4 ms·
Science is carried out by humans, and humans act on ulterior agendas all the time. There's a whole class of facts called "hate facts", which are putative facts
by bitwize 6y ago
Science is carried out by humans, and humans act on ulterior agendas all the time.
There's a whole class of facts called "hate facts", which are putative facts you would do well to doubt, and even if they were true pretend they are false anyway, because of the ammo they would give to people who want to oppress certain groups if they were true or widely accepted as true. One particularly volatile example is the supposed race-IQ correlations. Even if they were true we would be socially obligated to deny them, because letting that sort of thing become public knowledge would encourage the wrong sorts of people and groups. I suspect the same is true of sex differences in cognition, personality, or interest because it would enable misogynists to enact anti-woman policies in the name of "well, women just aren't interested in/don't have the personality required for that anyway".
- systemvoltage 6y agoA minuscule number of people read any of these studies or literature. To stop progress of scientific understanding because of some far fetched consequence isn’t a worthwhile trade off. My crazy sexist Uncle doesn’t conduct a deep thorough review of scientific literature before spewing his deep contempt for women. If I were to guess the number of people reading gender studies to bolster their biases, it would be in vanishingly small.
- mLuby 6y agoYou're right, in a narrow sense. But there's a game of amplified telephone going on. Researcher publishes: "Survey finds that undergrad males with heterochromia are 12% less likely to be leaders of student orgs than their homochromia male peers." Science communicator simplifies: "Having the same color eyes may make you more of a leader." News agency runs clickbait: "Eyeing the throne? Here are 5 kinds of people Science says could tank your company." Online forums spew anecdata: "I knew this one guy with different eyes who ran his org into the ground and also he was a predator. No way, me too!" The fringe group Securing our Homochromia Future starts getting mentioned by not-so-fringe people: "I don't agree with their methods, but they aren't entirely wrong about heterochromia either; did you read that study? No me neither, but the gist was…" (BTW if it wasn't already super clear I'm 100% making up these statements about heterochromia.)
- guerrilla 6y agoThis is beautiful. You captured exactly what's going on. That research published also probably only had 30 participants and wasn't the meta-study covering thousands of participants which said there's a tiny correlation between eye-color and assertiveness but they aren't totally sure because too many studies were of poor quality and couldn't even be included.
- systemvoltage 6y agoImpressive strawman, even if this were remotely true, just because news channels twist the scientific conclusions outcomes to suit their biases. The problem is with the media and their pre-equipped intentions, not the scientific community. Otherwise, you will need to cease conducting science all together. Stop all nutrition studies because some wacko nutritionist is going to spin it off as a magic snake oil cure. Blaming scientists and impeding scientific exploration is preposterous and dangerous.
- zpeti 6y agoYou do realise you basically just said "science should only be used when it suits my political views" Science is science. If you can't deal with the facts that's your problem. If the facts are difficult, we need to work hard to come up with good solutions to hard problems. Putting your head in the sand and denying the facts will probably come back to bite you later very hard.
- MyHypatia 6y agoOkay, so if someone conducts a scientific study that people from your demographic are less likely to pay back loans, and a bank uses that to deny you a loan to start your business. What are you going to do? Are you going to accept that "science is science" and the people in your group are worse on average, so you as an individual shouldn't get to start a business? If you object are you just someone who "can't deal with the facts", and "putting your head in the sand" and denying the facts that the bank is probably right, someone from your background is going to fail anyway? Or will you just say, "Okay, science is science. The wiser have spoken, I will now give up on my dreams."
- zpeti 6y ago1. You can seek out a lender who specialises in higher risk loans 2. If there isn't one, you can start a lender that does that, since there is probably a business opportunity if noone is doing it. 3. You can convince friends and family that you are more reliable than your demographic and get angel investments from them. 4. You can convince VCs that you are more reliable than your demographic and get investment 5. You can try and aim for quick profitability and bootstrap your business. 6. You can complain about your victimhood and do nothing.
- MyHypatia 6y agoOk, if you're just going to lie down and accept paying higher interest rates or jumping through hoops because you're male/female/black/white then go ahead. I don't accept having to jump through additional hoops or having to pay more money because of demographic factors. And thankfully there are laws today that prevent banks from refusing to loan people money because they are black, female, etc.