3 ms·

X1 carbons aren't exactly known for being the most repairable thinkpads. My new P15 still has a modular gpu and, IIRC, has easy access to most components by re

X1 carbons aren't exactly known for being the most repairable thinkpads. My new P15 still has a modular gpu and, IIRC, has easy access to most components by removing the back cover.

CarelessExpert 5y ago
And Thinkpads are a) pretty unique in how repairable they are, and b) seen by the public as enterprise workhorses and not sexy or exciting. I personally have an X1C5. I absolutely love it. Best laptop I've ever owned. But I'm still very curious about this thing as it feels like a whole next level in terms of how modular and easy it is to repair while still being lightweight, powerful, and capable.
organsnyder 5y ago
I agree that it's an unfair comparison. X1 Carbon (really, the whole X-series) is the line designed to appeal to those that want thinness and weight reduction at all costs. My T- and P-series machines are very repairable.
- 3np 5y ago
  Really, how recent is your newest one? The T-series (I’ve owned roughly every other generation since T420) have gotten increasingly less repairable with each release since at least the T430. I was always a fan/happy user, but after the T480(s) I won’t be buying a new Thinkpad anymore. The DRM in the batteries, only one RAM slot, the removal of some port in every new generation... Even the non-carbon ones have the writing on the wall.
  - notjulianjaynes 5y ago
    My T-480 with integrated graphics has two SODIMM sockets. My biggest complaint is there's room in the case for a 2.5" SATA drive, but no way to connect one. Wasn't aware of the battery DRM that's unfortunate.
    - 3np 5y ago
      The t4x0s series used to have two as well, now it’s down to one. Earlier models of T series did have space and connectors for both M2 and 2.5” drives. It started off all right, but every release in every series gets incrementally worse in some way. I’d go for Clevo/system76 if it weren’t for the lack of hi-res screen options. I’m stoked about Framework.

X1 carbons aren't exactly known for being the most repairable thinkpads. My new P15 still has a modular gpu and, IIRC, has easy access to most components by removing the back cover.

CarelessExpert 5y ago

And Thinkpads are a) pretty unique in how repairable they are, and b) seen by the public as enterprise workhorses and not sexy or exciting. I personally have an X1C5. I absolutely love it. Best laptop I've ever owned. But I'm still very curious about this thing as it feels like a whole next level in terms of how modular and easy it is to repair while still being lightweight, powerful, and capable.

organsnyder 5y ago

I agree that it's an unfair comparison. X1 Carbon (really, the whole X-series) is the line designed to appeal to those that want thinness and weight reduction at all costs. My T- and P-series machines are very repairable.

3np 5y ago
Really, how recent is your newest one? The T-series (I’ve owned roughly every other generation since T420) have gotten increasingly less repairable with each release since at least the T430. I was always a fan/happy user, but after the T480(s) I won’t be buying a new Thinkpad anymore. The DRM in the batteries, only one RAM slot, the removal of some port in every new generation... Even the non-carbon ones have the writing on the wall.
- notjulianjaynes 5y ago
  My T-480 with integrated graphics has two SODIMM sockets. My biggest complaint is there's room in the case for a 2.5" SATA drive, but no way to connect one. Wasn't aware of the battery DRM that's unfortunate.
  - 3np 5y ago
    The t4x0s series used to have two as well, now it’s down to one. Earlier models of T series did have space and connectors for both M2 and 2.5” drives. It started off all right, but every release in every series gets incrementally worse in some way. I’d go for Clevo/system76 if it weren’t for the lack of hi-res screen options. I’m stoked about Framework.