4 ms·
Considering the history of the meat industry, I'm OK with not allowing the farms to police themselves.
by reaperducer 6y ago
Considering the history of the meat industry, I'm OK with not allowing the farms to police themselves.
- jtdev 6y agoConsidering the history of the USDA, I’m not okay with the USDA having final say in determining what I or my family put on the dinner table.
- NationalPark 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Department_of_Agriculture#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Department_of_Ag... This?
- jtdev 6y agoNo, I'm referring to the regulatory capture and revolving door culture at USDA that has allowed Monsanto et. al., to douse your kids cereal with glyphosate, refuse hemp production in the U.S., water down the Organic Governance Board with corporate shills, etc., etc.
- macksd 6y agoI think there's a pretty fundamental difference between "allowing farms to police themselves" and actually prohibiting them from doing voluntary testing for diseases. I would compare it to the difference between eliminating a need for prescriptions and prohibiting people from getting screened for skin cancer on the regular. Is there a better reason to prohibit voluntary testing than what is included in the article?
- rapind 6y agoAre they being prohibited from testing though, or just prohibited from making safety claims based on those tests?
- CryptoPunk 6y agoProhibited from testing.
- shkkmo 6y agoThat isn't what is happening. The USDA is prohibiting suplemental testing. The allegation is that this is because that might reveal cases of infection that would show the USDA testing policies are not sufficient. Thus the USDA is placing their reputation over the health of US citizens.
- vkou 6y agoAnother poster makes the argument that the USDA does not prohibit supplemental testing, it just prohibits making safety claims on the basis of supplemental testing. I find their argument far more persuasive than yours. Is there more to yours?
- shkkmo 6y agoThe persuasivity of an argument does not guarantee its truthfulness. There are plenty of sources, including court documents, that verify that the USDA was trying to prevent private testing, not just claims being made on the basisnof private testing. The ban on testing was justified by the USDA based on the potential for safety claims, but the ban itself was on testing. I don't personally buy the argument, if the US testing was sufficient to guarantee safety I see no consumer harm in allowing additional (potentially ineffective) testing that could help a US producer satisfy other countries' import controls.
- mannerheim 6y agoCreekstone specifically argued for its use for marketing purposes:[0] > Creekstone claims to have suffered $200,000 per day in lost revenue as a result of the diminished export market. Stewart Decl. ¶ 17. Moreover, in markets where U.S. beef is available, Creekstone contends that consumer fears about BSE have diminished its sales. See Id. ¶¶ 4, 5 (discussing market surveys in Japan and U.S.). To allay the concerns of consumers and importers, in 2004 Creekstone made a “business decision” to perform the rapid BSE test on each cow it slaughters. ... USDA memorialized its decision to deny Creekstone permission to purchase rapid BSE test kits from Bio-Rad in a June 1, 2004 letter, concluding that “allowing a company to use a BSE test in a private marketing program is inconsistent with USDA's mandate to ensure effective, scientifically sound testing for significant animal diseases and maintain domestic and international confidence in U.S. cattle and beef products.” Anyway, at the time of the decision, Japan was allowing US exports of beef (this was argued by the USDA in the district court, which they did not pursue on appeal), so their effort was purely a marketing one. For the record, Japan would subsequently go on to ban American beef again, before allowing imports of American beef once more in 2019, after they themselves had scaled back their BSE testing in 2017 to only symptomatic cows. Would the USDA have allowed Creekstone to use the test if they had said they were going to use it as part of an animal health monitoring measure, which is what the USDA's program is? Maybe, but obviously Creekstone wasn't using it for that purpose if they were wanting to test every cow, including cows for which the test could not possibly detect BSE even if they had it. [0]: https://www.animallaw.info/case/creekstone-farms-premium-beef-llc-v-department-agriculture https://www.animallaw.info/case/creekstone-farms-premium-bee...