5 ms·
> But right now, it does not work for what people ultimately need it to be doing. As far as I am concerned, people are currently trading pogs or magic cards. Y
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
> But right now, it does not work for what people ultimately need it to be doing. As far as I am concerned, people are currently trading pogs or magic cards.
You're one of the developers who helped launch Bitcoin Cash. I'd be curious to hear you talk about why you find (or found?) the project worthwhile, if crytocurrency currently "does not work for what people ultimately need". Do you see yourself as laying the groundwork for a better future implementation?
- CyberDildonics 6y agoIt isn't a mystery. Exactly what everyone said would happen (bitcoin blocks fill up and transactions are expensive while throughput is dismal) came to pass. Bitcoin's average transaction cost has been anywhere from $18 to $60 over the last few months. Even dodge coin is approaching $2 for each transaction. Bitcoin Cash transactions cost $0.02 (2 cents) and the transaction throughput can grow 30x without the blocks being full. In the venn diagram of (decentralized) cryptocurrencies that are widely accepted and have reasonable transaction costs, litecoin, monero and bitcoin cash are what end up being viable for real use right now.
- jude- 6y agoAnd yet the market values Bitcoin Cash at less than 1% of Bitcoin's value. It's almost as if the block size "debate" was a nothingburger -- the silent majority against a tiny screeching minority.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoBitcoin is great for people who want to speculate, have no idea how cryptocurrency works and have no interest in using it for actual transactions. They can buy a number on an exchange and pray the exchange gives it back to them. Go nuts. For normal transactions bitcoin fails miserably. No one sane would make every day transactions with a $60 transaction fee.
- jude- 6y agoChains no one uses are cheap to use. Story at 11.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoBitcoin Cash has had more transactions than bitcoin for the last couple months. Ethereum has three to four times more while still being cheaper (though not much cheaper). It is cheap because the blocks are 32 times bigger so that throughput doesn't have to be only a few kilobytes per second. Here is reality: https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/transactions-btc-eth-doge-bch.html#3m https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/transactions-btc-eth-do...
- jude- 6y agoThe chart you share is buggy. If you click on the block size, you'll see it measures Bitcoin blocks as being around 800kb. This indicates that it's ignoring the segwit witness data. In reality, BCH blocks are a about 1/3 the size as Bitcoin blocks for the last 7 days: https://fork.lol/blocks/size https://fork.lol/blocks/size. If you zoom out to the last year, you can see that BCH had a rise and fall in number of transactions per block, whereas Bitcoin was consistent: https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/transactions-btc-bch.html#1y https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/transactions-btc-bch.ht... I don't see how Ethereum relates to the dearth of real-world traction BCH has versus Bitcoin. Moreover, Ethereum has a different block emission rate, a different pricing model for transactions, and a different wire format for representing them, so size and quantity measurement comparisons are apples to oranges. Suffice it to say that both Bitcoin and Ethereum's transaction capacities are maxed out (signaling high demand), whereas this is not the case for BCH.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoI linked transaction count, not block size. You said that Bitcoin Cash was cheap because "no one uses it" which is not true. It is 1/1000th the cost per transaction while still having more transactions than btc. > I don't see how Ethereum relates to the dearth of real-world traction BCH has versus Bitcoin. You said transactions on "chains no one uses are cheap". Ethereum has multiple times the transactions of bitcoin and still has slightly cheaper transactions. > so size and quantity measurement comparisons are apples to oranges. No they aren't. More transactions, not more expensive. > Suffice it to say that both Bitcoin and Ethereum's transaction capacities are maxed out (signaling high demand), whereas this is not the case for BCH. Bitcoin Cash is not maxed out because they expanded their maximum block size to 32MB instead of leaving it crippled like bitcoin. That's like saying there is no demand for ford fusions because they don't have a waiting list like tesla. It makes zero sense at all. It is baffling that you would say something like that. The things you are saying are not true. It is clear that you aren't trying to find out what is true, you have something you want to convince other people or yourself of. You don't get on a subway car and see an empty seat and say there is no demand because you saw a full rickshaw. This isn't just a stretch, it is a ridiculous nonsense argument and makes me believe you are emotionally invested enough to say thing contradicted by basic logic.
- micropresident 6y agoWell, I had not been involved in cryptocurrency development at all until Bitcoin Cash. I had a pre-existing relationship with Amaury Séchet who designed all the Bitcoin Cash protocol changes; and was asked for my help. There was a lot I didn't understand at the time. Many details about how cryptocurrencies function -- in practice; as opposed to the dogma -- that aren't obvious until you're working on the node software itself and you start having to interact with industrial miners, exchanges, and the user base. But yes, I think the technology is worthwhile and I still work on it heavily in my free time -- just not Bitcoin Cash. I have a couple projects I am slowly working on, but it's not my intent of my post to advertise them -- if you want to know ask and I'll tell you about them. There are technical problems with cryptocurrency, but most of those are fixable. The biggest problem with cryptocurrency is people. My current projects are an attempt to address both sets of issues. The following might be off-putting, but some of the unintuitive things I learned: 1. People en-masse almost always follow economic incentives. 2. People rationalize their behavior and will tell you reasonably sounding explanations; but they are really following incentives and are quite predictable. Not on an individual level, but on a group level. 3. People often are not able to understand counterfactual thinking regarding economics. They will explain how something makes economic sense -- but it only makes in the absence of considering alternative futures from the one under consideration. 4. Most people are not able to understand the economic incentives of other individuals. They lack "empathy" in this regard. 5. Money attracts sociopaths like moths to a flame. I have never seen so much toxicity in one "place" until I started working on Bitcoin Cash. I do not believe it is unique to that "community." 6. This is probably the most controversial thing: if you look at the core groups shilling any particular cryptocurrency, they are attracted to that cryptocurrency because the economic incentives align with their value system. Ultimately the value of cryptocurrency comes from how people value it, and that comes from a value system (or a belief system). They are best understood as pseudo-religious cults. With 6 said, the relationship between the value system and the cryptocurrency is bi-directional. When you hitch your financial future to the success of a coin it has a way of perverting the beliefs of the individuals invested in them. Money is now being issued by pseudo-religions for the benefit of the members. Imagine what would happen if Scientology had its own cryptocurrency? It would obtain "superpowers" as now there's an economic incentive to join. You get "paid" to join, and you have a large incentive to bring in new members due to the impact of Metcalfe's law (network value increases quadratically with number of users). Right now, these "communities" are coalescing organically, but eventually things like Scientology will "catch up". You can already see it with Bitcoin SV and it's personality cult around Craig Wright (who I met many times) backed by Calvin Ayre. I was raised in a very problematic religious cult and managed to escape -- and I find this very troubling. I also think it is an inevitability.