6 ms·
I used to think this, but this book convinced me otherwise: https://www.wiley.com/en-us/Making+Climate+Policy+Work-p-9781509541805 https://www.wiley.com/en-us/
by epistasis 6y ago
I used to think this, but this book convinced me otherwise:
https://www.wiley.com/en-us/Making+Climate+Policy+Work-p-9781509541805 https://www.wiley.com/en-us/Making+Climate+Policy+Work-p-978...
If we treat all industry as spherical cows, a common carbon price comes out as a great way to incentivize industrial change.
However, once we get into the particulars of different industries and the varying levels of difficulty they have in decarbonizing, and the very different levels of lobbying power they have to influence that price, and the difficult of enforcement across different sectors, a common shared policy across all sectors starts to be far less efficient than tailoring the solution to each industry.
For example, steel is pure commodity, very difficult to eat any cost from stranded assets, and has far less ability to call up capital to solve the problem than, say, natural gas. So the price will have hugely different consequences for steel than natural gas production, and there are different tailored industrial policies that will make the transition happen much more time- and cost-efficiently.
- whazor 6y agoI think we also need trade agreements to consider carbon tax, otherwise you would have unfair competition.
- angry_octet 6y agoThe current systmt is really distorted. Coal from Germany/Australia/US is taxed differently to coal from China/Indonesia. Products made from brown coal energy in China are untaxed. Chinese steel production using coal from Australia results in Australia having a carbon debt, but not China. If a ship is made with Chinese steel, no tax. Made with American/EU steel? Taxes. If a ship burns the filthiest high sulphur bunker oil then it pays no more tax than a sail boat. We can't fix climate change with exceptions for everyone.
- thinkcontext 6y agoA carbon border price was in Biden's campaign platform and it would be one of the best political moves he could make. US industry has a big advantage in carbon intensity over China, so a price would advantage domestic industry and at the same time put pressure on China to clean up faster. Both of these are big political problems for Biden.
- NumberWangMan 6y agoI'm not sure I understand. Wouldn't that mean that steel producers just end up passing on more of the cost to consumers in the form of higher prices, resulting in reduced steel consumption? It sounds like a tax would work fine. By the way, I'm working on the assumption of a carbon price applied on fossil fuels at the source, such as the Energy Innovation Act would include.
- asdff 6y agoConsumption would only be reduced for industries that have a viable alternative. Maybe you can replace steel for some applications, but not all, and for those the costs will be passed on to the consumer who will bear this tax and will have no alternative on the market.
- cwkoss 6y agoI think that's the point of the carbon tax. That customers will feel price pressure from their most-carbon-emitting activities and commodities is precisely the point. This will encourage finding alternatives. No demand is entirely inelastic.
- dahfizz 6y agoThe argument isn't that this wouldn't work, its that this would be sub-optimal. Squeezing extra tax out of poor people who have literally no alternative is not going to be a popular plan. Allowing for a hint of nuance in your public policy would incentivize switching to alternatives where possible, while also incentivizing the development and adoption of alternatives where they don't currently exist.
- cwkoss 6y ago> Allowing for a hint of nuance in your public policy I am highly skeptical that is it possible for American legislation's 'nuance' to tilt a simple tax law in any direction but towards enriching the rich and powerful. I feel like carve outs would be great for lobbyists and the politicians they pay patronage to, but it would destroy the effectiveness of the carbon tax: the industries with enough political power would negotiate exemptions because "there are no economically feasible alternatives" but making carbon-expensive activity economically infeasible is the core purpose or the carbon tax. Exempting any industry in particular is just corruption.
- YPCrumble 6y agoYou claim that “the price will have hugely different consequences for steel than natural gas production” as if that’s a problem so big that we should agree with you that a carbon tax is not a great solution. Why is that so bad - isn’t raising the price of steel exactly what a carbon tax should do?
- dmlerner 6y agoI think the idea is that the steel/gas price changes would be disproportionate to their real carbon uses.
- ahmedalsudani 6y agoHow would that happen? If the price is set on carbon, I’d expect it to be proportionate.
- zamadatix 6y agoI'll have to read the book because I thought this was actually the strength of the method not a weakness - that difficulty to decarbonize means it'll either push alternatives that are easier to into the market or allow the market to pay the cost to do the difficult changes in the most efficient way it can find.
- v77 6y agoThis is the reality of carbon taxes as implemented in some Western European countries and Canada. A generic tax that applies to a limited set of activities then a sector-by-sector specific plan for most large industries depending on a lot of factors.
- rthomas6 6y agoHere's the thing. Nobody wants to admit that solving climate change will involve reducing the standard of living of a lot of people. Some things will be more expensive, and people will consume less. If you think about it, without massive technological innovation, how could it be any other way?
- epistasis 6y agoThey don't want to admit it because it's not clear it's true. Except perhaps for cars, because we need to drastically reduce vehicle miles travelled as we can't swap out our fleet fast enough and transportation miles are the biggest, hardest to solve sector of US emissions. Personally, if regulations allowed more living without cars, I think we would all have massively higher quality of life. The suburban lifestyle of living on a tiny island that can only be left with a car has drastically reduced most people's health, left them isolated, and has effects like making it so kids no longer play in streets. Allowing more people to live in neighborhoods where their daily errands and school drop offs could be met by short walking or biking trips would drastically improve their quality of life, instead of piling the family into the SUV and spending hours in traffic everyday. For the rest of the word, we are having that massive technological innovation right now that will increase quality of life globally. For electrifying the developing world, micro grids with renewables and storage will be immensely cheaper than building our massive transmission grids and large centralized production. Industrial sectors have the least clear path to decarbonizations, as well as sea-freight and flight, but if we can solve electricity and transportation in the next decade we have a few years so solve these far smaller sources of emissions. There is a lot of reason to be worried, but there's also a ton of reasons to be hopeful. GDP is already decoupling from emissions, and I think as we decouple it further, we will find a higher quality of life for the vast majority of people, both in developed or developing nations.
- rthomas6 6y agoIt's not going to be a dystopia, and yes, urban design/zoning in the US is absolutely terrible. I hate it. I could rant about it for hours. But if we have to drastically reduce ground freight and shipping emissions to reduce co2 emissions enough, which we do, goods will be more expensive. And it's also not free to switch private cars to EVs. If goods in general are more expensive, then peoples' money goes less far. To be clear, I am in favor of this. Maybe you can make the very wealthy eat the cost, but somebody has to pay for it, and I can't see how it doesn't result in lower mean quality of life.
- Ericson2314 6y agoI suppose I should really read the book. But I am suspicious. To me having a carbon tax emphatically does not mean embracing some "capitalism solves all problems" ideology. Direct intervention is still needed, but direct intervention works best in conjunction with carbon taxes. You don't want the market trying to "route around" your direct intervention because there is no incentive to play ball. See https://rooseveltinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/RI_GND_policy-brief-carbon-CD.pdf https://rooseveltinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/RI... for more of that. If anything, it's actually this sort of nuclear subsidy that could be too hands off --- if it's like a 1990s throw money at ISPs for fibre with no strings attached tpye thing. I would say Carbon tax and nationalize the nukes.
- specialist 6y agoBook criticizes failed market based efforts. (Duh.) Carbon pricing is a tax, not a market solution. (Right?) Further, most recently, carbon pricing policy proposals have been decoupling price from impacts, in recognition that good policy accommodates good politics. So it seems to me the authors of carbon pricing proposals agree with this book, and pivoted accordingly.