where the product says it is working but it doesn't. Not where a product says it isn't working and it doesn't.
- dahart 6y ago> The problem is that, in this case, "Default Deny" can mean someone is dead. That's not really accurate. Did you check out the product description or FAQ? https://www.klim.com/Ai-1-Airbag-Vest-3046-000 https://www.klim.com/Ai-1-Airbag-Vest-3046-000 Default deny would mean the user doesn't ride, because the deny happens before you go, not during the ride. Yes, if they were to shut off service after signaling it's okay to ride, then it would be an affront to safety standards, and they would lose in court. But... they're not shutting off service during the ride...
- bsder 6y agoCan the microcontroller reboot? Oops, maybe you're not authorized anymore because the default stance is "deny" and you can't call home (otherwise you just block communication and you have a functional vest). This isn't theoretical. A watchdog timer is standard protection against weird "shit happens", one-off things in safety equipment. That means you reboot when something goes wrong (cosmic rays, flaky battery connections, etc.). DJs wouldn't use software that uses things like FlexLM because it might hang in the middle of their performance because it is "default deny". And that is nowhere near the level of importance as a safety jacket.
- dahart 6y agoI have no idea if it has corner-case failure modes, it probably does, like all products including your car. However, the product page for the vest mentions it has adventure mode, which means the rider is expected to be out of range of cell service for periods of time, so it seems evident that they might have thought about microcontroller reboots, since the device is going to be powered on and off out of range anyway. I don’t understand why there is a flood of pure speculation in this comment section assuming that the design must be worst-case and trash. There’s no reason to jump to that unfounded conclusion.
- bsder 6y ago> I don’t understand why there is a flood of pure speculation in this comment section assuming that the design must be worst-case and trash. The implementation is irrelevant because the fundamental idea is horribly broken. "Default deny" and "safety equipment" are like oil and fire. (If you really want to understand why this is stupid: Just go use some software with the FlexLM license manager and you will understand at a deep psychological level why this is a horrible idea.)