5 ms·
>I think unpaid internships being socially acceptable is one of the roots of this insidious habit. When I worked with interns they were all paid... but every o
by duxup 6y ago
>I think unpaid internships being socially acceptable is one of the roots of this insidious habit.
When I worked with interns they were all paid... but every one was more time and expense to work with than any value they provided. In weeks they accomplished what I could do in an afternoon, and we spent WAY more than an afternoon of work with them. Amazingly many seemed to have a very high opinion of their productivity.
Now that's fine because when I did work with them the intent was to give these folks an opportunity / experience.
But I don't know about this idea that interns are somehow a gateway to getting value out of people for free. Interns in my experience (outside of maybe a unicorn out there) are not something you can expect to get much of anything out of.
I can't imagine coming out of the intern experiences I've had thinking that I'm going to get anything like worthwhile free labor from them.
- notyourwork 6y ago> But I don't know about this idea that interns are somehow a gateway to getting value out of people for free. Interns in experience (outside of maybe a unicorn out there) are not productive ... We use internships as a pipeline to hire. We pay them for their time, they get real world experience. We both get quality time together to see if long term this is a good fit. Those who start full time ramp up much faster and are generally successful in their career.
- munk-a 6y agoI had a paid internship that was essentially this and enjoyed it greatly. I wasn't paid particularly well but my workload was a project that I probably took about ten times as long to do as I would today. During the run of the internship I was brought into discussions on design and worked under someone who managed to put up with a flood of questions that I sent at them. I was hired at the end of my internship and switched over to regular work and grew as an independent employee to handle more serious workloads. My internship was an investment that the company paid into me (and other folks) and by the time I left the company I feel like I more than paid that back. It's essentially just a probationary period at the start of employment but with much less expectation to retain the employee and less commitment from the potential employee to stay on.
- notyourwork 6y agoMy current company looks at internships as a way to promote working here. We want interns to be successful, learn and enjoy their time. It's a larger investment than hiring off the street but the reward for those who get full time return offers pays for itself ten times over.
- zeta0134 6y agoFrom the company's point of view, it seems like an internship really ought to be more of a culture fit check than anything else. It's like an extended technical interview in a way: "try on our team for size, see how it fits. Do you like the work? Do we see potential in your skills / productivity?" That sort of thing. Heck, even for experienced engineers there's a spinup time on any large technical endeavor that is sometimes measured in months. How long is a typical internship anyway?
- interviewer0000 6y ago12 weeks in the US. In the realm of software you'll make anywhere from 20 to 50 an hour.
- applecrazy 6y agoSome internships go higher, but those tend to be in the trading/quant software of things. (see https://www.levels.fyi/internships/ https://www.levels.fyi/internships/)
- DiggyJohnson 6y agoRespectfully, what is the value of pointing outliers at the top end of the intern of scale?
- applecrazy 6y agoNot much. I just wanted to point out how insane intern salaries can get. As a computer science student, us students idealize those internships because the benefits and longer hours means more money to pay off student loans.
- aplummer 6y agoYou generally will get dibs (competing with other internships) on getting to hire them full time. That’s often cheap recruitment.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoIt doesn't matter how much faster a full employee could complete a task. They are giving up their labor and should be compensated accordingly. If the company can't figure out how to derive value from that labor, that's its own fault. Moreover, if companies weren't getting value out of internships, they wouldn't continue hiring interns.
- yarcob 6y agoI've hired a few (paid) interns in my company. They all produced useful things. But they cost so much of my time that I no longer want to hire any.
- RHSeeger 6y ago> They are giving up their labor and should be compensated accordingly. If they were at college completing courses, they'd be giving up their labor towards that. If you consider an internship an educational opportunity, then the argument that they should be paid holds no water (since they don't get paid for college work, instead they pay for the experience). Obviously, not all internships are _really_ educational opportunities, but I would expect most of them to be to at least some extent. To argue that all of them are just "the intern doing work for the employer, and the only difference is the amount of work compared to a full employee" is naive at best, and possibly disingenuous.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoYour college analogy doesn't make sense. Students are the "customers" of the college, not the workers. Or, to put it another way, they're paying for their professors' labor.
- RHSeeger 6y agoMy point was that, just because they're doing work as an intern, that doesn't mean they are doing work they should necessarily get paid for. Both college and an internship are situations where - the junior individual (intern, student) is doing work - the junior individual expects to learn during the experience - the senior entity (college, company) is expected to put effort into making sure the junior has learning opportunities - the senior entity can expect the junior person to contribute less productivity to the company than a full employee Now, how similar/dis-similar they are depends heavily on how much the internship focuses on the learning experience and how much the intern adds to the company. But to say that the intern is definitely contributing more than they are gain is factually incorrect. And > They are giving up their labor and should be compensated accordingly. The thing is, "accordingly" is open to interpretation and, in some cases where the intern is getting a lot more than they give, it's reasonable to argue that it is "not at all".
- 908B64B197 6y agoIf you expect to get immediate value you are doing it wrong. The point is to build relationships with a good school and get a pipeline of applicants that will eventually become great engineers. I recall someone whining he couldn't find good junior engineers. I suggested he go to his local (pretty good) CS school. He then started to whine that they all were already interning at good companies and were transitioning to full time and there was no way for him to break-in!
- johnsoft 6y agoSomeone complaining they can find senior engineers, but not junior engineers? I would gladly trade places with them!
- raverbashing 6y agoIt depends on the level of the intern (and your ability to select productive ones), some are more junior than others (not sure how it works in the US exactly) Yes, most of the time they have negative productivity, but as an intern I had some demanding projects where our work was part of the final (revenue earning) product. But that's how it goes. Pay people for their time.
- cerved 6y agoIt's called onboarding. For six months I worked as an intern, getting paid less than my rent. If didn't have parents that could've supported me, I would've been unemployed. I don't work for free. You presumably don't. Pay your interns and pay them a livable salary.
- dylan604 6y agoI guess that depends on the industry the intern is being used. In photography, an intern typically does a lot of the manual labor like loading/unloading gear from the truck, setting up ligts,stands,tripods,etc. As the intern continues to do this work, they should be able to start learning when/where/why certain gear is being used and where to put initial settings. There is no "week to do something I could do in an afternoon" situation. It all has to be done right then and there. This allows the photographer to spend more time working with the subject/talent/producers/client/etc. After being an intern for long enough, that intern should be able to go off and be a decent assistant if not photographer on their own right.
- twunde 6y agoMost engineering internships at this point are paid and most people on HN are working for companies that do paid internships. Unpaid internships tend to be more prevalent in the arts and at small companies. Anecdotally I distinctly remember people doing design for free as interns, with very little oversight or training. Back in the day Craigslist would have a number of these types of "internships" although I think these are no longer common due to both better enforcement of laws and more importantly the rise of the gig economy creating competition
- emodendroket 6y agoIn many cases, even though it's technically illegal, interns end up just doing menial work that does little to further their skills.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoNo HR person would allow unpaid intern positions in 2021. It's very clearly illegal in the United States. When I mentor college students, the only times we hear about unpaid internships are: 1) Unfunded wannabe startups or small family businesses who don't understand what they need, but they assume they can convince some naive kid to do it for free. No one with actual skills or prospects takes these jobs. Job boards remove these posts if they're moderated. 2) Students who struggle to get a normal internship, so their dad/uncle/cousin/neighbor lets them do an unpaid "internship" off the books at their company to get something to put on their resume. They don't really do much work, but now they can put a line on their resume and claim some work experience for the next interview.
- mitchdoogle 6y agoHas this changed recently? When I was in school, seemed like most internship opportunities I found were unpaid. There was some deal where it would count as college credit. Now don't try to tell me college credit counts as being paid
- virtue3 6y agoThe only way to have unpaid interns is if they are receiving college credits I believe. > Unpaid internships are legal if the intern is the "primary beneficiary" of the arrangement. This is determined by the seven-point Primary Beneficiary Test. https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/15161-are-unpaid-internships-legal.html https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/15161-are-unpaid-internshi...
- coderintherye 6y agoYes, things changed in 2010, this is the best summary I could find of it: https://www.commlawcenter.com/2018/01/confused-paying-interns-rules-just-changed.html https://www.commlawcenter.com/2018/01/confused-paying-intern... That said, the interpretation changed some in 2015 and again n 2018. Here is the Department of Labor's "test" on whether or not you can provide unpaid internships: https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/71-flsa-internships https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/71-flsa-interns... That's federal, but some states have stricter laws.
- skipants 6y agoThis has to be the fault of the organization. _Every_ intern!? I've worked at places where the onboarding was generally terrible and I'd still say 80% of the co-op interns we hired were value-positive. Although, when I do reflect on it, I suppose there was a lot we did right: - always willing to help newcomers - answering their questions - knowing when not to answer questions and let them learn through failure instead - reassuring them through mistakes (and just being positive overall) - checking in on them once in awhile But none of these things take any sort of preparation. It's all just cultural. > Amazingly many seemed to have a very high opinion of their productivity. Well, you could be correct. I've definitely seen the situation where developers have a reputation that I know first-hand through their work isn't merited. It could also be that maybe your standards are just a little too high for what you expect people right out of (or still in) college.
- munk-a 6y agoEven very senior developers are usually a negative value on a company for at least three weeks. There's usually a week for environment setup with any local tools being configured for the user and it's only after that that the best devs can hit the ground running and actually start comprehending the system, but that comprehension should come at consulting peers (if the new guy isn't asking any questions it's because they aren't doing any work) and by 1.5 weeks I expect someone to actually start adding value - with the net loss being paid out by week three. But that's for a Senior or Principle dev - for intermediary devs I wouldn't expect positive gain for the company for a good two months and junior devs tend to be more expensive with that training phase lasting for something like six weeks. Interns are a loss for companies - but please don't stop hiring them, you'll get some great employees out of the process and you're also investing in developing better communication and mentorship skills for your long term employees. As someone working at a company that was teensy tiny when I started this latter point is quite important - I actively invest in my skills to keep up with the curve and make sure I'm still providing as much value as is reasonable for my position. If I had been locked away to dev code in isolation when I was hired I'd be super rusty at a lot of skills that provide my employer real value.
- skipants 6y ago
- smichel17 6y agoThere's two ways to look at this. One is, "Is hiring an intern a net profit?" The other is, "Is the intern's work, minus the cost of mentorship, a net profit?" When I was in college, I did a paid internship at a health insurance company, wherein I audited, documented, and updated requirements for a large SQL script that pulled data from hospitals and used it to calculate reimbursement for Medicare/Medicaid claims (RAPS). Basically, you have to map hospital billing codes to federal ones. The script was written several years prior by my mentor, and the risk adjustment department had no visibility into how the codes were mapped -- and if it was wrong, we could be fined up to ~$10M (depending on severity), or be missing out on ~$1M in revenue. (It turned out my mentor had done a pretty good job and we only needed minor adjustments, although we also updated the architecture so the risk adjustment folks could define the mapping themselves going forward.) So in short, I can definitively state that 1) it would have cost the company less for my mentor to do the work directly. 2) The several thousands of dollars that the company spent between my salary and my mentor's was definitely worth the millions in mitigated risk/liability. 3) My mentor enjoyed teaching me much more than he would have enjoyed doing the work himself. And I'd like to think that I ended up doing a slightly more thorough job than my mentor might have done -- his long tenure at the company and accumulated knowledge of these sorts of scripts being job security of some sort ;) Anyway, the point here is that internships don't have to be a zero sum game. They can cost more than paying your existing employees to do the same work, and still be valuable.
- lhorie 6y agoI've had very positive experience with interns. We'd recruit from U Waterloo, gradually get them up to speed on real meaningful work, and a few months later when they graduated, we'd instantly have fully trained connections who were more than happy to accept a full time position from us. We had good success with incremental training (getting people pursuing CS, who had at least passing knowledge of what programming is), spending a few initial hours on the bare minimum mechanical tasks that one would need to start working on tasks (e.g. how to enter and style static content, how to google, copy-paste from stackoverflow, the works), then gradually supplementing with actual meaty training via lunch-and-learn format, with the intent to bring everyone (including other full time employees) up to speed with the latest and greatest techniques and best practices.
- alistairSH 6y agoWhen I worked with interns they were all paid... but every one was more time and expense to work with than any value they provided. In weeks they accomplished what I could do in an afternoon, and we spent WAY more than an afternoon of work with them. I managed interns for years in my role as a UI development manager. The main reason to hire interns was as part of our hiring pipeline. It basically served as an extended interview. Any actual work they produced was a bonus. We were also able to keep interns on through the academic year (part-time), which made the time commitment even more worthwhile. The lack of productivity wasn't because they were interns - it was because they were new to the job. This did require flexibility around their school schedule, so instilling good communication habits early was necessary.
- reaperducer 6y agoevery one was more time and expense to work with than any value they provided. I've only had interns at one job, and I had a similar complaint. My boss told me that's exactly what's supposed to happen. He explained that they're not free labor. I'm supposed to be training the next generation of $my_profession, and if they're not getting in the way, I'm not letting them do enough to learn. I guess in some ways he was right. Many of the most valuable lessons I've learned at work have come through mistakes I've made. And probably a bunch when I was an intern all those years ago.
- duxup 6y agoThat's pretty much how I look at it. Working with them is just being a good part of the community.
- cbozeman 6y ago> I'm supposed to be training the next generation of $my_profession, and if they're not getting in the way, I'm not letting them do enough to learn. I had intended to say this myself. Computer programmers rarely train themselves. Very few of anything train themselves. Autodidacts who can become masters of <insert field here> are extremely rare, and even those that have that capability can still pick up a lot of information from someone with decades of experience. Our species seems to learn best through being taught by those with more experience than us.
- ska 6y ago> In weeks they accomplished what I could do in an afternoon, Somewhat like nearly every entry level engineer. You are right that "free labor" is a inept way to think about internships, but it's also true that its one of those things where returns are somewhat dependent on investment. A good internship program can get a lot of useful things done and also be useful to the interns. There is certainly variability, but typical interns can be productive withing the scope of their term. Great ones will outproduce some of your full timers. Biggest win is if you do it right you can make some great hires.
- dkersten 6y ago> But I don't know about this idea that interns are somehow a gateway to getting value out of people When I was in Uni, I did a 6 month paid internship. A year and a half later I joined the company and stayed for two years. When I left, there was still code that I wrote during my internship running in production. I'm sure the other staff could have done it faster and better than I did, but it was clearly good enough to keep 3.5 years after my internship ended.
- elteto 6y agoIf it took them weeks to do an afternoon’s worth of work then you either had a hiring quality problem, terrible mentoring and guidance, or both. Don’t blame it on the interns.
- zhdc1 6y agoI've had interns in both professional and an academic settings. I don't think I've every really run into a situation where a - good - intern wasn't at least as productive as their salary.
- mdoms 6y agoThat's not the point. You pay them because they're working. That's how things work in civilised countries.
- Bukhmanizer 6y agoIt all depends on the position and industry. In science a ton of menial data entry work is done by unpaid interns. Don’t get me started on my friends who work in fashion. Even in CS, we should strive to protect exploited workers in other industries.