2 ms·
What kind of reviewer, for what kind of paper? Any paper in which I wrote "Then x = y/2" would almost certainly be a math (or computer science) paper, so the re
by hvs 15y ago
What kind of reviewer, for what kind of paper? Any paper in which I wrote "Then x = y/2" would almost certainly be a math (or computer science) paper, so the reviewer would know what I was saying. If it was for a more general audience, I would probably find a better way to state my point.
- dmlorenzetti 15y agoIt's about modeling specific physical processes in buildings. It's computer science in the sense that the paper focuses on efficient implementation. However, the audience is the indoor environment community. The reviewer is a skilled experimenter, whom I enlisted to check my understanding of the physical processes. (By the way, this person knew what I was saying, just didn't like the way I said it. For our internal reviews, we tend to get pretty picky.) It's definitely not for a general audience-- there'll probably be five people in the world who can use the paper directly (once the results are embedded in software, there'll probably be several hundred who will use it).