3 ms·
One thing I'd like to see more stress on is that these systems, whatever degree of decentraliation they have, they are highly highly coupled systems, requiring
by rektide 6y ago
One thing I'd like to see more stress on is that these systems, whatever degree of decentraliation they have, they are highly highly coupled systems, requiring nearly absolute cohesion. These protocols are built to establish consensus, and that almost always requires change to be accepted by a sizable majority.
Touched upon in the article:
> But in blockchains, we have something almost opposite to that. Since blockchain systems are logically indivisible, and also in many ways more formal and algorithmic than traditional financial systems, blockchains practically defy any authority, even the authority of people over their own accounts.
My bias is more towards how adaptable & flexible systems are. There's little loose coupling, little flexibility, it feels like. Sometimes flexibility is engineered in, with smart contracts, but those virtual machines are enormously unadaptable, unflexible systems, by design, and trying to extend or grow or adapt them feels highly unlikely. Governance models for these systems seem rare, and- speaking as an outsider, a not regular user- I rarely if ever come across descriptions of how these blockchains are changing or adapting. It takes many years it feels like to get basic life-preserving measures happen such as the bitcoin block size limits. Decentralized somewhat, but extremely high authority, extremely unadaptable, unchanging. They possess few of what we think of as the general resilliency, adaptability measures that decentralization & distributiziation beget.