5 ms·
What is your long term plan for what to do with all of the carbon dioxide we're putting into the atmosphere? Both are immense problems with immense dangers, bu
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
What is your long term plan for what to do with all of the carbon dioxide we're putting into the atmosphere?
Both are immense problems with immense dangers, but it seems to me that one is clearly easier to solve.
- moate 6y ago"Repair an entire planet's atmosphere" vs "store a few hundred tons of radioactive material safely" are definitely very different levels of problems. Not to mention the possibility that spent fuel could be of use to future generations for some kind of future science and it would all conveniently be in one place.
- EricE 6y agoor if you burn today’s “waste” in reactors that can easily do so, you not only don’t have to securely store it while also getting carbon neutral energy that will displace existing fossil fuel derived sources. Nuclear is predictable which means it’s perfect for base load generation. Something all the other “clean” technologies are not.
- metalliqaz 6y agoso we didn't plan for the problem in the past, so we shouldn't bother this time? that's pure whataboutism and not helpful
- nharada 6y agoThe urgency is different. You don't earthquake-proof your house while the living room is on fire.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoAn even more apt analogy might be: if your living room is on fire, you should dump water on it. You shouldn't let the fire rage because the water could damage the carpet.
- metalliqaz 6y agoit's not an apt analogy. We can do both! There's no reason that we can't legislate proper waste handling with the subsidies. No reason whatsoever.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoYou can either let the fire rage while you make a plan for how to repair the carpet, or you can pour the water now and deal with the carpet later. There is in fact a limit to how much you can get legislatures to do at once. I’m all for coming up with policies for nuclear waste, I just don’t think it should hold up the construction of reactors. The world is on fire.
- metalliqaz 6y agowhy fight so hard against even trying???
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoWe should try! But I think the logical end result of "we should do X hard thing before Y" will be that Y never gets done! It's almost like a form of bike shedding—except that the bike shed is in fact important, but its construction can trail launch, and launch is on a tight deadline.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]