4 ms·
> I believe that marketers should feel free to use those to measure the effectiveness of their campaigns I don't. I believe marketers should have exactly zero
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
> I believe that marketers should feel free to use those to measure the effectiveness of their campaigns
I don't. I believe marketers should have exactly zero ways to measure the effectiveness of their mind hacking efforts. Any data they try and collect should have negative value by virtue of being completely randomized by the browser.
Actually I believe marketers shouldn't even exist. Nothing they say is trustworthy by virtue of conflict of interest. The internet would be much better off without these constant attempts to subvert it for their purposes.
- sdevonoes 6y agoI agree. I don't think marketers are trustworthy: their sole purpose is to "hack" my mind in order to buy stuff, so sure it's a job someone has to do but if I can avoid marketers to get more data from me, I'm in.
- scottmcleod 6y agoYoure a troll. Where do you work? Bet you wouldn't have a job without marketers...
- kroltan 6y agoAd hominem and inconsequential, just because one is benefited by the existence of marketers does not mean they have to approve of their existence.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- HDMI_Cable 6y agoThat can be simplified even further: If their incentives don't align with mine at least tangentially, then I'm not using their product. Out goes marketers, social media, and most ads.
- myfavoritedog 6y ago... and I thought I was harsh with marketers. I don't want their calls, their unsolicited email, etc. I don't want them to have my personal information or be able to buy or sell my personal information. But I don't begrudge their ability to get word out for their product or service while funding content that I would otherwise get nickeled and dimed for or not have produced at all. Nothing they say is trustworthy by virtue of conflict of interest Everyone who says anything has that same conflict of interest. You do, I do, marketers do, salespeople do, engineers do, politicians do, scientists do. Completely dismissing value of an entire profession based upon self interest doesn't have a limiting principle. Marketing, even if you naively limit the term to just cover advertising, is a rich and useful function of capitalism and society in general. The key to dealing with it is in protecting basic freedoms like a right to privacy.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> But I don't begrudge their ability to get word out for their product or service I do because in 99% of cases it's a deliberate waste of my time and attention. > Everyone who says anything has that same conflict of interest. I don't think so. The information I receive from friends and peers is far more trustworthy. With marketing, I get selective truths at best. Lots and lots of people on this site admit to adding "reddit" to their searches when looking for product reviews. Why? Because they don't trust marketers. We want real information from real people with real experiences, not some paid-for narrative. We especially want to know the risks, the negatives and the cons, precisely the kind of information marketers want to bury.
- anticristi 6y agoSo how did your peers find out about robot vacuum cleaners, mobile phones, etc.? I guess you'll answer from their peer. And those? Since ads need to be conspecious by law, I don't see a conflict of interest. We know this is a carefully crafted story of the person who has stakes in the product or service.
- schwinn140 6y agoWow, thats a bit much. Think of your favorite site with the best experience possible. That is possible because people tested countless times what works, what didn't, what is the most efficient path to a rewarding UX, and so on. Yes, there are a ton of garbage lazy marketers in the world. Saying that marketing shouldn't exist would immediately render every refined UX you have navigated, purchased from, and or loyally stream content from. Throwing out the good because of the bad is too far of a reach IMO. Anywho, that's just little old me and my opinion doesn't mean much.
- leipert 6y agoI disagree. You can improve your product without the extensive use of trackers, especially external ones. Hire UX and PM that know what they are doing, do UX research, talk to your customers, do competitive analysis. Just accruing swaths of data doesn’t help, you need to interpret it correctly. I think qualitative data will bring you a long way. Once you need to do A/B testing, you can also do it privacy friendly. If you market your product and run a campaign? Why not offer discount codes or something to figure out how you got them.
- schwinn140 6y agoHow do you think a UX person knows what works? It's not that they were born jedi's worthy of understanding good design and human intuition. They test, test, test, and you know what...they tested more. Tracking what button or page layout works better from a conversion perspective is not a privacy issue. It's a user experience benefit. Having a SaaS business and not understanding the exact user funnel, conversion, abandonment, etc. will directly translate into a loss of your job and/or the failure of your business. This isn't about personal preference which you have every right to. This is about building a business, which is why we're all here, and understanding how to successfully delight our customers.
- Seirdy 6y ago> Think of your favorite site with the best experience possible. That is possible because people tested countless times what works, what didn't, what is the most efficient path to a rewarding UX, and so on. Funny; those kinds of sites are my least favorite. All those colors and buttons are an information overload, and the animations make my laptop fans spin like crazy. Not everyone bought their computer under a decade ago. Please, blue links and black text aren't evil. We need to make interfaces functional and stop rather than continuously A/B test them to maximize addictiveness ("engagement").