3 ms·
The headline is misleading and the blog's author is clearly pushing an agenda, but for at least the last 5-6 years serious, educated people have been asking if
by cratermoon 6y ago
The headline is misleading and the blog's author is clearly pushing an agenda, but for at least the last 5-6 years serious, educated people have been asking if calculus really should be the peak high school math.
Some argue that probability and statistics would be better, or any of linear algebra, graph theory, logic, and various discrete math topics.
https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/calculus-is-the-peak-of-high-school-math-maybe-its-time-to-change-that/2018/05 https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/calculus-is-the-pea...
https://www.salon.com/2020/09/26/teaching-data-science-instead-of-calculus-high-schools-math-debate/ https://www.salon.com/2020/09/26/teaching-data-science-inste...
- _dps 6y agoIndeed this headline is editorialized against HN guidelines. The original headline is: "To Promote Equality, California Proposes a Ban on Advanced Math Classes" and it seems, at least upon quick inspection, to be factually accurate (although the article content itself is far from neutral). @dang if you get a moment this headline could benefit from reverting to the source headline. EDIT: Actually after digging another layer down in the linked sources, I'm not sure even the "proposes a ban" is factually substantiated though it's hard to tell for sure without going one layer yet deeper and scanning through a 300 page report.
- xxxxxxx12 6y ago> although the article content itself is far from neutral Can we admit how pernicious it is that the school system itself is manifestly captured by ideological motives and that simply criticizing that is impossible to be "neutral" by any standard people that agree with the program would define? I guess I'm saying: how do you voice criticism in a neutral way when the program being criticized frames itself as basic human decency. This is the same logic that lies at the center of something like the Patriot Act. Capture language and you've perniciously twisted language so as to be unimpeachable. This is Pandora's Box.
- _dps 6y agoI only meant to comment on the article's neutrality with regard to evaluating the meta aspect of the headline quality. I personally think that the kinds of measures proposed here are counterproductive (I am, among other things, a mathematics educator) — but my opinion on that isn't really relevant to the question of helping keep HN submissions at the desired level of quality.
- xxxxxxx12 6y agoI get what you're saying. I think there's an issue though, that neutrality is hard to come by for lots of reasons and especially nowadays when preference falsification is prevalent because critique of DEI/CRT is social suicide in certain sociopolitical milieu. So naturally you're only going to find critique on the other side. As the CRT folk are keen to say - you can't be neutral - pick a side!
- cratermoon 6y ago> Can we admit how pernicious it is that the school system itself is manifestly captured by ideological motives Sure: https://www.theroot.com/we-found-the-textbooks-of-senators-who-oppose-the-1619-1846832317 https://www.theroot.com/we-found-the-textbooks-of-senators-w...
- BitwiseFool 6y agoSome calculus is great for understanding concepts like rate of change and how you can measure something that has curves in it. All that being said, the domain of mathematics is so much larger than calculus but all of my high-school math curriculum was geared towards integrals.
- cratermoon 6y agoSure, a little. Limits, Riemann sums, derivatives: the basics needed to understand how they model change over time.