5 ms·
So this tilting is entirely for passenger comfort? When presented with "you can get there in 1 hour, but you can't put coffee on the table" or "it'll take 2 ho
by londons_explore 6y ago
So this tilting is entirely for passenger comfort?
When presented with "you can get there in 1 hour, but you can't put coffee on the table" or "it'll take 2 hours", do passengers really choose the latter?
A coffee cup is at risk of sliding off a table around 4.5 m s^-2, so much higher than discussed in this article. And coffee would definitely slide off a flat surface in most journeys by car - that's why cars have cup holders.
- flohofwoe 6y agoI have the opposite experience (very low "passenger comfort") in tilting trains, and I always thought that this is what actually killed them: I'm slightly suspectible to motion sickness (e.g. "normal" trains are fine, but sitting in the back seat of a car or in a bus can be a bit of a problem, especially when trying to read something). When I was on a tilting train once (maybe about 10 years ago? AFAIK they are no longer in use) the motion sickness kicked in pretty hard. PS: Interestingly, a tilted track (which seems to be quite usual now on newly built high speed tracks) doesn't affect me at all. I guess it was the general "wobbliness" of the tilt train.
- londons_explore 6y agoThere is no difference between tilted track and tilted train from what you can perceive from the passenger compartment, provided the tilt is done correctly. I suspect tilt angle was perhaps rounded/approximated/delayed, which would feel the same as if someone had laid the track rather haphazardly on a bog...
- pessimizer 6y agoNo difference in respect to acceleration, but I've heard that motion sickness is largely visual.
- labawi 6y agoAFAIU, the passenger compartment will indeed have identical angle and acceleration in both cases, as there is no other way to cancel lateral force. What is likely different is the stability of tilted tracks (reasonably easy to make nice continuous tilts and turns) and tilted train's uncannily small lateral force, while still having time and angle discrepancies and inferior smoothness causing very noticeable over and undershoots.
- CaptainZapp 6y agoSnag a middle seat instead of a window seat. This can help some with the motion sickness feeling
- HPsquared 6y agoAlso probably better in the middle of the carriage than the ends (near the centre of mass). I wonder if there's any significant difference between carriages?
- innocenat 6y agoThere are two main types of tilt: active and passive. Active tilt uses a computer, armed with track geometry knowledge, to control the tilt. Passive tilt is just the centrifugal force automatically tilting the train. The first one is very comfortable. The second is probably what you rode -- it's pretty bad.
- mhb 6y agoHave you tried boarding glasses? https://www.citroen.com/en/Highlight/55/citroen-launches-the-first-glasses-that-restore-the-taste-for-travel-seetroen https://www.citroen.com/en/Highlight/55/citroen-launches-the...
- StavrosK 6y agoIs this a prank? They can't be selling those things for 100 eur (or at all).
- mhb 6y agoThe price is crazy, but this idea has been around for quite a while. Here are some for 50 eur: https://en.boardingglasses.com/collections/frontpage https://en.boardingglasses.com/collections/frontpage. In three stylish colors!
- medstrom 6y agoHere in Sweden, the train company SJ had tilting trains for the 2000 model and abandoned the concept for the 3000 model, because passengers complained of discomfort, or so SJ said. A small speed boost is not worth tilting the train.
- Grustaf 6y agoI for one definitely find X2000 uncomfortable, I often take the slow train that takes an hour longer just to avoid the motion sickness.
- throwx2 6y agoAs a counter point, I’ve commuted daily with X2000 for a few years (except currently, of course). Much prefer it over 3000. Very occasionaly I can feel a little motion sickness. Once when the tilting was out of order a guy next to me did solitaire with a deck of cards. And then there was a bend, and all his cards ended up on the floor.. But I think it is a bit of an acquired taste.
- Grustaf 6y agoI didn’t even know about x3000 actually, maybe I’ve taken it unknowingly!
- HPsquared 6y agoThe 4.5 m/s^2 is static friction. Trains jostle and wobble in addition to the steady lateral acceleration of cornering, which would help break the static friction.
- tuukkah 6y agoThe tilting causes discomfort. From the article: "In fact the Pendolino had to limit the tilt just to make sure passengers would feel some lateral acceleration, because it was capable of reducing the carbody centrifugal force to zero and this led to motion sickness as passengers saw the horizon rise and fall without any centrifugal force giving motion cues."
- philjohn 6y agoI'm unable to look at a screen on a Pendolino for that reason, I need to be looking out of the window.
- gregoriol 6y agoMaybe they could replace the windows with giant screens and adjust the horizon?
- usr1106 6y ago> The tilting causes discomfort. True. I regulary used Finnish Pendolinos over 10 years ago and it was a pretty wobbly experience. Nowadays they run with tilting disabled and I had nearly forgotten about it. Until I travelled on a Swedish X2000 many years later and immediately felt it again. Maybe a bit less wobbly, but pulling you "into the wrong direction" in a more determined way. Not really pleasant and I can easily believe people getting "sea-sick" especially when working on a laptop. However, without tilting and the same speed the sensation might be worse. I guess we don't know, because without tilting they reduce the speed in curves.
- Avshalom 6y agoTilting here means getting the carriage to lean into the turn so it's both more comfortable and faster. The article is a little confusing because it never actually shows a diagram of a tilted train. That second picture is for the normal case where centrifugal force and normal suspension makes the carriage lean away from the turn, which means the center of gravity and the resultant force move out making the whole thing less stable.
- twobitshifter 6y agoSpeed limits are set for passenger comfort rather than the fastest speed a train could safely travel. The equation for the speed limit for a curve is a combination of the radius of the curve, the relative elevation of the outside rail (superelevation) and the allowable “unbalanced superelevation” of the train itself, how much lateral force the train is permitted to have going around the curve. You could design a railroad where the outside rail was raised enough to not feel any lateral forces effects of curves, but speeds will be much lower. Typical trains have 3 or 4 inches of unbalanced superelevation, but a tilting train can drive this number much higher to 7 to 9 inches. This allows faster speeds and maintains passenger comfort.
- iggldiggl 6y ago3 or 4 inches seems a tad on the low side, but then again I remember somebody giving an example of a US tilting train being barely faster than a conventional European train on a similar curve due to more conservative standards prevailing across the pond. In Germany, up to ~5" (130 mm) are permissible on the main line network. In theory and exceptionally, even values up to 6" (150 mm) are possible, although haven't really been used in practice so far as far as I know. The maximum speed for trams/streetcars/light rail is often based on a maximum deficiency of 150 mm, too. Tilting trains in Germany can use up to ~12" (300 mm) of cant deficiency, but then again in Germany they really seem a dead end so far.
- bobthepanda 6y agoUsually tilting is used to turn a 5 hour journey into 4, or 4 into 3. An extra hour will definitely convince some of your passengers they may be better off taking the hourlong hop in a plane; the entire value proposition of a high speed train is convenience and comfort. It also doesn't necessarily have to slide off a table. There is an ad for the '70s tilting APT in which the person lauding the train has a cup of tea on the table and it's just sloshing out of the cup, which is at best making a mess and losing drink you paid for, and at worst some inconveniently placed burns on your lap.