3 ms·
Why would you compare the death rates from a pandemic that happened immediately following a devastating world war, with famine and poverty all across the globe,
by tsimionescu 6y ago
Why would you compare the death rates from a pandemic that happened immediately following a devastating world war, with famine and poverty all across the globe, at the very beginning of real medicine, in a world of borders; with one happening in 2020 in a globalized world where we have access to much more advanced medical knowledge, and where an outbreak in Wuhan can become an epidemic in New York?
Not to mention, the initial death tolls in the unprepared places, like Lombardia in Italy or Iran, should be motivation enough for a quick and decisive response. Unfortunately, neither the US nor Europe nor Russia were smart enough to take such an approach, and instead of a quick and thorough lockdown + contact tracing that would have hurt daily life for maybe 2 months before back to normal, with almost no casualties (see Vietnam to note that this was entirely possible), we are getting 2 years of lukewarm responses that leave the same order of magnitude of deaths as the 1918 pandemic.
- anonymouse008 6y agoThat’s a thoughtful discussion, and I hear your points, I’m just keeping a bit of “open weights” to the possibilities. To your point, we are more medically advanced and can track cell phones across the globe, which in some ideas could mean we need to respond less in an aggressive amputation of economies and more focused proper risk assessments - which also means I would have advocated from the beginning to ground all travel (air esp) and any economic activity to assess the situation for a month or two. So when evaluating Italy or Iran, we should be doing genetic testing and massive analysis on who gets severe vs mild cases, and is is a heritable trait that could explain anomalies in various communities. Again, beautiful discussion... not saying you’re wrong, just leaving options open.