6 ms·
Just because you are able to find someone desperate enough to take up your shitty offer doesn't mean it is the fair market at work. There's a reason labor laws,
by paxys 6y ago
Just because you are able to find someone desperate enough to take up your shitty offer doesn't mean it is the fair market at work. There's a reason labor laws, OSHA, minimum wage etc. exist. This is predatory, period.
The irony here is that they wouldn't be able to do this if they just wanted people to act as photographers, not actually take any photos, because the various actors unions wouldn't allow it. Even nameless extras make $10-$15/hr or more for the time they are required to be on set.
- StavrosK 6y agoDefinitely, but they'll also just get unusable photos.
- aantix 6y agoWhy would you assume they're desperate? If I took a gig like this, I'd be damn sure that: 1) I am included in the rolling credits, 2) I have several cameo shots within the show, 3) I can use thumbnails of my appearances within my own web site and 4) that I am able to use the show's logo and likeness to promote my own business. My site would lead off with : "Award winning photographer. You may have seen my work recently on the hit Netflix show, 'Love Is Blind'".
- skeeks 6y ago1) Nobody reads them. 2) nice, but not useful for further business. 3,4) maybe the contracts would disallow that.
- aantix 6y ago1) The credits? That's not the point. This isn't a hail mary hoping someone discovers you via rolling credits. It's a way of solidifying your role in this production - so that if someone double checks, did you really help in this production, you are accounted for. 2) Could be useful for future business. It's a display of authority if positioned right. Just like any good portfolio piece. 3,4) Then don't take the contract. With any business, you are trying to project trust, authority, quality. You could leverage this as such.
- therealchiko 6y agofair and fine but all of that can be achieved whilst one is fairly compensated too. It's not a "give here and we'll give you this extra" type of situation, they offered nothing in return because they want it for free, period
- EricE 6y agoSo self promotion has zero value just because you don’t think it does? Hubris much?
- lhorie 6y agoAs someone who's done work in a field where "work for credits" was a common occurrence (freelance web design), I can give some perspective about why this is bad: maybe _you_ got the gig and are able to brag about how you're a "award winning photographer", but the problem is that not only you start to attract more people wanting free work in exchange for exposure, but also, these people will also try to push that agenda onto others entering the field as well, compounding the mentality like cancer. It is predatory because there's a lot of insecure upstarts who _will_ believe that free work is par for the course, if someone tells them so while hanging a carrot in front of them. The inconvenient truth that exploiters want to misdirect from here is that your ability to negotiate all the things you mentioned is not negated by a clause to actually get paid _in addition_ to receiving exposure. Another little dirty secret: bylines in your website don't mean shit. The money comes from networking.
- aantix 6y agoDon't conflate all "work for credits" as being worthless. 'Love Is Blind' was "sampled by 30 million member households." If your business's demographic would be in a similar cohort as the show, then this work could be used to project authority. I know of this show. My wife does. If a local photographer demonstrated that they were in the show, their work is great, I would find them interesting. I wouldn't blindly give them my business, but at least they don't blend in like 100's of other photographers. If you can't envision exactly how you would use this as a promotional piece or blindly expect that just by doing the work you'd get a magical windfall of additional business, then this isn't for you. Don't sign. >Another little dirty secret: bylines in your website don't mean shit. The money comes from networking. Empty bylines? Sure. But a byline that states your competency and goes on to display that competency by supporting it with 1) beautiful work and 2) having well known clients? That helps to solidify the case of why they should work with you. "Feel free to reach out to any of my previous clients. I will give you their contact info if you need a reference or two before working together. "
- lhorie 6y agoI was doing work for household names such as Sony and Pfizer when I got a call from some dude who wanted to implement some Facebook + Youtube grand idea for $1k and "I could put my name at the bottom". Admittedly, this merely falls in the realm of "annoying waste of time", but alas, reputation can haunt you in unexpected ways and the point is you want to cultivate networking prospects that actually provide real hard income, not low quality ones that think they can hustle you at every corner. Our company actually got paid big bucks to work on these household name projects and they used the portfolio to full advantage to land new contracts. But here's the key thing: there was a business development team reaching out to prospective clients and putting blood and sweat into presentations and proposals. At one point, leadership decided that they were going to try the "let our brand/portfolio speak for itself" idea (which amounts to the same as expecting credits to do the work for you), and in the next town hall meeting, they were very clear that that was the worst idea they had ever tried in the history of the business. So, sure, having a recognizable brand under your belt can serve as leverage, but as they say, a large number times zero is still zero. If a single high profile thing is the only crutch in your portfolio, or if the description of responsibilities looks inflated, people will notice that you're a one trick pony. You're still going to have to invest the time to build a proper network and reputation if you expect to be on fast-dial for household name projects.
- g_sch 6y agoIf you're accepting an offer to work for free for a major company, why do you think you'd have enough leverage to negotiate those other things?
- devindotcom 6y agoGoing with your own logic here, you're just in the middle on a race to the bottom. The show would reject your offer for someone desperate who would not make any such demands. The producers are dictating the terms here, they are completely in control.
- wtetzner 6y ago> "Award winning photographer. You may have seen my work recently on the hit Netflix show, 'Love Is Blind'". Don't you first need to win an award?
- aantix 6y agoIf I were a photographer, I wouldn't expect anything less from myself.
- TigeriusKirk 6y agoThey may or may not get in the credits, but I'd bet against them getting any of the other items on this list.
- anm89 6y agoClever switchout of the word "free market" here for "fair market". This is certainly for better or worse free market. I have never heard of the concept of a "fair market" beyond what any given person considers fair on a case by case basis.
- paxys 6y agoA market isn't free unless it is also fair. Have you never heard of terms like "fair market value" before? Why do governments worldwide spend time and money regulating markets? Why do antitrust laws exist?
- anm89 6y agohttps://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/freemarket.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/freemarket.asp > 200 https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/fairmarket.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/fairmarket.asp > 404 Free market is something like a technical term with a generally accepted definition within economics (sure you could squabble about the details of this definition) Fair Market value is a saying that means you got what something is worth. Semantically you would break it up as (fair) (market value) not (fair market) (value). There is no implied shared definition of a fair market in an economic sense and that phrase is not implying that the sale was done in the context of a subjectively ethically "fair" circumstance. I think you are well aware of this though.