6 ms·
Pencil Project – open-source GUI prototyping tool
- flakiness 6y agoThe code is here: https://github.com/evolus/pencil https://github.com/evolus/pencil It is based on Electron. The last commit was 1.5 years ago.
- darkwinx 6y agoThe last commit in the "development" branch was 2 days ago.
- RobertRoberts 6y agoThe lack of basic website maintenance makes this project appear abandoned. Their stencils and templates a _very_ old.[0] [0] https://pencil.evolus.vn/Stencils-Templates.html https://pencil.evolus.vn/Stencils-Templates.html
- sbarre 6y agoI noticed the same.. That said, it is an open source project and likely relies on individuals volunteering their time for such things.
- flakiness 6y agoGood catch! They seems to follow the git-flow model? https://github.com/evolus/pencil/commits/development https://github.com/evolus/pencil/commits/development Not that active anyway, but yeah.
- blacksoil 6y agoI was using this a lot. Pretty good and no-nonsense :)
- PencilUser1234 6y agoI've used Pencil and had good results.
- dopeboy 6y agoPencil is fantastic and I used it many times for visualizing architecture. It's one of the few good diagramming tools available on Linux. I think I've donated a couple times to support them. That said, portability and collaboration are important to me which has drawn me to cloud solutions like draw.io.
- fellowniusmonk 6y agoIs this that same project that only ran on old versions of firefox for awhile? It's was such a great free tool, glad to see it still kicking around.
- vbsteven 6y agoThe github readme mentions that it used to be built on top of the old Mozilla XUL stuff but recently switched over to Electron. That's probably why it only ran on old FF.
- BiteCode_dev 6y agoI liked it but last time I used it it crashed a lot. Was years ago though.
- sandebert 6y agoI used this for a couple of years, way back. Grew tired of bugs and limitations, found WireframeSketcher and haven't looked back since. https://wireframesketcher.com/ https://wireframesketcher.com/
- Steer 6y agoI had the same experience with Pencil, but switched to the desktop version of Draw.io https://github.com/jgraph/drawio-desktop/ https://github.com/jgraph/drawio-desktop/ which I really like and recommend.
- deergomoo 6y agodraw.io is great for flowcharts and similar diagrams, but every time I've tried to mock up UIs with it I quickly find myself spending 90% of my time fighting snapping and being unable to do precise movements. Perhaps it's just me not knowing how to use it properly.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoLooking at the page, the prototypes may be too realistic. https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/02/13/the-iceberg-secret-revealed/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/02/13/the-iceberg-secret...
- Terretta 6y agoBig fan of the sketches-only approach for those reasons, but more for getting the "client" to engage on usability and functionality before trying to nail look. Hard to find fully convincing sketch only tools, but do have a decent set of sketch style templates and stencils for Omni Graffle on MacOS (such as Konigi's sketch stencils: https://konigi.com/blog/omnigraffle-sketch-stencils-now-available/ https://konigi.com/blog/omnigraffle-sketch-stencils-now-avai... ) along with a subset of not-quite-architectural handwriting fonts. With sketches the feedback from users, managers, stakeholders, and clients, is much more substantive and on track for iterating usability and flow. // Flow feel requires clickable sketches, think Balsamiq at https://balsamiq.com/wireframes/ https://balsamiq.com/wireframes/, but sketchier.
- dikei 6y agoI used to use Pencil back in college, when it was still based on XULRunner, not Electron. It's a pity that the tool hasn't gained much traction in the mean time.
- enumjorge 6y ago> It's a pity that the tool hasn't gained much traction in the mean time. The project’s very rough looking website is not helping. It’s hard to take a GUI tool seriously when your features page includes 90s style “clip art” as one of its billet points. I hate saying something negative about an open source project since it’s usually someone’s unpaid work, but if they want more traction, they’ll need help from someone with some design chops.
- victornomad 6y agoPenpot is really amazing https://penpot.app https://penpot.app Similar to Sketch or Figma but Open Source https://github.com/penpot/penpot https://github.com/penpot/penpot Have a try if you haven't! I wish one day I could replace my Figma workflows
- antonlopezr 6y agoPenpot looks incredible! I am super curious about design tools such as these but I have very little experience in the field. What is the workflow to get a design made with these working as a proper web or application? Even some pointers would be great. Sorry if the question is very basic. Cheers!
- capableweb 6y agoThe usual flow is something like: - Someone come up with what something should do when X - Designers create the UX and UI to support that feature - Developers start reviewing the UX/UI, create a list of things designers/product managers forgot to think of when doing the design/product requirements - Designers finishes the design - Developers manually try to copy the design into code. How this happen depends a lot In 90% of the companies, this is how I've seen it being done. Some places are trying to make that last step automatic nowadays, but the progress and results are nowhere near production-ready yet. Let me know if you have more specific questions :)
- GordonS 6y agoWow, I've wanted something like this for literally years! Pencil is OK, but fiddly to use, lacking in stencils, and basically unmaintained. Figma is a really powerful tool, but is too expensive unless you're a full-time UI/UX person (in which case, it's actually a good deal). It's so great to have a powerful OSS prototyping tool - and one that looks like it's had thought put into it's own UI/UX. Can't wait to try this out and see if it meets my expectations, thanks so much for posting this!
- qwerty456127 6y agoVery cool but why do we have to use GUI "prototyping" (mockups) nowadays, why we can't compile a prototype straight into release code anymore like we did during the Delphi and WinForms days?
- flakiness 6y agoIt's mostly because of the job specialization - In a project, there is an engineer and there is a UX person. There are also UX-minded engineers and these people tend to skip the mock-up and just dive into the code. The semi-WYSIWYG editing in IDEs still aren't that bad.
- mhd 6y agoNote that "GUI" in this case can often mean "web page" and/or cross-platform mobile views. (Also because a company might up to three non-coding jobs being entangled in this mess before it even reaches a programmer.)
- spacemanmatt 6y agoExactly this. Giving non-developers a communication tool that lets them compile their needs into a form developers can work with rather directly is extremely valuable to organizations.
- robertlagrant 6y ago> why we can't compile a prototype straight into release code anymore like we did during the Delphi and WinForms days? You probably can if you're making something with zero styling for one version of one OS on a 640x480 non-touch screen in one language that can't be deeplinked into from other applications for people with no accessibility requirements.
- tl 6y agoOk, sure. Why can't we start with something that works with zero styling for one version of one OS on a [fixed resolution] non-touch screen in one language that can't be deeplinked into from other applications for [some people] and figure out if we're even building the right thing before we go "zOMG web-scale" and pretend we're making the next iPhone? I'd also argue that "zero styling" means "standard controls" which often already have good accessibility, and everything (including accessibility?) can be added (re-written in?) after you have a winner.
- mlvljr 6y agoLinks to the ZIPs on https://pencil.evolus.vn/Stencils-Templates.html https://pencil.evolus.vn/Stencils-Templates.html appear broken, folks.
- skohan 6y agoMaybe this is a great tool, but I'm a bit put off to use a UI-related tool from a site which looks like it was made in 2004
- debacle 6y agoPencil used to by my go-to tool, but over time it has slowly grown more complex and less useful. More recently, I am using Google Slides for quick GUI prototypes - if I need something more robust, I hire a designer, but my necessity for solid wireframes as a communication tool is low enough that it's not worth learning a new tool.