4 ms·
because bitcoin miners can't dictate monetary policy (they can only dictate transaction ordering/inclusion), but governments can do both.
by gruez 6y ago
because bitcoin miners can't dictate monetary policy (they can only dictate transaction ordering/inclusion), but governments can do both.
- jayd16 6y agoHow can they not dictate monetary policy? They could conceivably cause inflation by increasing mining rewards or perhaps deflation through coin destruction.
- jude- 6y agoMiners don't decide what software other people run, that's why. If a miner tries to mint themselves more Bitcoin than they are due, then their block will be rejected by the network.
- jayd16 6y agoThe scenario in question is when a small group has control of the network through consolidated hash power.
- doggosphere 6y agoThat would require changes to the codebase which most nodes probably wouldn't support. Which would be creating their own fork. You can't just "increase mining rewards" as a miner.
- boh 6y agoThey influence Bitcoin development (SegWit is a good example), so they dictate the Bitcoin version of policy.
- yeneek 6y agoIt's other way around. Majority of miners were against SegWit and blocked its activation for over a year. Community then decided to collectively upgrade their nodes to accept only certain transactions. It is called User Activated Soft Fork (#UASF) The miners had to make a decision. Mine coins that rest of the world dont want, or activate segwit.