3 ms·

I honestly wonder if there might be room in the market for a paid-membership search engine that included only a curated set of sites. You'd lose all the long-t

I honestly wonder if there might be room in the market for a paid-membership search engine that included only a curated set of sites. You'd lose all the long-tail quality stuff (e.g. my own write-only blog :P ), but also all the garbage. It might be worth it. I don't think you could kill Google with that, but it might make a viable lifestyle business. Edit: and I meant to add - I was looking for info on a specific Synology device the other day. Google turned up Synology's own website (good) and a zillion crappy affiliate-link-spam sites. eBay and Reddit were the best sources of info when I sighed and started constraining the search with site: prefixes.

kingsuper20 6y ago
>I honestly wonder if there might be room in the market for a paid-membership search engine that included only a curated set of sites. I know basically nothing of the mechanics of search, although I expect that a boutique search engine would have trouble accessing the guts of third party sites as they don't want to get hammered by the world. I did just think of an interesting specialty engine. If you had fast access to the full library on libgen or sci-hub, a person could produce a pretty interesting set of abilities.
- dcminter 6y ago
  I know enough to know I don't know much :) But there's plenty of documentation out there. My impression is that if you're not dealing with people trying to game the algorithm then it's all a lot simpler. As to data sources - with a constrained set of sites the creation of custom adapters should be do-able I'd have thought. Not that I have any plans. Maybe I should though :) Edit: come to think of it, it's practically an internet law that stuff you think of already exists. So maybe I should just post an Ask HN for the link to the search engine in question...
  - kingsuper20 6y ago
    An interesting meta-problem comes with success of a curated search engine. The sites it actually supports would themselves have to be curated as otherwise the camel's nose gets back into the tent.
    - dcminter 6y ago
      Yeah, exactly. Either not successful enough to game or... Nice problem to have? Maybe? (I have similar thoughts about diacussion fora fwiw)

kingsuper20 6y ago

>I honestly wonder if there might be room in the market for a paid-membership search engine that included only a curated set of sites. I know basically nothing of the mechanics of search, although I expect that a boutique search engine would have trouble accessing the guts of third party sites as they don't want to get hammered by the world. I did just think of an interesting specialty engine. If you had fast access to the full library on libgen or sci-hub, a person could produce a pretty interesting set of abilities.

dcminter 6y ago
I know enough to know I don't know much :) But there's plenty of documentation out there. My impression is that if you're not dealing with people trying to game the algorithm then it's all a lot simpler. As to data sources - with a constrained set of sites the creation of custom adapters should be do-able I'd have thought. Not that I have any plans. Maybe I should though :) Edit: come to think of it, it's practically an internet law that stuff you think of already exists. So maybe I should just post an Ask HN for the link to the search engine in question...
- kingsuper20 6y ago
  An interesting meta-problem comes with success of a curated search engine. The sites it actually supports would themselves have to be curated as otherwise the camel's nose gets back into the tent.
  - dcminter 6y ago
    Yeah, exactly. Either not successful enough to game or... Nice problem to have? Maybe? (I have similar thoughts about diacussion fora fwiw)