9 ms·
I'm pretty sure this is illegal at least in Germany. Also: > at some point, if a person stops paying for a service, that service has to be suspended What the
by xg15 6y ago
I'm pretty sure this is illegal at least in Germany. Also:
> at some point, if a person stops paying for a service, that service has to be suspended
What the fuck is the "service" here?
If the whole point of IoT was at the end that you can now declare "not actively making things worse" a service and have a working business model, I think we can now officially declare this trend a net negative on living quality.
- r00fus 6y agoIt's not like IoT was destined for anything else as long as businesses are allowed (nay, rewarded) to pull that kind of shit.
- bhupy 6y ago> nay, rewarded Really? I see a low hanging fruit opportunity to get rich: manufacture and sell the same motorcycle vest and sell it at an upfront cost equal to some approximate amortization of monthly payments over some average LTV. As a motorcycle rider, I currently have like 10+ different options for motorcycle jackets.
- vr46 6y agoAlso as a motorcycle rider, the whole notion of life-saving protection and safety being a "service" suggests that the thing is too complicated to work 100% of the time, with no fail-safe option, and therefore cannot be trusted at any cost. Protective devices need 100% uptime.
- bhupy 6y agoAgreed, it doesn't seem like this would even need to be a "service", at least in the sense that the core functionality of "inflating" can entirely be serviced offline/locally on the jacket. There's so much wrong with the implementation here, and it looks like a bright flashing opportunity for someone to provide a simpler/saner/cheaper alternative and make a quick buck.
- vr46 6y agoIt looks like they got the marketing badly wrong, because we should be talking about how clever the bag is etc, but instead we don't give a monkey's. Gah. MotoGP has mandatory airbag suits, with accelerometers and gyros. Racing is obviously different, there's no cars and trucks to run you over, but top speeds are completely insane, so the tech might well translate over to the road.
- bhupy 6y agoIt appears their bet was that by having the upfront cost be discounted and making the money back in "service" payments, they increase access to those that might otherwise not be comfortable footing the high upfront cost. The product isn't a motorcycle jacket, it's a financial instrument with life-and-death usury rates. In some sense, it's probably impossible to market a product like this well.
- wombatmobile 6y ago> it's probably impossible to market a product like this well. At the right price, with 100% uptime, motorcycle airbags would be a monster hit product. I say that with confidence because as a motorcycle rider who is aware of the stats which tell me we risk death and serious injury 8X more than car drivers. I want a motorcycle airbag - at the right price and conditions. Who doesn't? And why don't they exist? What would be the cost to manufacture them at the rate of 500 million a year? That's the global market potential. p.s. Do motorcycle airbags actually work to significantly prevent injury and death? If the answer is that they aren't particularly efficacious anyway, even when ideally implemented, I can understand why they scarcely exist in the market.
- bhupy 6y ago> What would be the cost to manufacture them at the rate of 500 million a year? That's the global market potential. Completely agreed. The fact that there's one bad product on the market doesn't mean that one can conclude that our system rewards bad products, per the GGP comment. > p.s. Do motorcycle airbags actually work to significantly prevent injury and death? If the answer is that they aren't particularly efficacious anyway, even when ideally implemented, I can understand why they scarcely exist in the market. Probably not! I think time will tell.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoI can't wait for them to offer "low latency impact protection".
- jacquesm 6y agoExactly.
- shakna 6y ago> Protective devices need 100% uptime. The manual for the same companies skiing airbag points out that if the GPS drops out, the airbag is disabled. [0] That should pretty clearly indicate how well they take safety. [0] https://www.inemotion.com/myinemotion/documents/ski/2017.user_manual_rpg_in&motion_airbag_vest_en_v1.pdf?v=1554480075 https://www.inemotion.com/myinemotion/documents/ski/2017.use... (Page 16)
- aitchnyu 6y agoHow can they ever justify relying on a GPS? My watch reminds me every 20 minutes of a walk that it lost GPS.
- shakna 6y agoHow can any designer of a safety product justify it having any kind of software shutoff? Safety products must _failsafe_, especially in unexpected situations. This is just failing hard.
- FDSGSG 6y agoWhy would GPS not be reliable while skiing?
- alushta 6y agoTrees.
- shakna 6y agoGPS has service interruptions. Planned and otherwise. GPS jammers may be illegal, but they exist, which means that they can be encountered. Wet leaves on trees have been known to degrade GPS signals. Cross-country skiing exists, and may proceed through forests that are... Wet. GPS connectivity can be impacted when switching from one satellite to another. Safety equipment _must_ have a _failsafe_, not depend on the assumptions of the software. At no point in time is it reasonable for it to depend on something external to itself for whether it works or not.
- 6y ago
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Really? I see a low hanging fruit opportunity to get rich: manufacture and sell the same motorcycle vest and sell it at an upfront cost equal to some approximate amortization of monthly payments over some average LTV. The same company sells the same vest for twice the price without the subscription. However, that doesn't help the people who bought a vest that locks them out of necessary safety features, nor does it help the rest of the market when a business poisons the well like this.
- lamp987 6y ago"I think we can now officially declare this trend a net negative on living quality." +1
- oh_sigh 6y agoThe service is that they get an $800 vest for $400 + $12/mo. Providing a subsidized device when the full retail prices may otherwise dissuade non-frequent motorists doesn't seem evil to me. Some people only ride a 2-3 months a year with ideal weather. So providing this service lets them use the device for 10+ years before they finally catch up with the cost of buying it outright at year 0.
- ketralnis 6y agoI have spotify plan that amex failures have cancelled twice in the last 10ish years. Emailing them to retry the charge works, I'm sure it's just random outages and it's never bothered me. But it's also never killed me before. That would be evil.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoPer TFA they give you a 30day grace period if the card declines.
- mijamo 6y agoIf the lower upfront cost is the only thing you want then there's no need for a subscription. Just have a financing option like businesses have been doing for decades. And if the person stops paying send it to sent recovery. It's a solved problem for a very long time. The only reason why you would want a subscription is to keep charging people even after they have paid the full price and interests, which is a super annoying and bad policy to have in the first place.
- dahart 6y agoThis is just a financing option, they even call it a "lease plan" on the web page. The unusual and positive benefit here is it doesn't go to recovery, you get to keep it and just pick up and continue your payments later as if nothing happened. I wish all my financing plans offered that option! * I'm totally and utterly baffled by all the downvoting. It seems like many people did not check out the product's web page and are left with Vice's misleading interpretation. Here's the description I'm talking about, right from the product page: https://klimsitecontent.s3.amazonaws.com/contentblocks/2021%20Moto/cbim-11.jpg https://klimsitecontent.s3.amazonaws.com/contentblocks/2021%... It says "Membership: Lease or Buy (No Subscription!)" Maybe they goofed by using the word "service" in the description, but this is just a financing plan. And it's not some kind of crazy safety issue where they shut it off while you ride, they appear to have designed it to prevent that. And it is, in fact, more lenient than my mortgage, my car payments, or my credit cards. I don't get to pause or cancel any of those without pretty severe repercussions.
- seriousquestion 6y agoThe SaaS of the future; Safety as a Service